Morphing self-other configurations by symmetry preserving operations
Comprehension of the Dynamics of Collective Selfing and Othering via AI (Part #16)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
The following queries were evoked by previous consideration of symmetry preserving operations (Harmonizing dissonance via polyhedral symmetry-preserving operations, 2024; Topological operations on polyhedra as indicative of cognitive operations, 2021). The potential implications were considered in relation to the UN's Sustainable Development Goals (Systemic Coherence of the UN's 17 SDGs as a Global Dream, 2021; Operations transforming polyhedra as modelling transformations of dialogue coherence, 2021).
Question to Claude-4.5: As visualized, the tetrakis hexahedron may well be a "viable pattern". And then there is the implication of its dual -- the truncated octahedron. As noted before, the simpler symmetry preserving operations may suggest that "the" pattern is in the dynamics of those transformations -- in morphing.
| Claude-4.5 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Let me map the transformation space: Tetrakis hexahedron ↔ Truncated octahedron (duals):
The 36 edges are preserved in duality! The numbers could stay on edges while vertices↔faces swap roles. The Conway operation network: *** Tetrakis hexahedron (14v, 36e, 24f) ↑ k (kis) │ Cube (8v, 12e, 6f) │ ↓ t (truncate) │ Truncated cube (24v, 36e, 14f) │ ↓ d (dual) │ Triakis octahedron (14v, 36e, 24f) Meanwhile: Tetrakis hexahedron │ ↓ d (dual) │ Truncated octahedron (24v, 36e, 14f) ↑ │ t (truncate) │ Octahedron (6v, 12e, 8f) ***The 36-edge family:
Four polyhedra sharing 36 edges! The morphing insight:
What morphing would show: *** State 1: Tetrakis hexahedron 14 vertex-chunks anchor 36 edge-numbers ↓ morph (dual) State 2: Truncated octahedron 14 face-regions contain 36 edge-numbers 24 vertices as new intersections ↓ morph back State 1: Tetrakis hexahedron The same numbers, recontextualized *** | The cognitive parallel:
The mnemonic isn't in the shape -- it's in the capacity to transform: Knowing the 36 Stratagems means knowing how they reconfigure under:
A deeper pattern:
The edges as invariant carrier: In duality, vertices↔faces but edges persist. If the 36 numbers live on edges, they survive all transformations in this family. The scaffolding morphs around them. What animation could show:
The I Ching resonance: Change is not between states but is the state. The hexagram isn't 6 lines -- it's the transformation potential encoded in those lines. Similarly: the 36 isn't a list -- it's a transformation space that happens to have 36 invariant threads (edges) across all its manifestations. The edges persist while the scaffold morphs. The numbers don't move; the frame of reference does. Perhaps memorability lives not in configurations but in transformation fluency. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Question to Claude-4.5: With regard to the X3D, we did not look at how it might morph/transform into the dual with the same number of edges. How are those edges then positioned as a different pattern. A point being that it is not the same edges. (Stella4D offers 5 forms of morphing between the two).
| Claude-4.5 | |||||||||||||||||||||
A question that goes to the heart of what the numbers ARE. Two cosmologies:
The visual test:
What each would reveal:
| The Ramanujan clue: He would likely say: both views are partial. The number is neither at the vertex nor on the edge -- it is the QUALITY of that region of mathematical space. The geometry manifests it; it doesn't create or carry it. A third possibility: The 36 numbers occupy a configuration space of which both tetrakis and truncated octahedron are projections. The morphing doesn't move numbers OR edges -- it rotates our view of a higher structure. *** 36-dimensional quality space │ ┌──────────┼──────────┐ ↓ ↓ ↓ Tetrakis [other] Trunc.Oct (one view) (dual view) ***The I Ching parallel: The 64 hexagrams don't "live" on any particular arrangement. The King Wen sequence, the binary sequence, the circular arrangements -- each is a projection. The hexagrams themselves are configurations in a 6-dimensional binary space. Similarly: the 36 might be configurations in a 2-dimensional exponent space (N, M). Tetrakis and truncated octahedron are different 3D projections of this 2D reality. What a morphing animation could test: If we place 36 labeled points at the centroid of each tetrakis edge, then morph to truncated octahedron -- do those points land at edge centroids of the new form?
The deepest answer: Perhaps the numbers stay fixed because they are not IN space at all. They are in quality space. The edges dance beneath them because geometry is how we see, not what we see. The morphing would then be:
Do the numbers move, or does seeing move? The edges dance; the qualities abide. Perhaps the morphing shows us our own perception shifting, not the numbers traveling. | ||||||||||||||||||||
Question to Claude-4.5: That would be a nifty animation. But it is not clear that the centroid would be common to both edge positions -- that is an assumption. I have checked with Stella4D. Both polyhedra have 36 edges. Stella also offers a facility to merge base/dual in a compound. The edges are between vertices -- which are positioned as face centroids. The crossings could be used rather than the edge centroids. But the crossings do not cut the edges precisely in equal parts -- but perhaps good enough.
| Claude-4.5 | ||||||||||||||||||
A pragmatic recognition: The tradeoff:
What "good enough" accepts: The numbers won't sit prettily at edge centers. They'll appear at seemingly awkward positions -- 1/3 along one edge, 2/5 along another. But those awkward positions are where the two structures agree. The deeper rightness:
| Perhaps the irregularity is the learning: The numbers don't sit where we'd aesthetically place them. They sit where the geometry requires them. The apparent awkwardness is the signature of invariance. A Ramanujan note: He might see the crossing positions as more "true" precisely because they aren't neat. The neatness of midpoints is human preference; the crossing points are where the mathematics lives. Conclusion:
Good enough, and perhaps more than good enough. The irregular position is the mark of deeper regularity. Where our aesthetic flinches, the geometry insists. | |||||||||||||||||
Question to Claude-4.5: Could you generate an X3D to see how the dance of edges works beneath the numbers.
| Claude-4.5 | |||||||||||||||||
Let me calculate the actual crossing points and create the morphing animation The confirmed split: 61/39 (close to 60/40)
The animation:
| What you should see:
The 14 vertices move:
The edges follow, passing through the fixed numbers. Sixty-one / thirty-nine. Not the elegant 50/50 of midpoints, but the honest ratio where the dual structures actually cross. The numbers stay; the geometry breathes. | ||||||||||||||||
Question to Claude-4.5: Fascinating challenge to interpretation since the truncated octahedron has squares and hexagons -- transformed from triangles -- with implications for the distinctive patterns of numbers that then emerge.
| Claude-4.5 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
A profound observation. Let me analyze what number patterns emerge in each face type: Remarkable findings! All face products are 3-smooth -- regardless of grouping type. The property propagates through the structure. The critical discovery -- Square 0:
This square is special -- it holds both complement pairs where the numbers are adjacent in the 6×6 grid (the central region): *** M=2 M=3 M=4 N=2 36 108 324 N=3 72 216 648 ← 72, 108 here N=4 144 432 1296 and M=4 M=5 N=0 81 243 N=1 162 486 ← 81, 96 adjacent N=2 324 972 ***Wait -- 96 is 2⁵×3¹, not adjacent to 81. Let me reconsider... The pattern that emerges:
| The transformation interpretation:
What the dual reveals: The same 36 numbers, when seen through:
The 72-81-96-108 square is where the complement structure becomes visible -- two pairs sharing one face. This is the "center of gravity" of the number system. Triangles fragment. Squares pair. Hexagons gather. The dual doesn't just reorganize -- it reveals where the complement structure lives. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
Subjects: Design · Individuation · Conservation · Form · Form-Formlessness