Playful transformation between forms of global governance -- “organizing”?
Coronavirus -- Global Plan, Doughnut, Torus, Helix and/or Pineapple? (Part #11)
[Parts: First | Prev | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | Refs ]
Global brain? It might be supposed that in time of crisis any appropriately imaginative response would emerge from a "global brain". This is a fantasy characteristic of techno-optimists anticipating the development of artificial intelligence, more specifically in relation to the tipping point of a technological singularity. In response to the current pandemic, it is far from clear that either the technology, or those endeavouring to make use of it through complex modelling, could be compared to a global brain and the neural learning from which it would purportedly benefit. Whilst the current facilities may indeed provide answers, it is useful to ak whether the questions are of an order of subtlety appropriate to the challenge, as explored separately (Superquestions for Supercomputers Avoiding terra flops from misguided dependence on teraflops? 2010).
The challenge is further complicated by the probability that other singularities may occur before the technological one (Emerging Memetic Singularity in the Global Knowledge Society, 2009; Jerusalem as a Symbolic Singularity: comprehending the dynamics of hyperreality as a challenge to conventional two-state reality, 2017). The biological threat, of which COVID-19 may well be a precursor, is but one example. Memetic warfare, of which the fake news crisis is but one example, could be another -- especially in that the applications of new technology are increasingly paralleled or overtaken by spurious claims ("hype") as to their efficacy.
It is in this context that strategic decision-making in response to the pandemic is guided by mysterious sets of experts whose thinking cannot be called into question -- supported by models developed in secret (on the basis of data of low granularity), in contradiction with any case for transparency in a democratic civilization.
New thinking, "numerology" and pseudoscience? The argument developed here has focused on the need for "new thinking" taking the form of the coronavirus as a catalyst for the requisite imagination. A degree of emphasis has been placed on the number of protein spikes as offering a metaphor framing the problematic role of various forms of spikes in the psychosocial organization of global civilization, The reference to patterns of 72 and/or 74 spikes can be readily deprecated as pseudoscientific numerology. Such deprecation fails to recognize how patterns of order are governed by numbers, as is so evident in the symmetries of polyhedra and the creations of nature -- much valued by science.
Potentially far more serious, such deprecation omits any consideration of how adequately complex strategic responses are to be rendered comprehensible, memorable and communicable. Such factors are rarely more than implicit in the considerations of experts -- or in the design for global strategies such as the UN's Millennium Goals or its Sustainable Development Goals. Yet is is expected that these will invite widespread appeal even though very few would even be able to list the SDGs from memory. It is systematically forgotten that memory is to a high degree dependent on the patterns of order, governed by number which are characteristic of music and symbols framed by sacred geometry -- of which polyhedra provide remarkable examples. The argument with respect to rhyme can be variously made (A Singable Earth Charter, EU Constitution or Global Ethic? 2006; Participative Development Process for Singable Declarations, 2006; Poetry-making and Policy-making Arranging a Marriage between Beauty and the Beast, 1993). With respect to COVID-19 or any crisis, the latter particularly recalls the argument for aesthetic engagement with any "monstrosity" as featured in various traditions..
Given the problems they are summed to address, it could even be argued that the SDGs constitute "thorny spikes" -- as asystemically and inharmoniously ordered, "with neither rhyme nor reason". Such a pattern is dramatically configured in the symbol of the Crown of Thorns -- in this case of global civilization. Again, is it proving to be the case that: If your only tool is a hammer then every problem looks like a nail? Given the failure to consider the challenge of memorable appeal and uptake, will the future frame the expertise deployed in response to the pandemic as the epitome of pseudoscience?
Playfullness and "organizing"? Presented in this way, rather than stressing the unquestionable superiority of any particular approachs to "global planning", there is arguably a need to be able to shift flexibly between geometrical frameworks as lenses or automobile gears. This strategic nimbleness is usefully understood both in terms of the game-playing, which has informed policy development for so long as inspired by chess and go -- now the focus of artifical intelligence algorithms, The playfulness is however especially vital to the comprehension, memorability and communicability of any strategy expected to evoke widespread support (Playfully Changing the Prevailing Climate of Opinion: climate change as focal metaphor of effective global governance, 2005).
In reflecting on the design of a desirable "global brain" adequate to enagagement with the pandemic, imaginative innovation can be be seen as fundamentally related to such playfulness in eliciting attractive patterns. This can be is presented as consistent with a fundamental sense of "organizing" in its particular historical association with the organ as a musical instrument through which harmony is variously explored -- now reinvented as an electronic organ (Envisaging a Comprehensible Global Brain -- as a Playful Organ: patterns connecting the dots between hemispheres, epicycles and quavers, 2019). There is a degree of irony in this period of crisis in that the enthusiasm for a "global plan" by the highest authorities ignores the current familiarity from an early age with the far greater technically-supported complexity in online gaming (potentially enhanced by musical appreciation).
