Imaginable aesthetic enactivism?


Evoking Castalia as Envisaged, Entoned and Embodied (Part #2)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]


"Poetizing"? The possibility would be consistent with the argument of Martin Heidegger (Introduction to Philosophy -- Thinking and Poetizing, 2011), variously reviewed (Frank Scalambrino, Philosophy in Review, 33, 2013, 4; Katherine Withy, Philosophical Reviews, 2011). The latter notes Heidegger's effort at reconciliation:

Our guides in this course are Nietzsche, the poetizing thinker of homelessness, and Hölderlin, the thoughtful poet of homecoming. An encounter with Nietzsche's poetizing thinking and with Hölderlin's thinking poetizing will guide us towards a dwelling in our essence....Heidegger privileges Nietzsche and Hölderlin in this text for several reasons. First, in each (yet in different ways), "poetizing and thinking are interwoven with one another in a single and wondrous way" (p. 13). Second, according to Heidegger, such interweaving has been seen before only at the beginning of the Western philosophical tradition -- in Plato and Parmenides, Pindar and Sophocles (pp. 6, 14). That we see it again now in Nietzsche and Hölderlin shows that this tradition has been completed. Thus a world-historical and philosophical necessity governs the interweaving of philosophy and poetry in these two figures.

Since that time a trace of a new understanding of poetizing is now cultivated through the term autopoiesis -- clearly derived from poiesis -- recognized by science as the self-maintaining capacity of a complex living system. This implies the possibility that sustainability, as the "holy grail" of current governance, might be best comprehended through poetry in some way -- through aesthetics (In Quest of Sustainability as Holy Grail of Global Governance, 2011).

"Rhetoric"? The current crises of governance -- globally, nationally and locally -- are marked by politically inspired speechifying of every kind, with very little indication that this is inspiring more coherent initiatives. There is an increasingly desperate quest for approaches that are widely attractive, meaningfully credible, as well as capable of enabling viable global connectivity (Imagining Attractive Global Governance: questioning possibilities and constraints of well-boundedness, 2013).

Given the importance of figures of speech to the articulation of attractive future possibilities, their traditional significance in that respect merits renewed attention, as argued here. Being fundamental to the traditional art of rhetoric, highly developed in a range of cultures, the very fact that "rhetoric" is now widely deprecated as a characteristic of sterile discourse calls for careful attention.

The point is made Paul Stob, professor of communication studies:

In rhetorical studies, we often deal with a similar issue... When people say things like 'rhetoric versus reality' or 'We want action, not rhetoric', they're making a rhetorical move that hinges upon the deprecation of rhetoric itself. So 'it's just politics' is a way of playing politics that seems to dismiss politics. (Why 'it's just politics' is the ultimate political dodge, The Christian Science Monitor, 26 August 2015)

That said, it is curious to note that an assessment in a leader by The Economist on the current crisis argues that:

Farewell, left versus right. The contest that matters now is open against closed... Countering the wall-builders will require stronger rhetoric, bolder politics and smarter tactics. First, the rhetoric. Defenders of the open world worder need to make their case more forthrightly (Globalisation and Politics: the new political divide, 30 July 2016).

Less evident from this injunction is whether the requirement is for univocal rhetoric or that potentially characteristic of a sustainable multipolar global society having a "polycentric international architecture", as recently envisaged by Sergey Lavrov, Foreign Minister of Russia (Shift to multipolar world: Lavrov says Russia working to adjust foreign policy to new reality, RT, April 2016).

