Implication for academic disciplines of the “sex life” of their practitioners


Implication of Mathematics in Human Experience from an AI Perspective (Part #3)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]


Given the wide variety of surveys conducted in relation to sex, seemingly missing is a survey of the "sex life" of practitioners of particular disciplines -- with the implications for their practice. An unexpected example is offered by one of the most influential economists (Sean O'Grady, The amazing sex life of economist John Maynard Keynes, Financial Review, 17 March 2015). Curiously that discipline has resulted in studies of sexual economics, as originally proposed by Roy F. Baumeister and Kathleen D. Vohs, Sexual Economics: sex as female resource for social exchange in heterosexual interactions, Personality and Social Psychology Review. 8, 2004, 4). This relates to how participants think, feel, behave and give feedback during sex or relevant sexual events. With sex defined as a marketplace deal, the theory states that the thinking, preferences and behavior of men and women follow the fundamental economic principles.

Irrespective of political persuasion, there is a remarkable possibility that Keynes could be said to have been instrumental in justifying the appropriateness of the presence of sex workers ("escorts") at international summits with a socioeconomic focus -- as notably reported with respect to the World Economic Forum and the St Petersburg International Economic Forum, and discussed separately (Jack Newman, Prostitutes gather in Davos for annual meeting of global elite - where demand for sexual services rockets during economic summit, Daily Mail, 18 January 2023; Riley Waggaman, SPIEF ’24: Multipolar World Order converges on St. Petersburg to take PCR tests and chat about sustainable development, OffGuardian, 5 June 2024). Especially ironic are the extensive considerations of "sex work" by the European Parliament -- whose members have long been documented as benefitting from that facility (Andrew Rettman, MEPs urge Strasbourg sex trade pledge, EUobserver, 25 September 2008).

Question to ChatGPT: Do you have any trace of studies of the "sex life" of practitioners of any disciplines listed in this exchange -- in the light of recognition of the "amazing sex life" of John Maynard Keynes, and the influence it may have had on his practice of economics

The exploration of John Maynard Keynes' personal life, particularly his sex life, and its influence on his economic theories is a topic of both curiosity and scholarly interest, though it is not extensively covered in the academic literature directly relating to his economic contributions. While there are numerous studies on Keynes' economic theories and methodologies, specific insights into how his personal life, including his sex life, may have influenced his economic thoughts are less frequently addressed in academic papers. Here’s a synthesis of the information available:

  • General Influence on Economic Thought: There is acknowledgment that John Maynard Keynes was a complex figure whose personal and professional lives were deeply intertwined. His broad interests and personal experiences undoubtedly shaped his perspectives and intellectual approaches [Barkin Cihanli, On the Evolution of Keynes' Economic Thought, SSRN, 2021]
  • Limited Direct Analysis: Direct analysis linking Keynes' sex life with his economic theories is scarce. Most academic work focuses on his economic methodologies and philosophies without delving deeply into his personal life as a direct influence on these theories. For example, works like "Keynes et ses combats" focus on his multifaceted professional life and battles within the realms of economics, philosophy, and politics, rather than on personal relationships or sexual experiences [Maxime Ouellet, Keynes et ses combats, Canadian Journal of Political Science, 2007]
  • Cultural and Philosophical Influences: Some discussions about Keynes' broader cultural and social engagements suggest that his personal philosophies, possibly influenced by his personal life, affected his views on economics and society. However, these discussions rarely provide a direct causal link between his sexual orientation or experiences and his professional work.
  • Biographical Accounts: While not strictly academic, biographical accounts of Keynes' life sometimes discuss his personal life and relationships more openly and speculate on their impact on his views and writings. These accounts often portray a picture of a man whose personal and professional lives were richly entangled, with his progressive and sometimes unconventional views reflecting both his personal experiences and his economic thinking.

In conclusion, while John Maynard Keynes' personal life, including his relationships and possibly his sex life, was undoubtedly a significant aspect of his identity, the direct impact of these factors on his economic theories is not extensively documented in the economic literature. The academic focus remains primarily on his contributions to economic theory and practice, with personal aspects noted more in biographical rather than analytical contexts.

Question to ChatGPT: That response focuses solely on Keynes whereas the question related to the array of academic disciplines and their practitioners

Exploring how the personal experiences, including the sex lives of practitioners across various academic disciplines, influence their professional practice reveals a complex and nuanced landscape. The studies highlighted provide some insights but generally focus on specific professional contexts rather than a broad academic survey across disciplines:

