Beneficial reframing of fundamental differences
Massive Elicitation of Psychosocial Energy (Part #5)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
Will the future see it as appropriate that physics should claim an absolute monopoly with regard to adequate insights into phenomena fundamental to the daily experiential reality of everyone? Or is the claim a characteristic of any "model", as implied in many domains (Issues too Important to be Left to Specialists: Selected web resources, 2004) ? How can the skills in pattern recognition of the array of disciplines (as understood by Feyerabend) be reappropriated for the common good?
The approach is fruitfully framed by the argument of Susantha Goonatilake (Toward a Global Science: mining civilizational knowledge, 1999), notably with respect to the metaphors favoured within the wider spectrum of cultures -- beyond the western cultural realm (Enhancing the Quality of Knowing through Integration of East-West metaphors, 2000). The meaning of "mining" might itself be reframed to include a form of personal or collective appropriation, even embodiment -- as recognized in the process of land nám ("land claiming or taking"), described by Joseph Campbell (The Inner Reaches of Outer Space: metaphor as myth and religion, 1986) as a psychocultural method of acquisition of such territory -- "not by prosaic physical action, but poetically, by intelligence" and by art, as discussed separately (Reclaiming the Heritage of Misappropriated Collective Endeavour, 2007)..
Denial of implication: These questions are especially pertinent in that physicists deny responsibility for destructive use of the technologies deriving from their efforts. They frame themselves as quite incapable (by definition) of offering insights into intangible psychosocial processes determining use of those technologies. They even mock and condemn any efforts to derive insights into such processes in the light of the cognitive expertise required for the the tangible processes over which they claim and demonstrate a degree of mastery -- as exemplified by the Sokal Affair (Alan Sokal, Beyond the Hoax: science, philosophy, and culture, 2008).
Differences: The argument here is that society has an increasingly evident need for new ways of processing radical differences, diversity and disagreement -- of which the Sokal Affair offers but one high-profile example. Labelling the other as ignorant, misguided or stupid is not sufficient. This is as evident between the disciplines as it is between belief systems and the proeoccupation with disruptive fundamentalism of every kind.
Integrative initiatives necessarily endeavour to address such differences. Integration is about what is different and distinct. Transdisciplinarity and interfaith endeavours have not yet met the need -- with both disciplines and faiths being distinguished by the elegant manner in which they avoid addressing the challenge effectively. More ironic are the evident differences amongst those acclaimed as integrative thinkers, as noted separately (Epistemological Challenge of Cognitive Body Odour: exploring the underside of dialogue, 2006; Guidelines for Critical Dialogue between Worldviews, 2006)
Implicit in e = mc2 is its truly fundamental significance as a pattern of relationship between phenomena that could not be more radically different and seemingly unrelated. Physics honours the distinct phenomena represented and rejoices in the sophistication of the insight into physical processes that the relationship represents. It was indeed Einstein who both related the equation to relativity and claimed that it was a "real" relationship: that objects would actually lose mass when they gave off light particles. However it is somewhat ironic that Einstein was not the first to derive the formula. It had previously been used by Henri Poincaré (Science and Hypothesis, 1902) as a heuristic, to treat electrodynamic radiation as a "fluid." Of greater potential significance therefore is the function of e = mc2 as a cognitive pattern interrelating fundamental differences -- having no evident coherent relationship.
As a pattern the relationship might be compared to other fundamental triune/triadic relationships, notably as explored by theology and philosophy -- systematically reviewed by Paris Arnopoulos (Sociophysics: cosmos and chaos in nature and culture, 2005). However, although these may be the subject of very extensive discourse, the essential nature of their relationship is typically framed in terms of mystery -- if only from other perspectives.
Physics has gone much further in giving precision to the requisite understanding of three fundamental elements and reframing the nature of the comprehension required -- specifically with respect to what is commmonly treated as "obvious", as in the case of energy, mass and light. However physics has seemingly nothing whatsoever to say of significance about their experiential and cognitive implications. For astrophysicists the sun continues to "rise" -- if only as a matter of convenience. The argument here is that these physical forms are usefully to be understood as but a particular instance of what can be experienced as fundamental difference, susceptible to being insightfully understood as interrelated. What greater degrees of difference between three elements could be imagined?
Disagreement: Of further interest is the manner in which difference and disagreement are conflated in comprehending the coherence of their relationship. Beyond the physical preoccupation is the recognition of how disagreement needs to be factored into conception of relationships. As noted, the Sokal Affair exemplifies failure in this respect. Other examples are offered by Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway (Merchants of Doubt, 2010) in carefully documenting how a handful of eminent physicists (formerly associated with the nuclear weapons programme) was able to obscure the truth on issues from tobacco smoke to global warming. How is "light" to be thrown upon the "matter" when it elicits so much "energetic" debate?
The challenge is further exemplified by how "disagreement" is treated as an externality within physics itself -- as with regard to the "division" in this much-cited comment of Niels Bohr in response to Wolfgang Pauli:
We are all agreed that your theory is crazy. The question which divides us is whether it is crazy enough to have a chance of being correct. My own feeling is that it is not crazy enough.
