Strategic architecture by numbers and numerical cognition?
Memorability, Mnemonics, Maths, Music and Governance (Part #13)
[Parts: First | Prev | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
Architecture by numbers? Architectural theory continues to evoke active and criticial debate (Kate Nesbitt, Theorizing a New Agenda for Architecture: anthology of architectural theory, 1965-95, 1996; K. Michael Hays, Constructing a New Agenda: Architectural Theory 1993-2009, 2010). Given his focus on the theory of architecture, the insights of Michael Hays are potentially of great relevance to knowledge architecture (Architecture by Numbers, Praxis: Journal of Writing + Building, 7, 2005). Hays introduces his perspective as follows:
Architecture is fundamentally involved with numbers. From the very beginnings of architectural theory, as it emerged out of Pythagorean Platonic philosophies of harmony and proportion, architecture has been understood as a fulcrum between the material world of things and their construction and the transcendent mathematics of the cosmos itself. In the spring of 2004, I curated a show for the Whitney Museum of American Art at Altria called architecture by numbers. The premise of the show was simple: to juxtapose examples of contemporary practices that regard architecture's ongoing involvement with numbers as more fundamental than architecture's involvement with building
Hays offers a critical comment on the current deprecation of the theoretical perspective which it might be assumed is relevant to any insight into strategic archotecture as indicated above. Specifically he notes:
The current dogma seems to be that the complexity of the purely practical demands on architecture and the undeniable cleverness of architects' responses to those demands, exhaust the cultural interest in architecture in our own time. We are "after theory", the conventional locution goes. With the ability to process massive amounts of information and push it through sophisticated graphic software, we no longer have need of the slow and cumbersome ideas and abstractions that theory traffics in. The massive movements and sheer speed of the world system make theoretical supplements to real-time technocracy no more than ornaments, detours, and perversions of real progress and immediacy of effect.
Although valuable in intimating a more fruitful perspective, unfortunately his focus does not extend explicitly to what might be understood as knowledge architecture:
I mean something different from theory that guides and controls design practice. I intend rather the more fundamental, but also more limited activity of conceptualizing experiences that are irreducibly architectural- experiences that belong to none other than architectural objects or events in general and to numerary organizations or patterns in particular. This entails that architecture be understood as both an enabling condition and a restraint on thought and action...
In clarifying this perspective, Hays suggests use of the infinitive "to architect" in order to indicate the desire he attributes to artists-architects engaged otherwise with number:
To architect then, comes to mean something different from to make or even to plan -- different because the categories produced in architecting cannot be objects in their own right. To architect means rather to seek after architecture as a specific mode of knowledge to perform presently a specific activity for the purpose of prolonging or continuing the practice historically authorized as architecture, but which cannot now be done in the same way; to select from among other possible practices (dancing, writing, filming, designing, etc.) this particular course of action; to set it next to other systems; to intend architecture; to desire architecture.
Numerical cognition? Of potential relevance as a source of insight into the role of number in relation to governance is the open-access Journal of Numerical Cognition. This is the official journal of the Mathematical Cognition and Learning Society. The clarification of its purpose as a forum for the focused discussion of research intonumerical cognition was made by the introductory editorial by John Towse (Finding a Voice for Numerical Cognition, 1, 2015, 1). As stated:
... the Journal aims to be inclusive, and takes numerical cognition to encompass for example all branches of mathematics (including spatial reasoning), and welcomes research for its quality, regardless of whether its origins are in (Cognitive) Psychology, Education, Anthropology, or other disciplines...
The editorial notes that there simply are no existing specialized journals that cater to numerical cognition and the psychology of mathematics, noting that the journal Mathematical Cognition published several volumes from 1995 to 2000 before ceasing to exist.
So framed a perusal of the recent volumes on numerical cognition makes it clear that a significant interest for researchers lies in the challenges of educating students with regard to numeracy. The point implied by the argument above is that potentially far more critical are the issues of numerical cognition of those associated with governance and the articulation of strategy. The point can be emphasized otherwise by the current significance associated with cognitive architecture as a theory about the structure of the human mind and to a computational instantiation of such a theory in the fields of artificial intelligence (AI) and computational cognitive science.
