Spiralling transition comprehended through metaphor


Fibonacci Spiral in 3D Framing Psychosocial Phyllotaxis (Part #12)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]


Highlighting the knight's move helps to make another point by recognizing that it is just one metaphor held to be indicative of the nature of a creative process. As such it is readily perceived as alienating, even mechanical by some, despite its conventionally acknowledged advantage in giving a degree of focus to strategic thinking.

The transition, whether out of the constraints of the square, or out of the box -- together with its spiralling nature -- is necessarily better framed by a set of complementary metaphors or images, each with their strengths and weaknesses (Complementary Metaphors of Discourse: towards transformative conferencing and dialogue, 1984).

A similar argument has been made with respect to the strategic response to the pandemic (Alternating between Complementary Images of Coronavirus: requisite variety to enable viable strategic engagement, 2020). The point can however be made more provocatively (Complementary Bullfighting Metaphors of Global Governance: challenge of asymmetric engagement, 2009). Given that none of the metaphor fully encompasses the truth of the matter, it is appropriate to ask how disparate the metaphors need to be in such a set to constitute a requisite variety -- in a cybernetic sense, with its strategic implications (Global Coherence by Interrelating Disparate Strategic Patterns Dynamically, 2019).

The metaphors might include the following, although any such set itself invites creative reframing:

  1. flight-related metaphors, especially the sense of "taking off", "uplift" and "getting into orbit" (as cited in relation to careers and projects) -- exemplified by the contrast made between the symbolism of an eagle and that of a grounded turkey (Counteracting Extremes Enabling Normal Flying: insights for global governance from birds on the wing and the dodo, 2015; Coordination of Wing Deployment and Folding in Politics: bird flight and landing as complementary metaphors of global strategic coherence, 2018)

  2. staircase metaphors, most notably those of spiralling (and counter-spiralling) forms, imaginatively comparable to the double helix, or more complex forms, as noted above (Climbing Elven Stairways: DNA as a macroscopic metaphor of polarized psychodynamics, 2007; Walking Elven Pathways Enactivating the Pattern that Connects, 2006)

  3. musical metaphors, most obviously understood as an array of choirs or voices, as imagined in some religious perspectives of heaven, as poetically rendered by Dante Alighieri in the Divine Comedy -- describing a journey through Hell (Inferno), Purgatory (Purgatorio), and Paradise (Paradiso). Of some relevance is the importance attached to the Trisagion, sung in perpetuity by the 12 Song-Uttering Choirs of angels.

  4. stages of self-reference, with each stage challenging or questioning the articulation of the previous stage and providing a form of template for a subsequent stage

  5. mythical tales, perhaps most notably embodied in the Persian poem of the Conference of the Birds in quest of the Simurgh as the potential ruler of their disparate natures. When the group of birds finally reach the dwelling place of the Simurgh, all they find is a lake in which they see their own reflection mirrored. The cognitive implications of such mirroring can be explored from a strategic perspective (Stepping into, or through, the Mirror: embodying alternative scenario patterns , 2008). The latter noted issues arising from cognitive "glass ceilings" and avoidance of self-reflexivity. The insights to be derived from mirroring can be presented in a more challenging manner (Looking in the Mirror -- at Josef Fritzl ? Global conditions on reflection, 2009).

  6. progressive approximation to closure through a sequence of increasingly subtle agreements -- perhaps exemplified by protracted negotiation, deal-making, and Getting to Yes: negotiating agreement without giving in (1981)

  7. game-playing "levels" are an ever increasing preoccupation in game-playing of all kinds, but most notably in online video gaming (requiring level design), preceded by their role in military and corporate scenario gaming. As noted above, these may offer a sense of "rebirth" (Varieties of Rebirth: distinguishing ways of being "born again", 2004). The 2D construction of the Fibonacci spiral lends itself to the distinction of games of increasing cognitive challenge, as discussed separately (Tao of Engagement -- Weaponised Interactions and Beyond: Fibonacci's magic carpet of games to be played for sustainable global governance, 2010). This invites other possibilities in a 3D context.

  8. knight's move, as indicated above, notably with respect to three-dimensional chess, or its speculative higher dimensional variants

  9. lauburu, as the  4-fold Basque symbol is a geometrical variant of the Swastika symbol offering other insights into the pattern of the knight's move. Especially intriguing is the manner in which this can be understood through an animation in 3D extending to 24 "voices" (24-fold Pattern Implied by Dynamics of the Lauburu in 3D: visualization of the interplay of sets of voices in discourse, 2016)

  10. cycles are readily recognized as closely related to understandings of the cyclic repetition of the spiral form (List of cycles, Wikipedia). Of particular relevance is how the cyclic process is embodied cognitively and strategically, as argued separately (Encycling Problematic Wickedness for Potential Humanity, 2014). As indicated in the discussion of "encirclement chess", particular strategic importance is associated with encirclement in the interplay between opposing forces.