In that respect, the same issue of The Economist frames rhetoric in surprisingly distinctive terms:

There is a Welsh style of political speech that owes more to the pulpit than the podium. It was born in the nonconformist Valleys, where mysticism, mining and Methodism mingled and produced a distinctively emotional and poetic religious culture. At its heart is hwyl, a hard-to-translate Welsh term implying the stirringly sentimental, bardic and gutsy. On the preacher's lips it means cerdd dafod (rhythm, or "tongue craft") and cynghanedd (harmony). It has marked the speech of three of Britain's most acclaimed modern political orators, all sons of provincial Wales: David Lloyd George, Nye Bevan and Neil Kinnock. Of the latter's first speech as Labour Party leader one reporter admiringly wrote that he " hwyled and hwyled and hwyled". (Rage against the dying of the light, 30 July 2016)

Missing from such appreciation is the vital requirement for challenging aesthetic complement to monovocal rhetoric -- in order to constrain the prevailing tendency of speakers, poets and singers to be "too full of themselves" in their neglect of others (as with writers).

The focus below can be understood to follow from the case long made by C. P. Snow that the intellectual life of the whole of western society is now split into the titular two cultures -- the sciences and the humanities -- and that this is a major hindrance to solving the world's problems (The Two Cultures, 1959).

Rhyme versus Reason? This could be understood as a more general and fundamental framing of an argument later made by Samuel P. Huntington that people's cultural and religious identities will be the primary source of future conflict (The Clash of Civilizations?, Foreign Affairs, Summer 1993). With respect to the quest for elusive global connectivity, this clash of civilizations argument might well be framed otherwise as that between "poetry" and "prose" -- or between "rhyme" and "reason".

What is to be expected of persuasive speech? What connectivity requires "rhyme", rather than "reason" alone? In the clarification of the question by Matthew S. McGlone et al. (Birds of a feather flock conjointly (?): rhyme as reason in aphorisms, Psychological Science, 2000), the authors note that:.

In The Gay Science, Nietzsche (1878/1986) attributed the origin of poetry to a primitive belief that rhythm and rhyme could confer magical powers to the words of prayers, carrying them "closer to the ears of the gods". Although this superstition was dismissed long ago in most cultures, Nietzsche observed that "even now...the wisest among us are still occasionally fooled by rhythm -- if only insofar as we sometimes consider an idea truer because it has a metrical form and presents itself with a divine spark and jump" (pp. 139-140, emphasis added). Our results offer some support for Nietzsche's claim: Participants conflated the rhyme and perceived accuracy of aphorisms unless they were explicitly instructed to distinguish the statements' semantic content from their poetic qualities.

The current inadequacies of global governance, through the focus on "reason" at all costs, may be effectively exacerbated by having "thrown the baby out with the bathwater". Attractive, comprehensible connectivity may call for a measure of "rhyme". Any quest for "agreement" and "harmony" might then be understood in terms of such "consonance".

Furthermore, the quest for sustainability may indeed call for a degree of memorability with which "rhyme" is associated, as may be variously discussed (In Quest of Mnemonic Catalysts -- for comprehension of complex psychosocial dynamics, 2007; Imagining the Real Challenge and Realizing the Imaginal Pathway of Sustainable Transformation, 2007). The bertsolaritza process offers insights in that respect, as previously discussed (Improvisation in Multivocal Poetic Discourse: Basque lauburu and bertsolaritza as catalysts of global significance, 2016).

Righteous rectitude: How to bridge between perspectives whose adherents variously distinguish themselves by the claim to be unquestionably right, irrespective of the physical or symbolic violence which their differences engender? Added to this is the further irony of many being variously obsessed with protecting their righteous articulation of rectitude through duly enshrining it in exclusive copyright (droit d'auteur) -- typically behind a paywall. Equally curious, but far more problematic, is the association of the State with unquestionable rectitude, most notably in the sense that the State can do no wrong (as has long been the claim of organized religion).

This is most evident in French through the confusion of "law" (droit) and "right" (droit), as in current declarations regarding the Etat de Droit (or Rechstaat in German), as made by the French Prime Minister Manuel Valls (Il y a une ligne infranchissable, l'Etat de droit, Le Monde, 29 juillet 2016; L'état d'urgence, c'est l'état de droit, France Inter, 12 novembre 2015). A corresponding understanding has been articulated by Barack Obama to the effect that There is no justification for violence against law enforcement. None (The Huffington Post, 17 July 2016).