Architectural and mathematical self-reflexivity? Mathematics does indeed offer considerable theoretical insight into reflexivity. It is less evident how this insight relates to the practice of mathematics and the preoccupations of mathematicians. Such questions are also relevant to the systems-oriented disciplines:
- Hibak Mohamud: Reflections on Systems Theory: the role of self and reflexivity (Edpsy, 19 October 2021)
- D. W. Pellegrini: Applied systemic theory and educational psychology: Can the twain ever meet? (Educational Psychology in Practice, 25, 2009, 3).
- Bogdan Popoveniuc: Self Reflexivity: the ultimate end of knowledge (Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 163, 2014)
Provocatively it could be said that the argument above identifies an array of perspectives which tend in practice to ignore each other and the degree to which they are part of the problem of governance. This is yet another example of inter-sectoral and inter-disciplinary fragmentation -- reinforcing the perceptions of the irrelevance of other perspectives.
In this sense, ironically, it is how they might be fruitfully configured together -- a design challenge mirroring that of governance at this time, given the manner in which otherness is widely deprecated. Whereas the argument above draws attention to recognition of "beautiful" cathedrals, mosques and temples, and their impressive design, the question is whether the disparate perspectives highlighted above together pose the question of the design of a "temple of knowledge". How might those perspectives be meaningfully interrelated -- preserving their disciplinary identities and distinctive orientations?
To that end, one example of interest is application of the mathematics of Voronoi diagrams, as elegantly proposed by Sa'id Kori (Design of Knowledge Temple in Jerusalem). However, whilst this does indeed address issues of building architecture, it in no way addresses those of knowledge architecture -- or those posed by Jerusalem itself (Jerusalem as a Symbolic Singularity: comprehending the dynamics of hyperreality as a challenge to conventional two-state reality, 2017).
Such a proposal can be usefully contrasted with the recognition by a mathematician, Marcus du Sautoy, of the manner in which all 17 symmetry patterns of the "wallpaper group" (noted above) appear in the remarkable Moorish palace of the Alhambra, long appreciated for its beauty (Symmetry: a journey into the patterns of nature, 2008; The Alhambra, symmetries and the beauty of mathematics, 2010).
The Alhambra is one of the most famous monuments of Islamic architecture -- preserved by Spain as a monument to the triumph of Christianity (Robert Irwin, The Alhambra, 2011). How such palatial elegance and complexity was held to be of significance to governance invites reflection -- especially in the present period when priority is given to analogous investments, if only to impress (Lara Eve Eggleton; Re-envisioning the Alhambra: readings of architecture and ornament from medieval to modern, University of Leeds, 2011).
Rather than a temple or a palace, for whom is an architectural complex like the Alhambra understood as a memory theatre, as explored in the widely cited work by Frances Yates (The Art of Memory, 1966)? Such insight features in more recent initiatives:
- Simon Critchley: Memory Theater (Other Press, 2015)
- Allen Foresta: Memory Theater Revisited: a purpose-built playhouse for the performance of teaching, learning, kowledge creation, and kowledge retrieval, too (Gottesman Libraries, 30 April 2019)
- Peter Matussek: The Renaissance of the Theater of Memory (Poetics and Politics of Memory, 2001)
- Robert Edgar: Animating the Memory Theatre (2012)
- Joseph El Khouri: Inside a Memory Theatre (Tharunka, XL-5, 7 August 1973).
- Giulio Camillo's Memory Theatre (Agencement. 11 February 2013)
Yates draws attention to the method of loci, namely a method of memorizing information by placing each item to be remembered at a point along an imaginary journey through what is also termed a memory palace -- for which there are now many references.
Assuming a requirement for self-reflexivity in the quest for memorable strategic design of relevance to governance, there is a case for recognizing that any fruitful configuration of the dimensions and disciplines highlighted above may strangely parallel the architecture of beautiful cathedrals, mosques and temples as they are now envisaged -- a form of temple of knowledge in virtual reality. The argument may be simplistically presented through the following animation -- especially indicative of the dynamics between disciplines and perspectives which are typically indifferent to each other in practice, whilst purportedly aspiring to interdisciplinarity.
| Self-reflexive design of a temple of knowledge of relevance to giovernnce Animation suggestive of phases in the configuration of the disparate requisite perspectives |
![]() |
[Parts: First | Prev | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
Subjects: Mathematics · Architecture · Psychology · Strategy
