Collective comprehension and communication of a 12-fold set
Eliciting a 12-fold Pattern of Generic Operational Insights (Part #3)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
The learning challenge of a 12-fold set of insights -- as highlighted by Young -- can therefore be considered in the light of Miller's "magical number seven" (plus or minus two). The set of 12 could, for example, be configured in two ways: as a circle or as a rectangle. The binary choice made, comprehensibility is enhanced by clustering the 12 into 3-fold and 4-fold patterns. Primary attention could then be given to either the 3-fold or the 4-fold.
The argument is that it is difficult for most to fully understand, remember and communicate 12 distinct qualities -- recognizing that the operational understanding required is of a higher order than that required to distinguish 30 or 100 acquaintances, plants, foodstuffs, soundtracks, or other matters. Whilst expertise may enable this number to be of a much higher order, the larger that number the more difficult it becomes to communicate those distinguished and to ensure the memorability of those distinctions over time (Minding the Future: Thought experiment on presenting new information, 1980). This may well become a major issue in an agining population where a coherent set of mnemonic clues may be vital.
The point can be emphasized in a potentially significant way in that "operating oneself", may be understood in terms of 3-fold organization (head, thorax, abdomen) or 4-fold (4 limbs). Their coordination is typically unconscious rather than conscious. This has direct implications for the control of a vehicle, such as a helicopter for example, when each may have a role. Their appropriate engagement with the operation of the vehicle may require considerable training and experience. Again this is not to deny that control panels on complex installations may have hundreds of switches and indicators. The argument is that "driving" such a configuration calls for polysensorial engagement appropriately related to the implications of the slang term "grok".
Fig. 1: Example of a tentative elaboration of a 12-fold array of clusters of complementary options | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
The following numeric properties of 12 (from Wikipedia) merit very careful research with respect to their potential implications for the memorability and communicability of a pattern beyond human working memory capacity (and irrespective of whether the mathematical formalization is meaningful):
- as a composite number, the smallest number with exactly six divisors, its proper divisors being 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 12.
- as a highly composite number, the next one being 24. It is the first composite number of the form p2q; a square-prime, and also the first member of the (p2) family in this form. 12 has an aliquot sum of 16 (133% in abundance).
- as the first abundant number (in fact a superabundant number) and demonstrates an 8 member aliquot sequence; {12,16,15,9,4,3,1,0} 12 is the 3rd composite number in the 3-aliquot tree. The only number which has 12 as its aliquot sum is the square 121. Only 2 other square primes are abundant (18 and 20).
- as a sublime number, a number that has a perfect number of divisors, and the sum of its divisors is also a perfect number. Since there is a subset of 12's proper divisors that add up to 12 (all of them but with 4 excluded), 12 is a semiperfect number. If an odd perfect number is of the form 12k + 1, it has at least twelve distinct prime factors.
- as a superfactorial, being the product of the first three factorials. Twelve being the product of three and four, the first four positive integers show up in the equation 12 = 3 4, which can be continued with the equation 56 = 7 8.
- as the number of edges of regular cubes and octahedrons, with regular icosahedrons having 12 vertices.
- as a pentagonal number.
- as the number of spheres touched by a central sphere in the densest three-dimensional lattice sphere packing, and this is almost certainly true for any arrangement of spheres (the Kepler conjecture held to be 99% proven)
- as a kissing number (or Newton number) in three dimensions, namely the number of unit spheres that touch another given unit sphere.
- as the smallest weight for which a cusp form exists. This is related to a constellation of interesting appearances of the number twelve in mathematics ranging from the value of the Riemann zeta function function at -1 i.e. ?(-1)=-1/12, the fact that the abelianization of SL(2,Z) has twelve elements, and even the properties of lattice polygons.
- as the number of Jacobian elliptic functions
- as the number of finite trivalent (cubic) distance-transitive graphs.
Of potential relevance for similar reasons are the following reflections of Peter Collins, in a private communication in the light of his own earlier work (Some Observations on Perfect Numbers):
- 12 as the first and most important "double perfect number" on the assumption that in summing the divisors of a perfect number the number itself is included (rather than excluded). So, rather than excluding 6 from the proper divisors of 6 (as 1, 2 and 3), it is included, then the sum of all the divisors of 6 gives 12 (i.e. double the perfect number in question). Thus a double perfect is simply double that of 6 as a perfect number.
- summing the reciprocals of all the divisors of a perfect number always equals 2. In the case of 6 we have 1/1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + 1/4 + 1/6 = 2. And of course 2 * 6 = 12 (i.e. the first double perfect number).
- every double perfect number can be expressed as two consecutive natural numbers. So once again, for example 12 = 3 * 4. This implies that if we obtain the difference of the reciprocals of these latter two numbers that we obtain the reciprocal of the corresponding double perfect number. Thus 1/3 - 1/4 = 1/12.
- from a qualitative perspective the nature of the two consecutive numbers is very revealing in that they relate to what are in an important sense at opposite extremes from each other.
- the first number is always a (Mersenne) prime with of course no factors and therefore symbolic of the highest level of independence.
- the second number is always a power of 2 therefore making it the most composite possible for its size. In other words the maximum number of factors possible arises with numbers raised to the power of 2.
With respect to the Monster Group first constructed by Bob Griess in 196,884 dimensions, Collins further notes in the light earlier reflections (Monstrous Moonshine - 24 dimensional space) :
- this is split into 3 subspaces (98,304 + 300 + 98,280 = 196,884) all having an intimate connection with 12:
- 98,304 = (2*12)*(2*12).
- 300 = 12*{(2*12) +1}).
- 98,280 = 98,304 - 24 = (2*12)*(2*12) - (2*12).
- the minimum number of dimensions in which the Monster can be constructed is 196,883 (= 196,884 - 1):
- 196,883 = 47 * 59 * 71, with the difference between 47 and 59 is 12; likewise the difference between 59 and 71 is 12.
- 47 = (4*12) - 1
- 59 = (5*12) - 1
- 71 = (6*12) - 1
- 196,883 = 47 * 59 * 71, with the difference between 47 and 59 is 12; likewise the difference between 59 and 71 is 12.
Collins concludes regarding the qualitative rationale as to why 12 should be so important in the context of the Monster Group, arguing that symmetry necessarily requires a relationship as between parts and whole. Perfect symmetry would thereby entail the perfect harmony of (differentiated) parts with the (integral) whole. The significance attributed to the Monster Group in mathematics as the ultimate form of symmetry, calls for reflection on its potential psychosocial implications, as discussed separately (Potential Psychosocial Significance of Monstrous Moonshine: an exceptional form of symmetry as a Rosetta stone for cognitive frameworks, 2007).
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
