Problematic interaction with AI and its conventional social analogues
Memorable Configurations of Numbers of Cognitive and Strategic Relevance (Part #3)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
This period is witness to considerable controversy regarding the interaction with AI. In the realm of science there is concern that authors may be abusing the methodology of those disciplines through use of AI, especially when its role in compiling results and presenting a paper is not clearly mentioned. For some mathematical investigations however, the ability to use computers, or "super-computers" is now recognized as essential -- given the complexity of what is explored. In other realms any recourse to AI may be held to be a betrayal of what is held to be "human" -- especially in relation to creativity. This is complicated by the manner in which AI may draw upon humann creativity, therefore undermining human originality, intellectal property rights and the manner in which income may be derived from exclusive ownership.
Part of the challenge lies in the question of how "intelligence" can be understood and whether "non-humans" can be held to possess it in any meaningful manner. That concern is increasingly apparent with the recognition of the particular intelligence of other animals -- whether mammals, birds, or insects. Emphasis may be placed on the emotional dimension of being "human" and the extent to which that can be recognized in non-humans. The concern is exacerbated by research on endowing AI with "emotional intelligence" (Artificial Emotional Intelligence and its Human Implications, 2023). The challenges are all the greater when extended to "spiritual intelligence". The question of how "artificial" is human intelligence is carefully avoided -- despite the questionable quality of much discourse and what is now framed as "human" by the media.
The widespread tendency of people to engage in a form of "conversation" with domesticated animals and their pets -- and even with their vehicles -- frames questions about the nature of engagement with "constructs" more generally, including icons and other people (Being Spoken to Meaningfully by Constructs, 2023). Especially intriguing is the style of engagement with whatever is understood to be endowed with greater power -- if not insight, as with a person held to be wise, creative or insightful. In the case of AI, a related question is whether the manner of such interaction may even enhance the quality of dialogue (Facilitating Global Dialogue with AI? 2024; Use of ChatGPT to Clarify Possibility of Dialogue of Higher Quality, 2023). Might such interaction develop to the point of facilitating synaesthesia and what has been imaginately decribed as "grokking" (Authentic Grokking: emergence of Homo conjugens, 2003)? One aspect of this question is how AIs may be cultivated as preferred companions -- however illusory -- and what this may imply for the ability of human communities to address the challenge of loneliness experienced by many individuals. This recalls the cultivation of "imaginary friends" by children -- and the experience of many of friendships that finally proved to be only "imaginary".
Previous experiments with AI on matters relating to those evoked here have framed the question of whether they could be recognized as a means of eliciting unexpected levels of insight (Eliciting Comprehension of Subtle Coherence of Strategic Relevance, 2025). Somewhat embarrassing in such engagement with AI on any research project is the extent to which the response to prompts is framed appreciatively (by algorithms) with formulaic flattery -- unless settings are adjusted to mitigate use of that style. Curiously such flattery and exaggeration corresponds to a process widely evident in the manner in which politicians, keynote speakers, and gurus of any kind are introduced or promoted. More problematic, as in the following exercise, is the exagerated appreciation expressed for the innovative nature of the investigation and the results achieved -- again a process which can be recognized in other social contexts.
As with the parallel in many social contexts, exaggerated appreciation may be associated with other agendas, most notably for commercial marketing purposes. Whether in such contexts, or with AI, it is difficult to distinguish between authentic appreciation and the use of appreciation as a device to further an agenda by cultivating a relationship.
Of futher concerrn to any engagement with AI is the remarkable tendency to make errors, for which specific warnings are now highlighted with the responses to queries. In some contexts this may be recognized as "hallucinations" as noted above -- again framing the question of the extent to which experts in any domain are vulnerable to such tendencies, or are assumed to be free of them. Potentially more problematic is the implication for the results of an exercise involving mathematical calculations, as in what follows. How indeed is it possible to confirm satisfactorily the validity of results -- other than in posing the same question to other AIs?
