Population decimation: clarification of terminology
Challenge of Nonviolent Population Decimation (Part #9)
[Parts: First | Prev | All] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
There are several ways in which the term "decimation" is used or understood:
- most commonly it is currently used in the sense of mass destruction, massacre or annihilation, whether of people or animals (as in the case of the North American buffalo). It is notably used in relation to the probable impact of weapons of mass destruction or other forms of catastrophe currently anticipated (shortage of food, etc). A reduction of the population to a tenth of its original number may be inferred, but only in the loosest sense.
- it was used to describe a form of military punishment used in the Roman Army whereby one soldier in ten was selected by lot and killed by the other nine. In this case, decimation derives from Latin meaning "removal of a tenth". An obsolete non-economic, juridical sense of "tithing", bears some relation to this process.
- in digital signal processing, decimation is a technique of "downsampling" to reduce the number of samples in a discrete-time signal. The amount of that reduction, not necessarily a tenth, is precisely defined by a decimation factor (the ratio of the input rate to the output rate).
- in statistics, where "population" refers to the size of any data sample, a "population decimation operator" may be used to shrink the population size (i.e. it "decimates" the population). As with the previous case (of which it is effectively a generalization), the degree of shrinkage is determined by a decimation factor, that does not necessarily result in a shrinkage of any given percentage (whether ten percent or ninety percent)
There are therefore three possible kinds of confusion regarding "decimation". Firstly as to whether it implies destruction of some lifeform or whether it has a more general significance. Secondly as to whether it implies reduction by ten percent of the original amount, or reduction to ten percent of that amount (namely the elimination of 90 per cent). Thirdly as to whether the term is in anyway specifically related to "ten" or is merely used in an indicative manner.
Whereas the English language has a verb for reduction by half (halve), no such verb appears to exist to indicate reduction to a third, a quarter or a tenth. Verbs do of course exist to indicate splitting into thirds (trisect, trifurcate) or quarters (quadrisect, quarter), but without any implication that only one part would then remain.
No such verbs appear to exist for larger numbers, notably to indicate reduction to a tenth (with a degree of exception in the case of tithe). "Decimation" is used to imply such a reduction in the first case, but it is primarily associated with indiscriminate annihilation rather than any specific reduction in numbers. In the second case, it is used extremely precisely but to indicate removal of one tenth, leaving the remainder, namely a reduction of ten percent -- rather than ninety percent (as might have been inferred in the first case). In both cases the focus is on killing. In the third and fourth cases, although disassociated from violence to life in any form, "decimation" is only indicative of a reduction that has then to be precicely defined by a "decimation factor".
It is clearly problematic to use "decimation" to refer to any reduction in the size of the human population, since it is readily assumed that this implies the first case, namely involving violent killing in some form. The expression "population decimation" might also be understood as a consequence of some form of global birth control strategy. There is no clear term to indicate a reduction in height by ninety percent. Even statistical use of "decimation" calls for stipulation of the "decimation factor".
These somewhat confusing subtleties mean that the title of the above recommendation as "Nonviolent Population Decimation" needs to be understood in context to mean reduction in the average height of the population to ten percent of the current size. Use of the qualifier "nonviolent" should preclude any sense that deliberate killing is implied.
One of the advantages of the recommendation is that it specifically provides for a continuing uncontrolled increase in population numbers as required by many religions and human desire -- irrespective of whether this results in catastrophic decimation in population numbers. For example, climate scientist, James Lovelock expects the traumatized planet to be capable of supporting less than a tenth of its 6 billion world's population by 2100 (reducing it to some 500 million by annihilation of some kind), because the necessary remedial measures will not be in implemented in time (Decca Aitkenhead, Enjoy life while you can, The Guardian, 1 March 2008; Jeremy Lovell, Gaia Scientist Lovelock Predicts Planetary Wipeout, 2008). It is also the case that many religions favouring population increase expect some form of Armageddon long before that -- and live in expectation of such end times, supporting faith-based governance to that end. Whichever the case, each is considered as an inevitable, violent form of population decimation -- whether or not the violence is understood as deliberately engineered (see Spontaneous Initiation of Armageddon: a heartfelt response to systemic negligence, 2004)
In this nonviolent recommendation, however, it is not the number of people that is decimated but their height. However, as implied by Lovelock and seemingly intended by major religions, the current strategy could indeed be understood as "nonviolent population decimation" since the violence of that decimation is only a consequence of an essentially nonviolent strategy of avoiding the issue of overpopulation.
| Human size reduction is a viable long-term response to climate change whether Warming OR Cooling |
| Why aren't we gene editing people to be my size? (BBC News, 3 February 2017) The actress Kiruna Stamell who has dwarfism. She tells the Today programme society should be working to make it easier for people to live with a disability and wonders why for global warming's sake we aren't gene editing people to be her size. |
Anthony Watts, Where have all the sunspots gone? (February 2008): Given the current quietness of the sun and it's magnetic field, combined with the late start to cycle 24 with even possibly a false start, it appears that the sun has slowed it's internal dynamo to a similar level such as was seen during the Dalton Minimum. One of the things about the Dalton Minimum was that it started with a skipped solar cycle, which also coincided with a very long solar cycle 4 from 1784-1799. The longer our current cycle 23 lasts before we see a true ramp up of cycle 24, the greater chance it seems then that cycle 24 will be a low one. This explains recent discussion about global cooling. http://www.swpc.noaa.gov/SolarCycle/ If the converging cycles are the proximate causal factors, there is a real possibility of a "skipped solar cycle" or an average sunspot maximum being the lowest since the 1790s-1820s. Combine the effects of global cooling with "Peak Oil", i.e., peak production of cheap fossil fuels, and the prospects for the coming decades are rather grim, indeed. |
---
The question is which of the above interpretations of
Nonviolent Population Decimation
is the more ridiculous as a "strategy" for humanity at this time?
| Film development of the above possibility -- Downsizing (2017) |
Downsizing is a 2017 American science fiction comedy film which tells the story of Paul and Audrey Safranek, a couple who decide to undertake a newly invented procedure to shrink their bodies so they can start a new life in an experimental community. When Audrey refuses the procedure at the last minute, Paul has to reassess his life and choices after befriending an impoverished activist. Downsizing premiered at the 74th Venice International Film Festival on August 30, 2017, and was theatrically released in the United States by Paramount Pictures on December 22, 2017. In the future, searching for a way to solve overpopulation and global warming, Dr. Jørgen Asbjørnsen invents "downsizing", a process to shrink people to a height of five inches (12.7 cm); he and his wife Anne-Helene become part of the first human test subjects once the process is proven safe and demonstrate it to the world. While the inventors advocate that downsizing is environmentally friendly through the reduction of waste, protagonists argue that its benefits extend far beyond that and improve one's life through the increase in value of their money. The film is included in the Wikipedia List of films featuring miniature people Reviews:
|
[Parts: First | Prev | All] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
Subjects: Nomenclature · Population