Towards a New Enlightenment?
Exhortation to We the Peoples from the Club of Rome (Part #8)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
In concluding the second section of the book, the authors argue, in a remarkable departure for the Club of Rome, that there may be a need for a new Enlightenment -- rather than a renewed Rationalism. In exemplifying this, reference is made to the need for a philosophy of balance rather than exclusion. This is seen as implied in the Confucian understanding of Yin and Yang, as framed together by the Tao. The need for a more subtle balance is specifically cited with respect to that:
between humans and nature | between women and men between equity and awards for achievement between state and religion |
Restrictive binary thinking: Whilst this emphasis is much to be welcomed, it could be asked whether this philosophy of balance (rather than exclusion) is exemplified by the thrust of the book. Binary thinking indeed has its implications for global decision-making (Destabilizing Multipolar Society through Binary Decision-making, 2016). The challenge could be presented with respect to the following as they feature in the report::
- "Enlightenment" versus "Endarkenment"? The possibility of such a Renaissance has indeed been variously argued (David Lorimer and Oliver Robinson (Eds.), A New Renaissance: transforming science, spirit and society. 2010). It is presented as a transformation offering hope in contrast to the impending sense of doom -- and the doom-mongering with which it is associated. Cognitively it is framed as "the light at the end of the tunnel". This framing is conflated with the quest for the "positive" and the rejection of the "negative". This rejection exemplifies the absence of such balance (Barbara Ehrenreich, Smile or Die: how positive thinking fooled America and the world, 2010). The hope-mongering of political discourse and progressives is a feature of this imbalance (Credibility Crunch engendered by Hope-mongering, 2008). The supreme irony is that "light", as obtained from electricity, has required an appropriate juxtaposition of both "positive" and "negative". Only the naive would strive to remove the "negative" wire which enables this.
Arguably "enlightenment" and "renaissance", as currently imagined with uncritical optimism, may well be victims of the binary thinking inhibiting the renewal they endeavour to imply. There is some probability that "endarkenment" may be a phase in a more mysterious cyclic process including "enlightenment", then to be otherwise understood (Enlightening Endarkenment: selected web resources on the challenge to comprehension, 2005).
Similarly the enthusiasm for "renaissance" may be problematically related to the uncritical appreciation of ever more births on a resource-challenged planet (Challenges of Renaissance: suggestive pattern of concerns in the light of the birth metaphor, 2003; Missing the New Renaissance? 2010). A more profound appreciation of "death" -- and its cyclic necessity -- may be called for in a global civilization widely recognized to be in danger of imminent collapse. Not to be forgotten is the highly problematic role of institutions like the Catholic Church in the process of the historical Renaissance.
- "Anthropocene" versus "Neganthropocene"? The report appropriately highlights the dramatic consequences of the Anthropocene (segment 1.4) arguing that: for the sake of the socio-economic well-being of humankind, it is absoluteley imperative that the world avoid the kind of environmental disasters resulting from trespassing planetary boundaries (p. 17).
Missing however is any acknowledgement of a complementary argument, from a contrasting perspective, notably as framed by Bernard Stiegler (The Neganthropocene, 2018). Understanding of "the Anthropocene" is explored as a conceptual dead-end trap characterized by a form of banality and nihilism -- an entropic vortex -- that it is vital to move beyond. This reinscribes philosophical, economic, anthropological and political concepts within a renewed thought of entropy and negentropy. The argument engages the insights of Alfred North Whitehead, Jacques Derrida, Gilbert Simondon, Peter Sloterdijk, Karl Marx, and Benjamin Bratton.
- "Bottom-up" versus "Top-down"? It could be argued that the acclaimed strategic shift to "bottom-up" is primarily a consequence of the obvious failures of "top-down". Advocating the shift is somewhat misleading in that the "bottom-up" strategy is already widely practiced by "we the peoples" through civil society organizations (3.15). The recommendation implies that the authors are engaging in a catch-up process -- effectively appropriate insights already articulated by others (as is common between political parties). The challenge of balance will remain in that both will continue to be required and how they can be interwoven has yet to adequately understood.
- "Leadership" versus "Followership"? As presented, the report carries the implication that it is offering -- if not providing -- a vital form of leadership. Hence the title of the third section: Come On! Join us on an exciting journey towards a sustainable world. With the "bottom-up" emphasis, there is an implication that "we the peoples" are being exhorted to follow that leadership in some way -- or so it will be interpreted by many. Rather than leading "from the top", the Club would seem to be aspiring to be a leader "from the side".
Rather than the Club of Rome, like Moses -- bringing the tablets down from the mountain top for the people, after being inscribed by God (Exodus 31:18) -- is Moses now to be understood as having discovered the tablets among the people? As noted above, the binary nature of such directionality calls for much further clarification, especially given the widespread perception of "misleadership" by elites and the associated perception of "misfollowership" (Emergence of a Global Misleadership Council: misleading as vital to governance of the future? 2007; Framing the interplay of (mis)leadership and (mis)followership: challenges and responsibilities, 2007).
