Optimization of psychosocial “light capture”


Fibonacci Spiral in 3D Framing Psychosocial Phyllotaxis (Part #6)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]


Screenshots from Phylotaxis -- an interactive display presenting "science" and "culture" as extremes
by Jonathan Harris for Seed Magazine
"Science" Seed organization "Culture"
Phylotaxis: science? Phylotaxis: seeds Phylotaxis : culture?

So framed, as in nature, this offers the possibility of highlighting the strange dynamics between those in quest of insight and anxious to assert the particular value of their discoveries in what may  become a highly competitive environment. As is only too evident, whether in the ideological or religious domains, those imbued with insight readily claim its unique nature and qualify other claims as secondary -- if not dangerous. The claim to have "grasped it" merits careful reflection (Beyond Harassment of Reality and Grasping Future Possibilities: learnings from sexual harassment as a metaphor, 1996).

Civilization could be said to have demonstrated total and complete inability to address this challenge. A degree of exception to this assertion is to be found in the case of innovation embodied in patents. This claim to property is obviously also evident in the case of land and claims to mineral exploitation rights. However any generalization as "intellectual property" extends primarily to artistic works and writing -- copyright -- but is highly problematic in the case of "cultural property", as is evident in the case of that of indigenous cultures.

There is the intriguing possibility of an analogy between photosynthesis in plants and the manifestation in psychosocial reality of intellectual products -- intellectual property. The necessity of light for photosynthesis is obvious, just as is creative inspiration -- if not revelation -- for intellectual products. Whilst the processes of photosynthesis are reasonably well understood (although questionably replicable), those of creativity and innovation remain relatively mysterious. Phyllotaxis according to the Fibonacci pattern enables that in plants. Yet to be clarified is the optimal distribution of psychosocial elements to best enable creativity and learning -- especially as it relates to collective learning of relevance to governance

It is from that perspective that the current organization of parliamentary and other assemblies can be usefully challenged -- especially with any visual comparison with exemplars of optimal distribution in nature, as discussed separately with the following images (Global Governance Communication, 2010; Towards an Appropriate Architecture of Global Conference Communication, 2010). The challenge of "insight capture" in such contexts then merits comparison with "light capture" by plants (Technical facilitation of insight capture and processing, 2019).

Organization of insight processing appropriate to global governance?
European Parliament (Strasbourg) United Nations General Assembly (New York)
European Parliament in Strasbourg United Nations General Assembly in New York

***

Pattern of representative global insight organization and dissemination
-- possible alternative appropriately inspired by the Golden Mean?
Sunflower showing organization of seeds Schematic layout of a sunflower from an Excel spreadsheet
Sunflower showing organization of seeds
(Flower Patterns and Fibonacci Numbers,
Mathematics and Knots, U.C.N.W., Bangor, 1996 - 2002;
S. Douady et Y. Couder,
La physique des spirales végétales, La Recherche, janvier 1993)
Fibonacci Numbers and Nature:
Why is the Golden section the "best" arrangement?
2009 by Ron Knott
Schematic layout of a sunflower from an Excel spreadsheet with a slider to alter the turns-per-seed on an interactive chart to show to enable recognition of the best distribution of 2000 seeds on a seedhead.

Fibonacci global map? Of potential value in the quest for meaningful global governance is the equidistant distribution of points on a sphere in the light of the Fibonacci pattern -- and any implication of phyllotaxis:

The set of hexagrams of the I Ching can be understood as indicative of distinctive conditions of governance and change, and the associated psychodynamic tensions, as discussed separately (Designing Global Self-governance for the Future: patterns of dynamic integration of the netherworld, 2010; Harmonics of "globalization": a universal constant?, 2010). As reproduced there, the spherical distribution of those conditions by József Drasny (The Image of the Cosmos in the I Ching: the Yi-globe (2007) could merit reconsideration in this light.

