Variety of suggestions for construction of the Fibonacci spiral in 3D


Fibonacci Spiral in 3D Framing Psychosocial Phyllotaxis (Part #8)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]


The geometric construction of an approximation to the Fibonacci spiral in 2D is widely referenced. It could be readily assumed that the principles of such construction could be extended to 3D -- if not to higher dimensions. Criticism of that approach was however noted above.

It is therefore appropriate to note the very extensive literature survey and commentary by M. Nagy, S. R. Cowell and V. Beiu  (Survey of Cubic Fibonacci Identities: when cuboids carry weight. arxiv, 18 February 2019; Survey of Cubic Fibonacci Identities: when cuboids carry weight. arxiv, 18 February 2019). This was initially presented to the 7th International Conference on Computers Communications and Control , 2018) under a slightly different title (Are 3D Fibonacci spirals for real?: From science to arts and back to science, 2018):

This paper is aiming to start an investigation on possible extensions of the classical Fibonacci spiral (2D) to three dimensions (3D). Our goal is to understand if and how 3D spirals, which are called or linked to Fibonacci, are in fact supported mathematically. Our inspiration here has been the 2D Padovan spiral for which a 3D extension is known. The classical 2D Fibonacci spiral is generated on a particular tiling of the 2D space with squares which follow a well-known Fibonacci identity. In this paper we shall analyze quite a few 3D spirals. The main conclusion is that the search for a 3D Fibonacci spiral is left wanting, as none of the 3D spirals we were able to find is backed by a Fibonacci identity describing a recurrent tiling of the 3D space (similar to the recurrent tiling in 2D). Still, this paper has set the stage for the construction of 3D Fibonacci spirals by showing that for distinguishing different tilings of the 3D space a thorough understanding of homogenous Fibonacci cubic identities is compulsory. [emphasis added]

Given that conclusion, questions can be usefully asked about the many references to "spiral" of psychosocial relevance, most notably those of spiral dynamics and the spiral of silence. In the former case, for which there are many images available on the web, are typically structured with indicative colours,(about which there is much controversy). In the latter case very little structuring is indicated, the implication being only that it takes the form of a vortex.

There are of course many different spirals with which psychosocial development might presumably be associated. The Nagy survey notes that that there may be many variants of the Fibonacci spiral itself. Some 30 spirals that have been defined mathematically are listed by Wikipedia (List of Spirals). Of interest, for example, is the argument for the relevance of a 3D spiral in cardiac studies (Davide Piccini, et al, Spiral Phyllotaxis: the natural way to construct a 3D radial trajectory in MRI, Magnetic Resonance in Medicine, 66, 2011, 4):

The pattern known as "spiral phyllotaxis" is an eye-catching arrangement, consisting of two sets of spirals forming a lattice. This pattern can be identified in a great number of plants and flowers, where the visible spirals going clockwise and counter-clockwise are typically associated with two successive elements of the Fibonacci sequence. In these cases, the angle between successive leaves is always close to the golden angle. Extensive studies on spiral phyllotaxis and its mathematical properties have been reported in many scientific fields within natural sciences..., theoretical sciences..., and also engineering applications....

The argument here assumes that the role of the Fibonacci spiral in nature suggests an especially fundamental role which is likely to be of relatively greater relevance to psychosocial development than other spirals. The memorability of any spiral pattern may be all the greater if it is reminiscent of spirals in nature. It is therefore appropriate to assume that the metaphoric use of spiral in spiral dynamics and the spiral of silence could be usefully articulated through the Fibonacci spiral -- justifying further exploration of its representation in 3D.


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]

Subjects: Construction · Form