Unresolved challenges of “dialogue”
Envisaging the AI-enhanced Future of the Conferencing Process (Part #2)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
There are frequent appeals for "dialogue" in relation to any conflict, whether violent or otherwise (Europe Talks: fostering dialogue among Europeans on critical issues, France24, 20 October 2020). Curiously it is readily assumed that such "dialogue" is a modality which is a vital response to complex situations. It remains highly questionable whether this is the case, given the manner in which conflict situations persist even when repeated efforts are made with the most skilled facilitators and mediators. Why has dialogue proven to be so ineffective in so many critical areans? Why is this failure not more assiduously addressed? Why the complacency in that regard?
The difficulty is evident in the case of mediation in interpersonal situations. To what extent is the call for dialogue used as a pretence, especially when it is recognized (by some) that little is likely to be achieved? To what extent is dialogue simply avoided when the differences are assumed to be too great -- as in the case of terrorism (Avoiding Dialogue with Alternative Worldviews at any Cost: timid hypocrisy in responding to terrorism, 2005)?
Specific studies clarifying learnings have been made:
- Huma Haider: National Dialogues: lessons learned and success factors (2019)
- T. Paffenholz, et al: What makes or breaks national dialogues? (The Inclusive Peace and Transition Initiative, IPTI, 2017)
- J. Harlander: Supporting a National Dialogue: dilemmas and options for third parties (Centre for Humanitarian Dialogue, 2016)
- M. Blunck, et al.: National Dialogue Handbook: a guide for practitioners (Berghof Foundation, 2017)
Of interest therefore is any effort to articulate the unresolved challenges of dialogue which are not effectively addressed. Why indeed does dialogue fail so frequently? The following themes also help to frame some of the issues:
- Unresolved challenges to engaging dialogue (2013)
- Dialogue: learnings for the future of dialogue (1997)
- Confusion in the Moment of Dialogue: checklist of patterns of behaviour and attitude inhibiting better dialogue ( 2004)
- Dialogue: levels of dialogue (1982)
- Future Generation through Global Conversation: in quest of collective well-being through conversation in the present moment (1997)
- Interrelationships between 64 Complementary Approaches to Dialogue (2007)
- Integrative Failure: towards transformative conferencing and dialogue (1984)
Of particular interest in any effort to distinguish alternative styles of "dialogue", on the assumption that participants in fundamental disagreement may favour one rather than another -- as with any facilitator (Varieties of Dialogue Arenas and Styles, 1992).
A notable arena of neglect is engaging with the failure of dialogue -- especially to the degree this is evident in the international arena (Roger Hallowell, et al, Pass through the Failure Gateway, Dialogue Review, 25 April 2019). This is an aspect of the contextual issue of the learnings to be derived from failure -- rather than avoiding them, as is so typically the case (Scott Cowen, The Value of Failure: how we can make the most of losing, Knowledge@Wharton, 14 March 2019). Such avoidance is especially dangerous when it reinforces the tendency to avoid understanding of how any system may fail, and the requisite vigilance with respect to that possibility (Variety of System Failures Engendered by Negligent Distinctions, 2016; Vigorous Application of Derivative Thinking to Derivative Problems, 2013).
Of potential relevance is the struggle with value polarities and dilemmas with which opposing participants may variously identify (Reframing dialogue constrained by value polarities, 2013). Whether expressed abstractly or otherwise, how is the future of dialogue to be envisaged -- and how might those of the future frame current struggles. Is a global revolution in dialogue to be imagined, and what form might it take, as explored in the earlier exercise:
| Revolution in engaging dialogue? Nature of "global" dialogue | Revolutionary implications for psychosocial professions and contexts Towards post-revolutionary harmonic order? |
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
Subjects: Debate