Problem displacement


Institutional Games and Strategies as a Response to Complexity (Part #3)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx ]


Close analysis of "successful" social innovation may therefore reveal that the particular problem has been eliminated to the satisfaction of all concerned (from the electorate to the policy- maker) by eliminating the particular set of symptoms by which it was recognized and which gave rise to the call for remedial action. But action of this kind may merely have ensured that a new set of symptoms emerges in some other social domain.

The new set may well be considered more acceptable, or may be less easy to focus on as the basis for an effective campaign for remedial action. Some time will also be required before the new set of symptoms can be effectively recognized. It may in fact be very difficult for an organization to see that its programmes merely displace a problem into the jurisdiction of some other body -- whose own actions will eventually result in the problem being displaced back again or into the jurisdiction of a third body. (Institutions may deliberately engage in problem displacement throughout a network of jurisdictions as a way of legitimating their own continued existence.)

Such displacement may be difficult to detect because one set of symptoms may be apparent in legislation {e.g. legal discrimination), but when eliminated may then take on an economic character (e.g. economic discrimination) which if eliminated may then take on a social character (e.g. social discrimination), and then a cultural character, etc. Such displacement chains may loop back on themselves and develop side chains which are difficult to detect since each organization is only sensitive to the problem symptoms in its own domain and considers symptoms of the same problem in other domains to be acceptable or of secondary importance. This situation makes it difficult to compare the presence or absence of problems in different geographical areas because of the different forms its symptoms take, the acceptability of some forms in some areas, or the lack of sensitivity to them.

Subjects: Societal Problems