  • Sexologists as Educators: A study on the role of sexologists as educators highlights their influence as agents of social change, suggesting that their personal experiences and understanding of sexuality could significantly impact their professional effectiveness and perspectives [Sofia Achem et al., El Rol del Sexologo como Educador Sexual, Revista De La SASH, 4, 2023,2]
  • Sex Education Teachers: Another study, "Sexing the Subject," discusses the link between practitioners' sexual history and their teaching methods in sex education, emphasizing how personal experiences of educators impact their pedagogical approaches and potentially the educational outcomes [M. Kehily, Sexing the Subject: Teachers, pedagogies and sex education, Sex Education, 2, 2002, 3]
  • Professional Life and Sexual Experience: Research by Verónica Policarpo examines the interplay between professional life and sexual experience among Portuguese individuals, shedding light on how professionals navigate their personal and professional spheres, which could influence how they manage professional responsibilities and personal identities (Verónica Policarpo, Sex life under fire: impacts of working life on the construction of the sexual experience, Sociologia, 89, 2019)
  • Sexuality in Healthcare and Social Work: The impact of sexuality in healthcare and social assistance relationships is explored in a study focusing on how professionals deal with the sexual lives of individuals they care for. This interaction undoubtedly shapes professional practices and could influence how these professionals view and integrate notions of sexuality into their work [Pierre Moulin, The Construction of Sexuality in Health and Social Work Professionals or the Normalization of Layman Behaviors, Nouvelle revue de psychosociologie, 4, 2007, 2]

These studies suggest that while direct research connecting the sex lives of academics across all disciplines with their professional work is limited, there is evidence within specific fields, such as sexology and education, that personal experiences with sexuality do impact professional perspectives and practices. The influence is seen mostly in fields directly related to human behavior and social interactions, where personal understandings of sexuality can profoundly affect professional conduct and the framing of educational content. This intersection underscores the importance of considering personal dimensions when evaluating professional roles and contributions in fields dealing with human relationships and societal norms.

That response (and the references offered) would appear to suggest the limited exploration of the relevance to other disciplines.

By contrast, in his discussion of Marie Curie (known for her pioneering research on radioactivity), Tom Wilkie argues that the private lives of scientists reveal much about the way they work and the discoveries they make (The secret sex life of Marie Curie, The Independent, 13 June 1995). The practice of a discipline may even be upheld as "better than sex" (What’s so sexy about math?- A TED Talk by Award-winning mathematician Cédric Villani, Medium, 3 December 2019; Donald C. Benson, The Moment of Proof: mathematical epiphanies, Oxford University Press, 1999). Relevant comments have been evoked by a question to Quora (What are the sex lives of mathematicians and physicists like?)

Question to ChatGPT: The quest for such traces might be more fruitful if it focused on recognition of the "passionate" engagement with sex of practitioners of academic disciplines, as with the case of Marie Curie

Exploring the passionate engagement of practitioners across various academic disciplines with their work, often analogized to sexual passion due to the intense dedication and love for their fields, yields interesting insights. Here are some thoughts and potential studies that touch on this aspect, although direct studies focusing specifically on the sexual lives of practitioners like Marie Curie and its impact on their scientific work are scarce:

  • Passionate Engagement in Science: Historical accounts and biographical studies of figures like Marie Curie suggest that their devotion to their work can be compared to a form of passion often seen in personal relationships. This analogy highlights the deep emotional engagement and tireless dedication they had toward advancing their fields, which can be metaphorically likened to the dynamics of a romantic relationship [Bernard Simon Talmey, Love; a Treatise On the Science of Sex-Attraction].
  • Impact on Pedagogy and Practice: In fields like sex education, the personal experiences and passions of educators can significantly influence their teaching methods and how they engage with students. This interaction not only affects educational outcomes but also shapes the pedagogical approaches adopted by educators [m. Kehily, Sexing the Subject: Teachers, pedagogies and sex education, Sex Education, 2, 3]
  • Professional Life and Sexuality: Studies focusing on professions that deal directly with human behavior, such as sexology, often explore how personal beliefs and experiences with sexuality influence professional practices. These studies can provide insights into how personal dimensions of sex and relationships impact professional decisions and patient interactions in fields like healthcare and social work [Kevin Reel, Sexuality in Rehabilitation: Supporting Canadian Practitioners Conceptually Towards Client Enablement, Canadian Journal of Bioethics, 1, 2018, 3]
  • Cultural and Ethical Considerations: The integration of personal experiences with professional responsibilities can be particularly pronounced in fields dealing with intimate aspects of human life, such as nursing or sexology. The practitioners' own views on sexuality and relationships could profoundly influence how they approach topics like sexual health and patient care Sofia Achem et al., El Rol del Sexologo como Educador Sexual, Revista De La SASH, 4, 2023,2]

While the direct correlation between the sex lives of academic practitioners and their professional efficacy or creativity is not extensively documented, the analogy of passionate engagement provides a useful framework for understanding the depth of commitment and emotional investment that top scholars and researchers bring to their disciplines. This perspective underscores the holistic nature of how personal experiences can enrich professional endeavors, fostering a deeper understanding and innovative approaches within their fields.

