Re-dreaming Israel and Palestine -- in my world?


Annexing the World as the Deal of the Century (Part #13)


[Parts: First | Prev | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]


It is only too obvious that "Israel" and "Palestine" are the focus of many dreamers, whatever the compatibility of their dreams. As proposed here the Deal of the Century is the invitation to a degree of dreaming commensurate with the challenge their dynamics currently represent.

One clue, appropriate for the times, is provided by Alexander Wendt (Quantum Mind and Social Science: unifying physical and social ontology, 2015). As an eminent specialist in international relations he introduces his argument with the hypothetical perspective of extraterrestrials scanning the globe. He makes the point that nations states, however bordered or not, cannot be detected from space. In that sense the distinctions between them are non-existent. With this argument it is obviously questionable as to whether "Israel" and "Palestine" "exist" -- except as rather peculiar constructs of the collective imagination of some. This could be understood as a form of dreaming to which a degree of reality has been variously attached -- to the point that that reality is beyond any conventional question. He uses that insight to justify the fundamental insights emerging from understandings of quantum reality.

Somewhat ironically, but indicative of an unexplored flexibiity in such matters, the city of Bielefeld in Germany recently offered a one million euro award to anyone who could prove that the city did not exist (City of Bielefeld offers €1m for proof it doesn't exist, BBC News, 22 August 2019). This possibilty is matched by the more general argument of the philosopher Markus Gabriel (Why the World Does Not Exist, 2015).

Given the degree to which it is not understood, or is variously understood, should quantum mechanics be considered a form of dreaming? Most people have no understanding of its significance. The understanding by physicists is itself variously considered problematic, famously noted by Richard Feynman: Anyone who claims to understand quantum theory is either lying or crazy. The point has been more recently made (Sean Caroll, Even Physicists Don't Understand Quantum Mechanics, The New York Times, 7 September 2019). Arguably this is consistent with dreaming and the incompatibilty of many dreams.

Consistent with the Deal of the Century, there is therefore considerable freedom to imagining and dreaming about how "Israel" and "Palestine" currently "exist" -- have ever "existed", or may "exist" in the future. This extends to the challenge of imagining their relationship, to the extent that both "exist" at the same time. There is little question that many choose to dream of an "Israel" -- especially a Greater Israel -- in which "Palestine" is merely a figment of the imagination. For many the converse would be true -- with "Israel" but a figment of the imagination.

Such considerations have more general implications, given the point made above about the imaginary nature of boundaries to which legal reality has been questionably attached -- and to the "existence" of other entities which are the dramatis personae of international relations (Does America even exist? 31 December 2011; Does America Still Exist?; Richard Rodriguez, Does America Still Exist? Fudan University, 2012). To what extent do the United Nations, the European Union, or NATO "exist"? The point is especially obvious with respect to the existence of the "international community" to which so many appeals are made, and from which intervention is expected in so many situations -- including the relations in the middle East (International Community as God or Sorcerer's Apprentice? 2015). Intriguingly this is contrasted with an even more elusive entity -- the "world community".

Given the proposed Deal of the Century, how should whomever choose to dream about "Israel" and "Palestine" -- separately or together? How does the credibility of any such dream compare with that of fake news and recognition of the surreality of the times and the possibilty of post-truth frameworks? (Surreal nature of current global governance as experienced, 2016)

Dreaming of Israel alone? Clearly many already have a very heavy investment in this dream, reinforced by revelations to which Judaism attributes fundamental and unquestionable significance. This is the Chosen People dream, especially and particularly mandated by deity. The dream necessarily has a tremendous degree of coherence to it -- many having worked on its elaboration, and many continuing to do so. There are presumably few constraints to this dream, with all the peoples of the world being necessarily subsumed by it -- or considered irrelevant to its realization.

This is an example of spiritually inspired full-spectrum dominance -- recognizable as an ambition (or a "commission") of other religions, most notably the Abrahamic religions. There is of coure a degree of complicity with fundamentalists in the USA (and elsewhere) inspired by shared scriptures.

Central to this dream of Israel is the role of Jerusalem and efforts to make it central to global society -- as the Vatican has endeavoured to do within the Catholic Christian dream, and as Mecca has been positioned within the Islamic dream. Efforts to render this dream into a reality i the case of Jersualem are currently obvious in the pressure on nations states to move their embassies there. The dream can be elaborated further through any proposal to move the HQ of the UN to Jerusalem, as separately explored (Symbolic Relocation of United Nations HQ to Jerusalem Vicinity: revitalization of Middle East peace process enabled by US-Israel initiative, 2017). From the perspective of quantum mechanics, and given the skills in that respect in Israel, the dream can be developed further (Jerusalem as a Symbolic Singularity: comprehending the dynamics of hyperreality as a challenge to conventional two-state reality, 2017).

Within this dream, whatever merits recognition as "Palestine" is readily considered as but a "detail of history", essentially irrelevant to the coherence of the dream as a whole.