Curiously the challenge of global governance (segment 3.16) seemingly takes little account of how multiple initiatives by "we the peoples" -- whether as leaders or followers -- are to be coordinated and governed, if that is indeed a systemic challenge involving civil society and collective leadership (3.15). It is especially strange in that an earlier report to the Club addressed this challenge (Yehezkel Dror, The Capacity to Govern, 1995), of which no mention is made, although this is noted on the Club site as the first report dealing with governance commissioned and approved by the Club of Rome, testifying to the significance of this book. Nor is any mention made of a subsequent study by that author (For Rulers: Priming Political Leaders for Saving Humanity from Itself, 2017). In the light of experience to date, it could be asked whether "ungovernability" is potentially an issue of significance which the report could have appropriately addressed (Ungovernability of Sustainable Global Democracy? 2011).
In its appreciative reference to civil society organizations (CSOs), there is a strange irony to their recognition by the Club in that the latter may not see itself as a CSO -- just as in the past it defined itself as a "non-nongovernmental organization" (a non-NGO).
- "Copyright" versus "Copyleft"? The new report, as with its predecessors, is necessarily subject to intellectual property constraints, and the costs of its acquisition -- with the severely restrictive effects on dissemination and uptake of its insights. This issue is predictably avoided in the report, although it features in the discussion of copyleft as the practice of offering people the right to freely distribute copies and modified versions of a work (with the stipulation that the same rights be preserved in derivative works down the line). The more fundamental question is whether the report can claim to be addressing the challenges of a knowledge-based society by restricting the dissemination of its insights in this way. The issue can be discussed metaphorically (Inhibition of creativity through incarceration of knowledge, 2018).
Ironically a systemic approach to the insights engendered by the Club, through some 60 reports (noted above), is inhibited in practice by the intellectual property rights by which the use of each is constrained. Thus a primary factor in enabling the use of text analysis software like Leximancer (mentioned above) is the ability to feed electronic versions of each study through that application. Publishers have been typically resistant to making electronic copies and are even more resistant to allowing their content to be processed in that way and made accessible online -- even though the technical issues of semantic analysis have been largely resolved, enabling concept maps to be automatically generated. On the other hand it is possible that the Club authorities do not want the set of reports to engender a single interactive map. Whilst many are familiar with Google Earth and Google Maps, which have addressed numerous copyright issues, it would appear that the conceptual equivalent has yet to be made available -- an irony in a global knowledge-based civilization.
- "New" versus "Old"? Emphasis is variously placed on the "new" in the report -- highlighting "success stories", and reforming what is considered to be "old" and outdated. In particular, emphasis is placed on a "new narrative" (3.1.1) for a "new enlightenment" (2.10). At the same time there is also concern with the "new hype" of disruptive technologies (1.11.1). Missing is the sense of learning from past failures and insights embodied in the stories of the past. The Jataka Tales, Aesop's Fables and the stories of Nasreddin Hodja are designed to serve simultaneously as children's stories and as carriers of deeper systemic insights for those who can distinguish them (Reframing connectivity through metaphor, 2011).
As yet to be discovered is whether such sets of tales indeed offer, at least implicitly, an adequate cognitive toolkit with which to deal with life's circumstances -- as they may indeed purport to do. As a traditional source of education in many communities, how might "higher education" be distinguished from "meta-education" following exposure to them? How is such education to be compared with that of Russell L. Ackoff (Ackoff's Fables: irreverent reflections on business and bureaucracy, 1991) or that compiled by V. S. M. de Guinzbourg (Wit and Wisdom of the United Nations: proverbs and apothegms on diplomacy, 1961)? These suggest a form of balance to be found between learning from the past and a preoccupation of the Club with ehe future, exemplified by its earlier report (2052: a Global Forecast for the Next Forty Years, 2012). How is a balance to be found between the wisdom of the past and insights of the new -- given the danger of "throwing the baby out with the bathwater"?
Rather than the report's emphasis on education for the future (3.18), more of a challenge is the nature of the "meta-education" offered by exposure to a set of Zen koans -- especially the classic set of 48 in the Mumonkan (¿ Higher Education 8 Meta-education ? Transforming cognitive enabling processes increasingly unfit for purpose, 2011).The balance may well have more to do with the present, as argued in reviewing the 2052 report (Engendering 2052 through Re-imagining the Present, 2012).
- "Answer" versus "Question"? The report is necessarily presented as the latest insightful "answer" from the Club of Rome -- in the light of the questions it has found it appropriate to ask. Missing is any sense of the creative interplay between question and answer The identity of the Club could well be challenged by the question: Am I Question or Answer? Problem or (re)solution? (2006). Is the Club to be understood as an "answer", a "question", both, or neither?
