Representing boundaries to governance (constrained by other boundaries)


Imagining Attractive Global Governance (Part #3)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]


On the occasion of the Rio+20 Earth Summit -- the United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development (Rio de Janeiro, 2012) -- Oxfam released a discussion paper produced by Kate Raworth (A Safe and Just Space for Humanity: can we live within the doughnut? February 2012). The paper presents a single visual framework -- shaped like a doughnut -- that represents a space within which humanity can thrive. This doughnut-like area is defined by combining the above-mentioned set of 9 "planetary boundaries" with a new set of 11 social boundaries, based on the 11 dimensions of human deprivation that emerged from the issues raised by governments in their Rio+20 submissions.

Oxfam Doughnut
(from Kate Raworth, A Safe and Just Space for Humanity: can we live within the doughnut?, 2012).
Oxfam Doughnut

An earlier discussion of the Oxfam paper presented the above image in relation to both that of the "planetary boundaries" and one developed in response to the latter on the "psychosocial boundaries of remedial action" (Exploring the Hidden Mysteries of Oxfam's Doughnut: recognizing the systemic negligence of an Earth Summit, 2012). The two images are presented below.

Contrasting the Earth-System boundaries with the boundaries of Remedial Action capacity
(from Recognizing the Psychosocial Boundaries of Remedial Action:
constraints on ensuring a safe operating space for humanity
, 2009)

Nine planetary boundaries
(from Planetary Boundaries:
exploring the safe operating space for humanity
, 2009)
[click image for enlargement]
Nine remedial capacity boundaries
using the representational pattern
of the Planetary Boundaries (from 2009)
[click image for enlargement]
Earth-System planetary boundaries Earth-System remedial capacity boundaries

Inspired by the Oxfam presentation, could some such "doughnut pattern" be used to frame a viable pattern of global governance -- in the light of the set of extreme questions with respect to the 12 dimensions in the table above? How then to highlight the zone of viable governance within some such representation?

The design choice for such a representation can be illustrated by the preliminary representation below. The image could suggest that the viable approach is:

  • within the brown zone, following the Oxfam approach (where it is coloured green)? This is problematic, given that the 12 dimensions of the pattern of questions cut across the doughnut. This suggests the possibility that there are two "safe" ranges (on the brown) preceding the extremes of each dimension. This "illogical" interpretation is inconsistent with the Oxfam approach, but is the basis for a refinement of the design proposal (as discussed below)
  • within the green-coloured central hole of the doughnut, surrounded by the brown zone? This "abandons the doughnut philosophy", implying instead that that there are compromise possibilities to be found between the extremes on each dimension -- in the green zone close to the centre of the doughnut. Changing from the "doughnut" metaphor to an "eye" metaphor, this would imply that viability is associated with the "pupil" rather than the "iris". This is the option illustrated in the image immediately below.
Preliminary illustration of design option
option assuming that viability is indicated by being "within the central hole" (coloured green)
(yellow spot indicative of viablility; red of non-viability)
Design options for attractive depiction of governance challenges

"Bi-focal" option? There is however a third way of considering use of the doughnut (see image below). This could take greater account of the inherent incompatibility of strategic perceptions in relation to each dimension. This approach is somewhat inspired by the slider commonly used in web maps to enable zooming in or out by users -- to expose greater detail (and less overview) or less detail (and greater overview). From a geographical perspective, this accords with the sense that both global and local perspectives are valuable.

Thus in the case of the complexity/simplicity dimension, a more systemic, complex view is to be valued, just as a simpler view is also valuable to more immediate understanding. Strategically this reflects the different framings of global and local perspectives -- even though they may be appropriately complementary.

The concern with this design approach is the implication that on each dimension there are then two zones of viability (rather than one). With respect to any approach to global governance, using the simplicity/complexity dimension as an example, this then implies that:

  • the governance approach may be too complex -- namely outside the green zone (and the doughnut) at one extreme
  • the governance approach may be too simple -- namely outside the green zone (and the doughnut) at the other extreme
  • any compromise combination of complexity/simplicity in the approach may be non-viable -- namely in the clear zone towards the centre of the doughnut
  • a viable governance approach may however require comprehension through two "incompatible" (or "incommensurable") perspectives, just as it is problematic to combine a global and local perspective in the exploration of any map. For the viability of the proposal, the two incompatible perspectives then need to be within the green zone on opposite sides of the doughnut -- for each of the 12 dimensions.

    An appropriate degree of "separation" can be usefully understood through the two-eyed requirement of stereoscopic depth perception. This approach is also illustrated by the Uncertainty Principle in physics, understood here as precluding a global perspective if a local perspective is chosen -- and vice versa (cf. Garrison Sposito, Does a generalized Heisenberg Principle operate in the social sciences? Inquiry, 1969).

With respect to the last point, a further possible implication, well illustrated by the "being-right/dissenter-wrong" dimension, is that both perspectives may be at their respective polar extremes, namely outside the green zone of the doughnut -- as with a sense of being "absolutely right", accompanied by a sense that dissenters are "dangerously wrong".

Illustration of design option using "incompatible" perspectives
option assuming that viability is indicated by being "within the green zone"
(note the two non-viable cases of
" being-right/dissenters-wrong" dimension and the "implementation/commitment-indifference" dimension)
 Design options for attractive depiction of governance challenges: 'incompatibel' perspectives

Suggestive use can be made of a normal distribution curve to distinguish the representations above. This has the advantage of implying of the greater proportion of any population adhering to perspectives relatively closely associated with the mean, in contrast with those preferring greater or lesser emphasis, and with those adopting even more extreme positions.

Illustration of contrasting design options above
(presented as cross-sections of the circle)
Green zone indicative of viability Green ring indicative of "bi-focal" viability
Contrasting design options: Green zone indicative of viability Contrasting design options: Green ring indicative of 'bi-focal' viability

The "bi-focal" design option is discussed further below.


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]