As variously explored, with COVID-19 now constituting a major threat to global civilization, there is a strange irony to the probability that the protein spikes on the virus, as so widely depicted, are distributed around its spherical form according to a Fibonacci pattern (Reimagining Coronavirus in 3D as a Metaphor of Global Society in Distress, 2020; Spike-endowed Global Civilization as COVID-19, 2020; Cognitive Engagement with Spike Dynamics of a Polyhedral Coronavirus, 2020).

Patent organization: Of potential relevance to this argument is the triple helix model of innovation, inspired as it is by the structure of DNA -- and subsequently extended into quadruple helix and quintuple helix models. The associated spirals are discussed below.

Unrelated to the triple helix model as such, studies of innovation patterns as represented by patents include that of Inga Ivanova and Loet Leydesdorff:

Using time series of US patents per million inhabitants, knowledge-generating cycles can be distinguished. These cycles partly coincide with Kondratieff long waves. The changes in the slopes between them indicate discontinuities in the knowledge-generating paradigms. The knowledge-generating paradigms can be modeled in terms of interacting dimensions (for example, in university-industry-government relations) that set limits to the maximal efficiency of innovation systems. The maximum values of the parameters in the model are of the same order as the regression coefficients of the empirical waves. The mechanism of the increase in the dimensionality is specified as self-organization which leads to the breaking of existing relations into the more diversified structure of a fractal-like network. This breaking can be modeled in analogy to 2D and 3D (Koch) snowflakes. The boost of knowledge generation leads to newly emerging technologies that can be expected to be more diversified and show shorter life cycles than before. Time spans of the knowledge-generating cycles can also be analyzed in terms of Fibonacci numbers. This perspective allows for forecasting expected dates of future possible paradigm changes. In terms of policy implications, this suggests a shift in focus from the manufacturing technologies to developing new organizational technologies and formats of human interactions (Knowledge-generating Efficiency in Innovation Systems: the relation between structural and temporal effects, arxiv, February 2015) [emphasis added]

The authors produced an earlier study on: The Efficiency of Triple-Helix Relations in Innovation Systems: measuring the connection between a country's net income and its knowledge base, SSRN Electronic Journal, January 2015). Subsequently Inga Ivanova produced a study specifically focused on the Fibonacci pattern (The Dynamics of Financial Markets: Fibonacci numbers, Elliott waves, and solitons, December 2019).

A provocative question then arises from this nexus of preoccupations. Is the exponential production of knowledge -- in terms of patents and intellectual property, its organization, and the distribution of the embodied insight -- appropriate to a civilization in crisis? Typically most insight of any value is subject to copyright, security classification, or paywalls -- irrespective of how vital it might be to any remedial response.

This is evident in the competitive production of some 320 vaccines in response to COVID-19 -- primarily evoked by the profits to be made. Provocatively it might be asked whether preoccupation with self-organization, from the perspective of stigmergy, addresses this process through the production of copyrighted papers.

Understood as a process of "psychosocial photosynthesis", absolute priority is consequently given to the reification and commodification of creativity and insight, as variously criticised (Dustin Kidd, Commodification and Creativity: a review of Tyler Cowen's Creative Destruction, The Hedgehog Review, Summar 2003; Jeremy Gilbert, Against the Commodification of Everything: anti-consumerist cultural studies in the age of ecological crisis, Cultural Studies, 22, 2008, 5).

New thinking: The desperate appeals for "new thinking" in times of crisis occur in a context of highly competitive focus on patent registration as being indicative of "innovation". This merits recognition within the underlying context clarified with many case studies by Thierry Gaudin (L'écoute des silences: les institutions contre l'innovation, 1978). The author's reference to silence merits consideration in the light of the literature on the spiral of silence and the role of such silence (Alain Corbin, History of Silence: de la Renaisance à nos jours, 2018).