In the enthusiasm for providing answers, is there an avoidance of questions (Question Avoidance, Evasion, Aversion and Phobia, 2006)? Are there questions of a higher order to be discovered -- in order to provide corresponding answers (Engaging with Questions of Higher Order: cognitive vigilance required for higher degrees of twistedness, 2004)? Paradoxically, in order to sustain creativity and innovation, is the issue one of Sustaining the Quest for Sustainable Answers (2003)? And what then of doubt and incomprehension (Living with Incomprehension and Uncertainty: re-cognizing the varieties of non-comprehension and misunderstanding, 2012)?
The online reader of the report allows the potentially trivial query as to how many times "answer" figures in the text (16 times), as well as "question" (26 times). It also enables a query for "?" (83 times). This raises the question as to what proportion of answers there should be to questions in a "healthy" future-oriented strategic report. Could reports be ranked on that basis? Will this be an issue in processing such reports using AI techniques of the future?
With respect to question avoidance, there is the intriguing issue of detecting a "deadly question" which would completely undermine the methodology of the report in enabling its transformation, as discussed separately (World Futures Conference as Catastrophic Question: from performance to morphogenesis and transformation, 2013). What is the question that the new report "cannot afford" to ask? Is there a fundamental "hole" in the argument of the report?
- "Systemic modality" versus "Bulleted modality"? The Club of Rome acquired its reputation from the use of system dynamics, exemplified in The Limits to Growth (1972). As stressed above with regard to methodological bias, the current report could be said to have opted for a "bulleted modality" whereby the segments within the three sections are distinguished. Typically, wherever that modality is used, there is little commitment to highlighting the systemic relations "between the bullets". This distinction has been remarkably clarified in two related articles by John Otto Magee (German directness, American euphemisms: the hell of cross-cultural communication, Handelsblatt, 24 February 2018; Where Germans systematize, Americans break down, Handelsblatt, 20 April 2018).
The latter argues: Germans think systematically. They formulate their understanding of a decision to be made in a very broad and interconnected context. Therefore Germans do not always consider it helpful to take complexity and, as Americans say, "break it down" into its component parts. They aim to do the opposite, to see particulars in their interrelationships. They look for patterns, strive to understand complexity as a whole, as a system.
In those terms, the methodology of the report could be challenged for having adopted an "American" approach -- despite the nationalities of the primary authors. The article clarifies further by distinguishing the processes primarily favoured in German under the terms: Fragestellung (how a question is formulated); Überblick (an overview through understanding a system as a whole); Durchblick (knowing what is discussed, and understanding both the details and the big picture); Umsicht (a "view around" at all tangential topics; a cautionary principle to mitigate risk). The question raised is how to achieve a compromise beween the "German" and the "American" modalities. There are of course other "modalities", as identified separately (Systems of Categories Distinguishing Cultural Biases, 1993). Frequently cited are the 6 dimensions of Geert Hofstede (Culture's Consequences: comparing values, behaviors, institutions, and organizations across nations, 2001). Missing from Magee's summary, but clearly relevant to the concerns of the Club of Rome, are Vorsicht (precautionary attitude or vigilance, notably with respect to any forecast) and Rücksicht (perhaps best understood in terms of learning from the past).
- "Agreement" versus "Disagreement"? As with the articulation of many global strategic initiatives, the report is an invitation -- if not an exhortation -- to "agree" with its insights and recommendations. As presented online, the expression of agreement may take the form of using a "like" button. It criticizes alternative agendas with which many continue to identify. It makes no provision for those who "disagree", except what is implied by arguments for new approaches to education: A consensus of leading educators is emerging who agree that radical change is needed in the global system of education, in order to meet the new and diverse needs of humanity we have been discussing (p. 196).
This is the only indication of the "consensus" required, and the report makes no mention of "disagreement" or "dissent" -- perhaps as being "too negative". Unfortunately this strategic posture reflects only too closely many processes of the past which have failed to engender the levels of consensus they are believed by their advocates to justify. At the time of writing the point is usefully reinforced by a TED Talk (Zachary R. Wood, Why it's worth listening to people you disagree with, April 2018).
Religions, such as Christianity, are only too familiar with this challenge and how it can be met or avoided. Arguably what is missing is a new means of addressing the binary complex of agreement-disagreement in systemic terms (The Consensus Delusion: mysterious attractor undermining global civilization as currently imagined, 2011). It would seem that, so framed, there will always be disagreement and probably necessarily so -- if only as an aspect of the innovation process. There is clearly a need for a more fruitful modality through which to process "likes" and "dislikes" -- especially when there are few online facilities for expressing the latter.
Especially relevant to this dilemma is the condition under which disagreement engenders violence. The authors would be naive in assuming that many vested interests will fail actively to oppose the implementation of its recommendations -- interpreting "enlightenment" according to their own lights, however they are framed as characteristic of "endarkenment".