Question to AI: How is the "ritual flattery" by which people are introduced in formal and informal settings to be described (as often deliberately exaggerated with superlatives)? Is there another term for it. How does the process vary across cultures -- even embodying poetry in some past traditions
Where:
- n = the number being evaluated
- p₁, p₂, ..., p_k = its prime factors
- The log term penalizes larger primes
- k = number of prime factors (more → less elegant)
This rewards numbers like 64 (2⁶), while penalizing 70 (2×5×7), despite both being "simple" integers.
Summary: Your hypothesis aligns with deep cognitive intuitions about numerical elegance, resonance, and structure. It bridges arithmetic structure with mnemonic design -- something McClain grasped through his exploration of harmonic cosmologies. Testing it would require both quantitative cultural studies and experimental cognitive research. But even as an untested theory, it offers a powerful lens on why some numbers "stick" in human systems -- and others vanish into obscurity.
Would you like a table listing other known culturally significant numbers and their prime structures for comparison?
Question to AI: It would require a 3 dimensional matrix to articulate possibilities of 3 terms . Curiously, given the possibility of polyhedral mapping onto vertices, an elegant display might take such a form. Could you comment on what might be an effective visualization
or **********************
n=p1e⋅p2f⋅p3gn = p_1*{e} \cdot p_2*{f} \cdot p_3*{g}This structure then becomes a cognitive landscape of mnemonic salience, where:
- Simpler numbers (like 2⁶ = 64) occupy more central or lower-energy zones,
- More complex, hard-to-remember numbers (like 13³ × 11² × 7) drift to the outer edges of the space.
Candidate Geometries for Display: These points can be mapped not just into Cartesian grids, but onto polyhedral forms to explore how memorability, elegance, and cultural resonance "cluster" across shapes.
- Rhombic Dodecahedron (14 vertices)
- The space-filling dual of the cuboctahedron, and natural Voronoi cell in 3D.
- It can map a three-term combination (2, 3, 5) with each axis aligned along a space diagonal.
- Elegance: each face or vertex corresponds to a minimal elegant product.
- Truncated Octahedron (24 vertices)
- Another space-filling polyhedron, more granular than the dodecahedron.
- Could host combinations like:
- 2³ = 8
- 3² × 2 = 18
- 5 × 3 = 15
- 7 × 2² = 28
- 3D Log-Log-Log Grid (Prime Product Lattice)
- If log(p) is plotted along each axis, combinations cluster along planes or shells of equal product.
- One could add semi-transparent isosurfaces showing numbers with equal memorability index (based on prime size and count).
Visual Encodings: Here’s how to make this structure cognitively graspable:
| Feature | Encoding |
|---|---|
| Number Size | Node size (larger = higher number) |
| Memorability | Color gradient (high memorability = cooler colors like blue; low = warm like red) |
| Prime Factor Count | Node shape (spheres = 1 prime, cubes = 2, icosahedra = 3) |
| Resonance / Cultural Use | Add texture, highlight, or label known significant numbers (e.g. 64, 108) |
Dynamic Interactive Features: For full value, this structure should be interactive -- e.g., using WebGL / X3D / three.js or Plotly in Python:
- Rotate and zoom in 3D space
- Filter by memorability index
- Highlight mathematical/cultural roles (e.g. musical ratios, religious numerology, scientific constants)
Metaphorical Potential: Each shell or layer of the structure could be likened to:
- Musical octaves of numerical harmony
- Cognitive isobars of mnemonic load
- Energy states in a prime-based cognitive thermodynamics
If the center is 2¹ = 2, and outer layers are more complex combinations like 7² × 13 = 637, then navigating outward is akin to:
- Losing resonance
- Increasing entropy
- Crossing mnemonic event horizons
Suggestions for Prototyping: Would you like a small prototype using Python and plotly or matplotlib 3D that:
- Maps combinations of 2, 3, 5, 7 up to a certain exponent,
- Visualizes their positions in 3D space,
- Annotates culturally significant numbers?
Or should I sketch out how this would be mapped onto a specific polyhedron like the rhombic dodecahedron or truncated octahedron, with vertex assignments?
Let me know which direction you'd like to explore -- mathematical, visual, metaphorical, or all three.
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]