With respect to expectation of social innovation, the argument is presented most succinctly by Stafford Beer as a form of Le Chatelier's Principle:

Reformers, critics of institutions, consultants in innovation, people in sort who "want to get something done", often fail to see this point. They cannot understand why their strictures, advice or demands do not result in effective change. They expect either to achieve a measure of success in their own terms or to be flung off the premises. But an ultrastable system (like a social institution)... has no need to react in either of these ways. It specialises in equilibrial readjustment which is to the observer a secret form of change requiring no actual alteration in the macro-systemic characteristics that he is trying to do something about (The Cybernetic Cytoblast: management itself. Chairman's Address to the International Cybernetics Congress, September 1969)

There is a case for adapting insights from the extensive studies of competitive light capture by plants, as reviewed by Marina Semchenko, et al:

Competition for light is size-asymmetric due to the unidirectional nature of sunlight. Slightly faster growth and larger body size confers a disproportionate advantage to a competing plant by simultaneously increasing its own light capture and its shading of smaller competitors... As a result, above-ground competition can lead to the competitive exclusion of smaller or slower-growing individuals and play a decisive role in community structuring (Positive effect of shade on plant growth: amelioration of stress or active regulation of growth rate? Journal of Ecology, 100, 2011, 2)

With respect to innovation in science, the challenge has been expressed otherwise by Max Planck:

A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it.

Organization of insightful knowledge? It is curious to note the relatively simplistic approaches to the actual organization of insight, as evident in the various classifications of subjects in information systems. This raises the question as to whether the vast resources of mathematics, with its complex insights into relationships, are organized in the most fruitful manner to enable their comprehension and application, as argued separately (Is the House of Mathematics in Order? Are there vital insights from its design, 2000).

Potentially valuable in this respect is the efforts expended to organize the chemical elements, evident in the many alternative representations of the periodic table of chemical elements. Analogous forms of periodicity may yet be discovered in the organization of knowledge, as separately argued (Towards a Periodic Table of Ways of Knowing -- in the light of metaphors of mathematics, 2009). A similar argument might be made in the light of the standard model of particle organization (Beyond the Standard Model of Universal Awareness: Being Not Even Wrong? 2010), especially given the explorations of physics in that regard (Physics beyond the Standard Model, Wikipedia).

In the study of phyllotaxis, consideration is given to time periodic models (The Mathematics of Phyllotaxis). Is there any basis for a pattern of phyllotaxis in the organization and comprehension of knowledge? This might be suggested by detection of Fibonacci numbers in the periodic table, as variously explored:

Of the thousands of noted periodic tables in the INTERNET Database of Periodic Tables, some 68 take spiral form, potentially reflective of such organization (for example, Imran Ali, et al, Advanced spiral periodic classification of the elements, Chemistry International, 3, 2017, 3). A "spiral periodic table-mandala based on the pattern of phyllotaxis" has been provisionally presented by Dmitry Weise (Archetypes of Periodic Law).

Organization of antenna, metaphorical and otherwise: Attention to the detection and reception of insight in any environment may well be described using "antenna" as a metaphor, although little is then said about how these may be organized or deployed. The organization of petals and leaves on plants could well be described as functioning in some manner as antenna.

From a general systems perspective, it is therefore of interest to explore how the extremely well developed mathematics of radio antenna design is comparable with phyllotaxis in plants. One study which explores a degree of similarity is that of Italo Mario Fabbri (The Spiral Solenoids and the Leaf Antenna in Phyllotaxis Differential Geometry, University of Milan, 2018), using the common metaphorical reference to a "leaf coil" in conjunction with a sense of phyllotaxis:

The fundamental spiral coil named leaf coil is obtained by joining together the so called forward and backward spiral coils which define the new concept of the differential geometry of phyllotaxis. The other spiral coils are composed of symmetrically rotated leaf coils, combined together in such a way to eliminate the transverse magnetic components along the longitudinal z axis

Reference to "phyllotactic" arrangement is a feature of discussion of antenna design (Jean-Christophe Angevain, et al, Phyllotactic arrangements of reflector mesh facets to decrease grating lobes,  9th European Conference on Antennas and Propagation, 2015). A related possibility is the subject of a patent (Aidan Rhys Dwyer, et al, Photovoltaic array utilizing phyllotaxic architecture, US20120260967A1, 2012).


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]

Subjects: Cybernetics · Psychology