To that Freeman Dyson added:
When a great innovation appears, it will almost certainly be in a muddled, incomplete and confusing form. To the discoverer, himself, it will be only half understood; to everyone else, it will be a mystery. For any speculation which does not at first glance look crazy, there is no hope! (Innovation in Physics, Scientific American, 199, No. 3, September 1958)
How is this "dimension" to be factored in? This has been explored in the discussion on the nature of scientific revolutions -- itself challenged by extensive disagreement.
It is therefore most intriguing that technology effectively has the capacity to process difference and diversity fruitfully. It might be said that technology is the art of deriving benefit from differences. The same might be said of politics except that its limitations have become only too obvious -- limitations that are differently evident in the case of technology. What other forms of technology could enable "construction" from different elements (Using Disagreements for Superordinate Frame Configuration, 1992)? Might this even fruitfully include "contradictions"?
The ironic nature of the cognitive challenge is evident in the contrast between:
- the manner in which energy and light are derived by technology from enhancing the differences between "positive" and "negative" (whether in the case of electrical charge, pressure or temperature)
- the desperate attempt in society to emphasize the "positive" and to avoid (to the extent possible) any reference to the "negative" -- despite recognition of the problematic consequences from a cybernetic systems perspective (Being Positive and Avoiding Negativity: management challenge of positive vs negative, 2005). Most notable is the argument of Barbara Ehrenreich (Smile Or Die: how positive thinking fooled America and the world, 2010).
The irony is all the greater when:
- as with the Fukushima nuclear disaster, earlier "negative" feedback regarding potential vulnerabilities had been downplayed or rejected -- in order to continue to benefit from the nuclear technology. Subsequent efforts to cultivate a "positive" spin are indicated by consensus that: The Japanese government and TEPCO fell automatically into the 'reassure-at-all-costs' mode after the disaster, as reported by Andy Coghlan (TEPCO under fire over handling of Fukushima crisis, New Scientist, 5 April 2011).
- the promotion of strategic "alternatives", notably to the nuclear option, is readily characterized as "negative" in its opposition but is far from coherent in the articulation of what it stands for, as argued by George Monbiot (We know what to march against on 26 March; here's what to protest for, The Guardian, 6 March 2011). The difficulty is that any strategic manifesto typically takes the form of a "wish list" -- a "laundry list" totally lacking any of the systemic connectivity vital to its sustainability in practice.
Multiplicity: Of further significance to the pattern e = mc2 is that it involves three elements rather than the two so widely characteristic of the unresolved challenges of polarization, dualistic thinking and binary logic (Us and Them: relating to challenging others, 2009). Seemingly only the Chinese have addressed polarization in a creative manner through classic endeavours (the I Ching, the Tao Te Ching and the Tài Xuán Jing), but without apparently being able to use their insights to reframe wider social conflicts (Discovering richer patterns of comprehension to reframe polarization, 1998; Psychosocial Energy from Polarization: within a cyclic pattern of enantiodromia, 2007). Nuclear technology, based on e = mc2, has clearly emerged as being of fundamental significance as a source of insight into new approaches to energy capable of sustaining civilization -- perhaps as a verb rather than as a noun (as famously advocated by Mahatma Gandhi).
It is even possible that the ongoing "disagreements" in the "energy" debate might be reframed by new understanding of a fundamental cognitive relationship between the 3-fold (e = mc2), characteristic of the nuclear option, and the 4-fold, characteristic of the "renewable energy" option (wind, hydro, solar, and geothermal). More generally still, these challenges might be reframed in terms of number theory and its experiential significance (Representation, Comprehension and Communication of Sets: the Role of Number, 1978). There is the further possibility that such exploration might highlight the relevance of "zero" in the series (Brian Rotman, Signifying Nothing: the semiotics of zero, 1987). This could prove to be an indicator of a form of "cognitive omission" in strategic consideration of energy options (Lipoproblems: developing a strategy omitting a key problem, 2009). Examples sets ***
Especially intriguing in this respect are the explorations of an Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything (E8 Theory) by A. Garrett Lisi and James Owen Weatherall (A Geometric Theory of Everything, Scientific American, December 2010, pp. 30-33). More intriguing potentially are any suggestions of the psychosocial implications of such structures (Luminous, The Cosmic Mandala: Burning Man Badass Discovers the Shape of the Universe, 30 December 2009). The particular challenge is their comprehension (Dynamics of Symmetry Group Theorizing: comprehension of psycho-social implication, 2008).
Science, like religion, is essentially inept at handling fundamental differences, especially those of opinion vital to the governance of society (End of Science, 2008). Any future Theory of Everything (TOE), as with the theological definition of God, will necessarily elicit a variety of interpretations and the conflictual consequences of lack of consensus. An equivalent to the much-cited argument of Richard Dawkins (The God Delusion, 2006) is even predictable -- perhaps the TOE Delusion (cf Russell Standish, Theory of Nothing, 2006). The necessary complementarity of such contrasts is also evident in that between enthusiasm for an internet-enabled global brain (possibly sustaining "planetary consciousness") and the concerns articulated by Evgeny Morozov (The Net Delusion: the dark side of internet freedom, 2011).
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]