Neglecting the dynamics of the unenlightened: Highlighting the insight of the Pope through Laudato Si', as noted above, authorizes a relevant papal insight through an apocryphal anecdote:
A group of architects invited the Pope to review their detailed model of a new seminary which he had commissioned. The Pope inspected it for such a time that the architects became very anxious. Finally the Pope turned to them and asked: Will the seminarians be angels?. Receiving the obvious negative reply, the Pope then asked: Well then, where are the toilets?
Should a similar question be addressed to the authors of the new Club of Rome report? For indeed it would seem that little provision is made for the unenlightened and the manner in which they so obviously tend to function in disrupting and corrupting carefully designed models. The extreme paradox is that those of any one discipline or faith typically frame those of any other as ignorant and unenlightened -- or at best misled.
Curiously, given a long-standing degree of opposition to the Club of Rome from non-Western cultures and other regions of the world, little is said of their "disagreement" -- presumably to be framed in terms of a relatively "unenlightened" condition calling for their "education".
Balancing strategic dilemmas: The emphasis placed by the report on the balance exemplified by Yin and Yang suggests that dualities, such as those above, merit articulation in the light of a richer pattern. Indeed it could be argued that the very reference to Yin-Yang in the report reinforces binary thinking -- in the absence of any such articulation.
Achieving a balance between the polar extremes highlighted above can be recognized in terms of the challenge of a set of strategic dilemmas rather than any singular dilemma, notably as highlighted on the occasion of the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro (Systemic Mapping of Strategic Dilemmas, 1992; Sustainability through the Dynamics of Strategic Dilemmas, 2005; Configuration of inter-sectoral strategic dilemmas of sustainability, 2012). The report only refers in passing to the climate dilemma -- and fails to recognize the range of dilemmas requiring balance. How many such dilemmas merit distinction and how are they to be understood systemically?
In citing the need for a necessary balance between "women and men", as exemplifying that need, the Club's collaborators come to the challenge somewhat "late in the day" given the vigorous challenges to gender conventions at this time. This is demonstrated by the controversies associated with the strands of the LGBT movement and the multiple gender identities by which people are now able (or asked) to identify themselves. These indicate how a sense of "balance" is currently elusive rather than simplistic. This dynamic complexity offers one (in)comprehensible frame through which to explore the notion of balance between other more general extremes -- with implications for the balance implied by sustainability.
There is therefore a case for drawing on the 8-fold articulation of that binary pattern -- widely featured in Chinese culture (and some flags) as the BaGua mirror, with its insightful encoding. This can be explored in the light of the challenges of the LGBT dynamics in 2D configurations (Encompassing the "attraction-harassment" dynamic with a notation of requisite ambiguity? 2017).
A corresponding articulation is provided by Edward Haskell (Generalization of the structure of Mendeleev's periodic table, 1972) through which he proposes a coaction cardioid to distinguish in cybernetic terms the patterns of relationship between a "controlling function" and a "work function", as discussed separately (Cardioid Attractor Fundamental to Sustainability: 8 transactional games forming the heart of sustainable relationship, 2005). He notably uses the ecosystemic relationship between species as an example. The understanding of balance is then an emergent feature of the dynamics between the kinds of polar extremes noted above -- recalling the dynamic integrity of the benzene molecule as a resonant hybrid, so fundamental to the organization of organic life.
Haskell's framework suggests the possibility of applying this to psychosocial relationships -- seemingly ever more highly charged, especially since the implications of "control" and "work" are controversially called into question as dynamically reversible (through "resonance"). There is the provocative possibility that the dimensions and senses of Come On! could be articulated by such a framework -- given the interplay between controller (leader) and controllee (follower), reframed by the dynamics to which the LGTB community is now so sensitive.
| Possible 8-fold Positive-Negative Hybrid Conditions (following Haskell) | ||||
| . | . | Y = "Control component" | ||
| . | . | Negative | Neutral | Positive |
| X = "Work component" | Positive | predation (positive negativity) | allotrophy (positive neutrality) | symbiosis (positive positivity) |
| Neutral | amensalism (neutral negativity) | O (neutral neutrality) | commensalism (neutral positivity) | |
| Negative | synnecrosis (negative negativity) | allopathy (negative neutrality) | parasitism (negative positivity) | |
This 8-fold pattern can be compared to that of the BaGua pattern (Patterns Essential to Individual and Global Health? 2010; Adaptive Hypercycle of Sustainable Psychosocial Self-organization: designing a mapping of a Chinese metaphorical pattern language, 2010). The argument, with animated depictions, can be extended to 3D (Patterning psychosocial relationships in 3D or more? 2017; Encoding meaningful psychosocial complexity otherwise, 2018).
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]