As evoked above, the conceptal implications of the sexual experience of academic professionals could be readily framed as unreasonable, if not irrelevant. It is therefore appropriate to compare it with the credibility accorded to exploration of the religious experience of academic professionals (Elaine Howard Ecklund, et al, Religion among Scientists in International Context: a new study of scientists in eight regions, Socius: Sociological Research for a Dynamic World, 2, 2016), as discussed by Anne Marie Conlon (How religious scientists balance work and faith, Nature, 20 May 2024). That review notes the survey by sociologist Christopher Scheitle of more than 1,300 graduate students about the "struggle" they face with regard to their experiences and their attitudes to religion (The challenges of being a religious scientist, The Conversation, 28 November 2023). Scheitle found that many religious people studying science struggle to be open about their faith, reporting a culture of ‘assumed atheism’ that often led them to conceal their religion for fear of being judged or discriminated against.

Given the prevaling scientific deprecation of the inherent irrationality of spiritual experience, it is curious that no corresponding study has seemingly been made of the "struggle" of sexually active academics in reconciling their experience with their conceptual frameworks. This could be considered especially ironic given the current credibility accorded to the "non-binary" frameworks asssociated with the LGBTQIA+ community (Global Civilization through Interweaving Polyamory and Polyanimosity? 2018).

Potentially even more provocative are the implications of an essay by Danny Calegari from a mathematical perspective (Disappointment, Notices of the American Mathematical Society, September 2023). This featured in an interview of the author by Jordana Cepelewicz (How Failure Has Made Mathematics Stronger, Quanta Magazine, 22 May 2024). The provocation lies in the implications of any correspondence between experience of "sexual dysfunction" and of "mathematical dysfunction" in the light of an alleged equivalence between them (Manya Raman Sundström, The maths drive is like the sex drive, New Scientist, 28 January 2015; Cédric Villani, What’s so sexy about math?- A TED Talk, Medium, 3 December 2019). Especially curious are the mathematical models that underpin sexual success (Hannah Fry, The Mathematics of Love, 2015)

Question to ChatGPT: Is there a case for recognizing the number and variety of curves, as mathematically defined, which frame the strange attractor of a female as experienced by a male. Arguably it is not the static form of such curves alone but some measure of their dynamics, as potentially suggested by harmonic analysis. Is there any trace of such research

The concept you're exploring -- examining the attraction dynamics using mathematical frameworks like curves and harmonic analysis -- is a unique and sophisticated intersection of mathematics, physics, and human psychology. While the notion of using such precise mathematical tools to describe aesthetic and emotional human experiences, such as attraction, might seem abstract, it taps into a longstanding tradition in both the arts and sciences of trying to quantify and understand beauty and human relationships through geometrical and mathematical principles.

Theoretical Frameworks and Approaches:

  • Curves and Geometry in Human Aesthetics:
    • Historically, artists and scientists have tried to capture what might be considered the 'ideal' or aesthetically pleasing forms through mathematical proportions and curves. For example, the Golden Ratio has been famously associated with human beauty and architectural aesthetics.
    • In terms of human form, curves play a significant role in artistic representations and are often highlighted in discussions of human beauty, using principles from geometry and dynamic systems.
  • Dynamic Systems and Attraction:
    • The concept of a "strange attractor" comes from chaos theory, where it represents a condition in a dynamic system in which the system tends to evolve, no matter how it started. Applying this to human interaction, attraction could theoretically be modeled as a dynamic system where multiple variables (including physical appearance, as described by curves, and personality traits) interact over time in complex ways.
    • Harmonic analysis, which involves studying functions or signals in terms of basic oscillating components (waves), could theoretically be applied to analyze movements, speech patterns, and other dynamic behaviors in human interactions.
  • Research in Related Areas:
    • While direct research into using harmonic analysis or complex mathematical curves to study human attraction specifically might not be widely documented, interdisciplinary fields like psychophysics, neuroaesthetics, and evolutionary psychology explore related concepts.
    • Psychophysics often investigates the relationship between physical stimuli and the sensations and perceptions they produce, which could theoretically encompass how physical forms and dynamics are perceived as attractive.
    • Neuroaesthetics looks at how the brain perceives beauty, which could include mathematical or geometric patterns in visual forms.
    • Evolutionary Psychology might explore how certain physical characteristics are preferred based on underlying genetic, health, or fertility indicators, which could be abstractly modeled through curves and dynamics.

Practical Applications and Ethical Considerations:

  • Modeling and Simulation: Using mathematical models to simulate human aesthetic responses or attraction could offer insights in fields like virtual reality, game design, or even robotics. However, the complexity and subjectivity of human emotions make this a challenging endeavor.
  • Ethical Concerns: There is a significant ethical dimension to considering how and why we might attempt to quantify human attributes and interactions. The reduction of human experiences and qualities to mathematical models might oversimplify the richly diverse and deeply personal nature of human relationships.

In conclusion, while there isn't a substantial body of research directly linking the dynamics of curves as "strange attractors" in a mathematical sense to human attraction, the idea of using mathematical and geometric principles to understand human aesthetics and interaction remains a topic of interest across several scientific and artistic disciplines. The application of these concepts must be approached with an awareness of both their potential and their limitations, particularly considering the deeply subjective nature of beauty and attraction.


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]