  11. whip dynamics offer a surprising contrast to other metaphors, as exemplified by the sound made by a stockwhip through whipcracking in the process of herding livestock. The sound is produced when a section of the whip moves faster than the speed of sound creating a small sonic boom. The metaphor is of particular interest in relation to social change given that the  Nautilus Institute for Security and Sustainability reframed its understanding of the nautilus spiral form to encompass whip dynamics. With the challenge of the pandemic to the world population so recently reframed in terms of "herd immunity", it might be asked whether it is COVID-19 which could be understood as whipcracking by a metaphorical stockwhip -- or whether any global crisis is of that nature. Arguably this may be the preferred metaphor for leaders with a dictatorial bias.

  12. patterns of N-foldness, through which society indicates preferences for various forms of order and the complexity calling for comprehension. This is exemplified by 30, as with the set of articles in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. It is appropriate to note that the 30-edged icosahedron used for mapping that set is central to the cybernetic argument of Stafford Beer (Beyond Dispute: the invention of team syntegrity, 1994). Given that role, it is appropriate to note that the dihedral angle at 138.19 is a surprisingly close approximation to the golden angle of 137.5 -- with the icosahedron being unique among the Platonic solids in possessing a dihedral angle greater than 120. Curiously the "si" of Simurgh is indicative of the thirty-fold set of species represented in the Conference of the Birds, each reflective of an inhibiting human weakness -- with the potential irony of its occurrence in the title of the Papal Encyclical in response to climate change (Laudato si', 2015). The latter features prominently in a recent study for the Club of Rome, as separately reviewed (Exhortation to We the Peoples from the Club of Rome Review of "Come On! -- Capitalism, Short-termism, Population and the Destruction of the Planet", 2018).

Consistent with the last metaphor, a 12-fold set of disparate metaphors is presented above. This helps to focus the question of how many metaphors are required to render the strategic challenge comprehensible and under what circumstances -- in the light of the as yet unexplained preferences in practice for N-fold sets of particular scope (Checklist of 12-fold Principles, Plans, Symbols and Concepts , 2011; Eliciting a 12-fold Pattern of Generic Operational Insights: Recognition of memory constraints on collective strategic comprehension, 2011). Other preferences include a 20-fold pattern (Requisite 20-fold Articulation of Operative Insights? Checklist of web resources on 20 strategies, rules, methods and insights, 2018).

In constructing an approximation to the Fibonacci spiral in 3D (in the exercise above), the curve was framed by a stack of 12 cubes. One representation of the levels of spiral dynamics distinguishes 12 such levels by 12 colours -- indicative of a progression of insight and an implication of higher degrees of integrity. As suggested above with respect to distinctive "voices", these can of course be understood in mythical terms as the requisite number of distinctive "angelic" voices -- or even as Stations of the Cross, variously distinguished in Christianity as numbering up to 14.

As with the tuning systems of music, it is however characteristic of the dynamic that there are strong differences of opinion on the number of levels and colours preferred in interpretations of psychosocial spirals -- most obviously between an 8-fold pattern and a 12-fold pattern (Frank Visser, A More Adequate Spectrum of Colors: a comparison of color terminology in Integral Theory, Spiral Dynamics and Chakra-Psychology, Integral World).

As implied by the conclusion of the Conference of the Birds, part of the challenge with any such set is to reframe any elitist sense of a progression "upwards" or "inwards" which has the effect of engendering alternative perspectives "left behind" or otherwise "remaindered" (Reintegration of a Remaindered World: cognitive recycling of objects of systemic neglect, 2011). As noted above by citing the poem of T. S. Eliot, it is a case of arriving "where we started" -- in order to "know the place for the first time".

The set of metaphors could then be reframed to ensure that any spiralling transition recovers or revisits the point of departure -- as featured in myths of eternal return. In geometric terms, use can be made of helicoidal spirals (Psychosocial Learnings from the Spiral Form of Hurricanes: implications of the triple helix and the 3-fold triskelion as "cognitive cyclones"? 2017; Framing Cyclic Revolutionary Emergence of Opposing Symbols of Identity: biomimetic embedding of N-tuple helices in spherical polyhedra, 2017; Visualization in 3D of Dynamics of Toroidal Helical Coils, 2016).

Challenge of "growth": In the case of plants, phyllotaxis is intimately related to growth. Any presentation of the Fibonacci spiral, as an indication of growth through some form of "psychosocial phyllotaxis", calls for some kind of reconciliation between exponential -- if not unending -- growth. The problematic nature of such understanding is only too evident in criticism of unconstrained economic growth and the commitment to its future enhancement.

Of interest with respect to the spiral form depicted in 3D is the implication that this might more fruitfully be understood as intensive rather than extensive. This would be consistent with insights regarding its higher dimensionality as explored by physicists in terms of compactification, or the understanding of implication in contrast to explication, as articulated by David Bohm (Wholeness and the Implicate Order, 1980).


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]

Subjects: Symbols, Myths · Comprehension