Begging conventionally framed
Confusion in Exchanging “Something” for “Nothing” (Part #2)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
As noted by Philip Lynch (Understanding and responding to begging (Australia). Melbourne University Law Review, 2005):
Begging, or gathering alms, can be defined as the solicitation of a voluntary unilateral gift -- most often money -- in a public place. begging encompasses various begging categories or 'techniques', including 'passive begging' (that is, sitting or standing in one place with a sign and/or a receptacle entreating donations), 'active begging' (that is, approaching people in a public place and asking them for money or other gifts) and 'aggressive begging' (that is, following or asking a person threateningly or repeatedly for money or other gifts)
Ian Stead (Begging, Politics.co.uk, August 2010
Begging is the solicitation of money or food, especially in the street. There is a close relationship between begging and homelessness and homeless charity Crisis estimates that over 80 per cent of beggars are homeless. People who beg are among the most vulnerable in society, often trapped in poverty and deprivation, and it is regarded as a risky and demeaning activity.
Begging is visible on the streets of many British towns and most of the public report seeing someone begging in a public place at least once a week. Research carried out by the University of Glasgow found that begging was overwhelmingly driven by need rather than greed, although the apparently increasing prevalence of begging is coupled with an increasing perception that beggars, rather than being homeless and hungry, use the money they receive to support their addiction to drugs or alcohol.
Extensive resources on begging, termed panhandling in the USA, are indicated in a fact sheet from the US Center for Problem-Oriented Policing (Michael S. Scott, Panhandling, 2002). "Panhandlers" are variously referred to as "beggars," "vagrants," "vagabonds," "mendicants," or "cadgers." The guide also covers nearly equivalent conduct in which, in exchange for donations, people perform nominal labor such as squeegeeing (cleaning) the windshields of cars stopped in traffic, holding car doors open, saving parking spaces, guarding parked cars, buying subway tokens, and carrying luggage or groceries.
After reviewing factors that contribute to it, the guide identifies a series of questions that help in analyzing the problem, before reviewing responses to it, and what is known about the effectiveness of those responses from evaluative research and police practice. It distinguishes two types of panhandling: passive and aggressive. Passive panhandling is soliciting without threat or menace, often without any words exchanged at all -- just a cup or a hand held out. Aggressive panhandling is soliciting coercively, with actual or implied threats, or menacing actions. If a panhandler uses physical force or extremely aggressive actions, the panhandling may constitute robbery.
Jabir Hasan Khan and Menka and Nisar Ahmed (Regional analysis of various places of begging, International Journal of Development Research, 2013) ***:
The problem of begging is a universal phenomenon but it is more pronounced in developing nations. The only difference between the begging system of the western countries and in the case of India is the way of begging. Beggars get money in developed countries by performing their arts and skills but in India they are getting money only on the basis of sympathy or on the mercy of society. They are found everywhere in public places, such as filling stations, restaurants, banks, super markets, mosques, churches, etc. Moreover, deviant behaviors such as theft, thuggery, violent and criminal behavior, and vandalism are listed as some of the vices associated with street begging.... [It is argued that] since begging is a behavior in conflict with the ethical principles of the society, it should be considered as preventive/deterrent crimes.... considering it as a crime, is not logically justifiable and its range should be limited by no criminal and preventive actions. However, begging has been a traditional profession in India as charity is considered one of the noblest of human virtues according to Hindu tradition ...
Beggars request food, money, clothing and other items from passersby. They have many reasons for asking for assistance and can be found in many locations worldwide. Beggars tend to present a negative image of a particular location. The presence of beggars is perceived to be indicative of larger social ills or issues and can cause others to avoid beggar-inhabited areas....
Given the relation to homelessness, there is recognition that the feeling of humiliation and being regarded as a 'low-life'' were recurring themes in the self-perception of those begging (Lynch, 2005). The situation is complicated by a degree of recognition of associated abuses. There is an associated frustration with begging and the encounter with beggars, as indicated by the following:
- Florence Horsman-Hogan: When the begging hands push us too far. The Independent, 5 April 2009
- Isabel Wilkerson: Shift in Feelings on the Homeless: empathy turns into frustration, New York Times, 2 September 1991
- Sarah Ferguson: Us versus Them: America's growing frustration with the homeless, Utne Reader, 1990, September/October
- Nancy R. Gibbs: Begging: to give or not to give: with panhandlers at every corner, people are running out of patience -- and change, Time, 5 September 1988
- Lynne Sharow Schwartz: Beggaring Our Better Selves: the tug of the outstretched hand, day after day, Harper's Magazine, December 1991
This results in arguments opposing any donation (Kerry Kubilius, Before You Give: Beggars in Eastern Europe, about.com; Ole Martin Moen, Don't Give Money to Beggars, Practical Ethics, 22 September 2012).
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
Subjects: Disadvantaged