Is the cognitive challenge of "getting it together", and "holding it together", as much a matter of the enigmas of metapoetics as of metalogic? From the perspective of Castalia, the sciences and the arts as conventional cognitive enterprises are considered to have abandoned all hope with respect to any such cultural challenge.

Enabling global governance through aesthetics? It is then appropriate to ask whether policy can be enabled and enacted via more memorably elegant poetic and musical forms, as separately argued (Poetry-making and Policy-making: arranging a marriage between Beauty and the Beast, 1993; A Singable Earth Charter, EU Constitution or Global Ethic? 2006; Aesthetics of Governance in the Year 2490, 1990).

The potential relevance to ongoing conflicts also merits attention (Poetic Engagement with Afghanistan, Caucasus and Iran: an unexplored strategic opportunity? 2009; Strategic Jousting through Poetic Wrestling: aesthetic reframing of the clash of civilizations, 2009).

The following exercise in reimagining an event follows from several previous exercises in envisaging future possibilities in such a context (Gardening Sustainable Psycommunities: recognizing the psycho-social integrities of the future, 1995; Transdisciplinarity through Structured Dialogue: beyond sterile dualities in meetings to the challenge of participant impotence, 1994; World Futures Conference as Catastrophic Question: from performance to morphogenesis and transformation, 2013).

Emergent collective identity? The implied collective cognitive challenge can also be framed more provocatively in terms of the emergence of a form of humanity distinct from homo sapiens -- with the further challenge of how its subtly distinctive nature might be recognized. The bertsolaritza process is consistent with naming this emergent species as homo conjugens or homo undulans. The latter is the focus of the penultimate chapter of an extensive study by Daniel Dervin (Creativity and Culture: a psychoanalytic study of the creative process in the arts, sciences, and culture, 1990). Possible characteristics of this potential modality are discussed separately (Emergence of Homo undulans -- through a grokking dynamic? 2013; Authentic Grokking: emergence of Homo conjugens, 2003).

"Songlines"? One lead is offered by the faintly intuited intimations as to the nature of that insight -- a pattern potentially understood in terms of a configuration of which the elusive generative metaphor is a focus of "higher order" in cognitive and cybernetic terms (Engaging with Insight of a Higher Order, 2014). The intuitions may be understood in terms of glimpses, elusive harmonies, or the like.

The ultimate challenge has traditionally been framed as hearing the music of the spheres, perhaps now to be nuanced otherwise in the light of the recent magnum opus of philosopher Peter Sloterdijk (Spheres, 2011-2014). Through a Holy Empire of Music, the theme features in the science fiction of Olaf Stapledon (Last and First Men: a story of the near and far future, 1930) later described as becoming part of the very fabric of some early universes where all movement is musical rather than spatial (Star Maker, 1937).

Re-imagining the present: Despite assertions that everything is connected to everything, given the challenge of apparently disparate phenomena jeopardizing global governance, there is also a case for recognizing the lead offered by the possibility of re-inventing the experience of the present moment, as characteristic of improvised singing. In contrast to the many formal projections and plans for the future. The case for "re-imagining" can be fruitfully contrasted with that conventionally made for the Club of Rome and challenged separately (Engendering 2052 through Re-imagining the Present, 2012). This is a critical review of 2052: a Global Forecast for the Next Forty Years (2012) by Jørgen Randers.

Given the development of the internet, can a generative metaphor of cognitive and cultural significance be more fruitfully explored, as framed for the Club of Budapest, the cultural counterpart to the Club of Rome (Cultivating the Songlines of the Noosphere: from presentations by representatives to embodying presence in transformation, 1996; From Information Highways to Songlines of the Noosphere, 1996) ?


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]

Subjects: Aesthetics · Thought