Dreaming of Palestine alone? As in dreaming of Israel alone, many dream of Palestine alone -- as it was within the arbitrarily framed borders following World War II. The dream is nourished by a sense of traditional land ownership, irrespective of how this may have usurped the religiously founded claims of Israel.

The dream is reinforced by the dreams of some of sweeping "Israel" into the sea -- as a temporal aberration. The dream is further reinforced for the Palestinians by the sense of injustice of which they consider themselves to be victims through the actions of Israel in pursuit of its own dream.

Fundamental to the dream is the possibility of "Free Palestine" or "Greater Palestine" -- free from the yoke of Israel -- although how that freedom might play out in practice is less than evident given the differences between Hamas and Fatah. However, this challenge of the sustainable dynamics of "freedom" is far from having been rendered comprehensible -- as is evident in the case of many countries for which "independence" has proved to be problematic. Although "freedom" is the core of many dreams, the dynamics remain mysterious -- potentially as mysterious as those of dreams of Heaven.

Dreaming of Palestine and Israel "together"? Some have indulged in a dream in which somehow the dreams of "Israel" and "Palestine" coexist. One variant of this dream is framed as a "two-state" modality, of which the most realistic has been the condominium formula, as articulated by John Whitbeck (The Road to Peace Starts in Jerusalem: the condominium solution, Middle East Policy Council, 3, 1994, 3). Examples of such a modality are Andorra and the New Hebrides. The credibility of this dream has eroded with time -- even though there are now many examples of condominium in the case of real estate, and in the use of time-sharing agreements. These are of far greater subtlety than the crude deal recently proposed by Jared Kuhner on behalf of thr USA.

More intriguing are possibilities in which those subscribing to the dream of "Israel" simply fail to include any vestige of "Palestine" in their dream -- whilst those subscribing to the dream of "Palestine" simply fail to recognize the "existence" of Israel. This mode is curiously consistent with the failure of each to give any credence to the deity of the other, even though both are monotheistic. The multiplicity of religions, with their variety of deities, has long established the viability of this in practice -- whatever the dream of each to convert all non-believers in their dream, or simply to eradicate them. The approach can be seen as consistent with "mutual annexation" -- where each blithely ignores the claims through such annexation, much as with respect to the lands of Australia and the reciprocal claim made by Burnum Burnum (as noted above)..

Boundary issues: The challenge to this dream is the importance attached to "boundaries" within each dream -- even though these are effectively figments of the colletive imagination of some reinforced by fiat from their perspective. However dreaming enables each to give primacy to an imagined fiat as a creative feature of the preferred dream. Fundamentally, as argued by Alexander Wendt, any such boundaries do not "exist" -- beyond the willingness to believe in them, or the ability to impose them on others. Many are recogized as the consequence of arbitrary processes -- effectively created by fiat. This suggests the freedom of everyone to establish boundaries however it seems appropriate.

The questionable nature of boundaries is made obvious by the crisis of international migration with the complementary efforts either to override them or to reinforce them. The dynamics are expressed in a realm beyod the rational -- whether or not the future will offer a degree of comprehension through quantum reality and a more sophisticated understanding of the role of any observer. The challenge has been framed as a dyamic between the "headless hearts" and the "heartless heads" (Symbolizing Collective Remembering Otherwise: encompassing the "headless hearts" and "heartless heads" through their dynamic entanglement, 12 March 2018).

One clue to such coexistence is the understanding of superposition -- from the fundamental perspective of quantum reality. This completely reframes any simplisitic undestanding of a "two-state" solution. Within that dream, the relation between "states" is understood quite otherwise.

Myth-making: Another clue is offered by myth-making, given the current credibility of a range of myths, especially to the younger generation (The Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, etc) -- to say nothing of older myths which continue to entance (Mahabharata, Kalevala, etc). Especially noteworthy is the extent to which these myths coexist without any reference to each other. People are free to buy into one or the other. Missing from that emphasis is the freedom that each has to elaborate their own dream -- as is alredy evident to a degree in the elaboration of many online video games -- whether these attract many others or none.

There is little to hinder people in empowering themselves as dramaturges in orchestrating the dynamics between "Israel" and "Palestine" according to their preference -- glorifying or demonising the dramatis personae (Gorbachev: Dramaturge ?! Lessons on social transformation for international organizations from Gorbachev, 1991). A striking element in the success of any such orchestration is the need for an entity which embodies absolute "evil" -- suggesting the provocative possibility that "Israel" and "Palestine" have a fundamental need for each other in order to sustain their sense of identity as the embodiment of the highest values. Any orchestration then needs to explore both alternatives.

A further clue is offered by movements of opinion, readily to be understood as dreams -- which now interweave in a complex manner, most obviously via social media. Although unmapped, the "boundaries" between them are as permeable as weather systems depicted globally on a daily basis in familiar meteorological reports.


[Parts: First | Prev | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]

Subjects: Symbols, Myths