Framed in this way, organizing involves the capacity to make skillful use of an extensive array of possible models -- whether plans, toroids, helixes, polyhedra, or otherwise. The emphasis being on the capacity to shift playfully between them -- deploying and "reploying" them (see antonyms for deploy), attaching to any frame offer and detaching from it-- possibly to be described metaphorically as donning and doffing. The dynamic medium is the message, rather than the assertive imposition of any particular framework (as at present). Such imposition is then comparable to the boring drone of a singular sound -- however melodically it may be presented as a marketing jingle.
Just as playing the organ can require a considerable degree of skill (as well as aptitude and musicality) -- and complementary appreciation from any audience -- exploring the hundreds of interrelated polyhedra through the transformations possible between them is a compositional challenge involving hands-on experience with appropriate software. Use of Stella Polyhedron Navigator to produce the animations above made only too evident that a higher order of skill would be appropriate to render comprehensible the range of possibilities and the challenge to eliciting a sense of coherence. Where is the development of that skill enabled?
Cognitive gear transmission system? Of interest is then the scope of the organ -- namely the number of models which can be incorporated into an epic narrative capable of framing dynamically the different facets of a crisis and the response. In that respect, of some relevance is the justification for the recent development of a circular keyboard surrounding the instrumentalist, as described and illustrated separately (Dynamic patterns of play engendered by Homo ludens and Homo undulans? 2019).
A readily compehensible metaphor of playing with some such organ is offered by the remarkable range of gears required in a heavy duty truck offers a valuable metaphor -- an extension of the simpler versions with which drivers of non-automatic gear-shift vehicles are familiar. Such a pattern of 18 gears is discussed separately with respect to Shifting between strategic patterns: transmission systems and gearing (2019). This forms part of a more general discussion (Global Coherence by Interrelating Disparate Strategic Patterns Dynamically: Topological interweaving of 4-fold, 8-fold, 12-fold, 16-fold and 20-fold in 3D, 2019).
Automobiles have a variety of relatively simple gear shift patterns with which many are familiar. Whilst there is considerable familiarity with shifting between many gears in vehicles of different types, this familiarity would appear to be totally lacking in the case of strategic patterns. It could be imagined that truck drivers have mnemonic aids with respect to learning the complex gear shift patterns, as shown below-centre. Curiously, however, there are many references to the "Truck Driver's Gear Change" as descriptive of modulation in music -- but not as a mnemonic device.
Of interest with respect to the gear metaphor, a bicycle may have 16 to 18 usable gear ratios. A truck may have 10 or more gears (9, 10, 13, 15 and 18 Gears - Shifting Theory | Drive Truck, Smart Drive; How to Shift an 18 Speed Transmission like a Pro, Smart-Trucking, 7 December 2018; How to use an 18-Speed Roadranger, TruckSales, 16 August 2018). Is the current global strategic challenge to be compared to this description of driving a 15-speed truck:
Now I'll just touch on what a 15-speed is for a moment. If you get in a truck and it's got a blue button in it, it's a 15-speed. Now this is not a splitter in a 15-speed transmission. This is what is called deep reduction. And the best way to explain deep reduction on a 15-speed is that essentially you've got three tiers of five gears. Five gears way down in the basement, five gears on the main level, and five gears upstairs. Most of the time you're going to drive a 15-speed like a ten-speed. 1,2,3,4,5, flip up the range selector, back over to low - and for those of us who drive 13s and 18s and then get into 15- that's very weird for us to go back to low - but back to low 1,2,3,4,5 shift it like a ten-speed.
Now if you get into a gravel pit or something like that you need deep reduction, the best way to understand deep reduction in a 15-speed is like four-wheel drive low and four-wheel-drive hi. That's the difference. And it's not sequential, so if you're in deep reduction in 15-speed you can't go one, two, three, four, five and then split up to the next gear and go the other five. It's more like up to five in the low low and then up to three on the next level. So it's a little bit strange, but if you ever get into a 15-speed, just kind of play around with it and you'll get use to it. But know that if the splitter is blue it's a 15-speed; if it's red, it's 13; and if it's grey, it's 18. And in this day and age of non-synchronous transmissions, most of them are going to be 18-speeds. (9, 10, 13, 15 and 18 Gears - Shifting Theory)
Arguably there is a need for a mnemonic aid to the relationship between N-fold patterns, as is somewhat ironically suggested by the following Christmas song, used over centuries, whether or not it can be understood as having various levels of meaning, as explored by David Emery (Does "The Twelve Days of Christmas" Have a Hidden Meaning? Liveaboutdotcom, 18 July 2018). Clearly the pattern in the song on the left (below) would need to be extended from 12 to 20, to encompass the 16-fold pattern of SDGs (below right). The central image offers an indication of the daily reality with which drivers of trucks are obliged to "play".
What appears to be required is some recognition of the value of the set of contrasting "strategic gears" as a whole (8-fold, 12-fold, etc). The metaphor is also suggestive with respect to the relation between the strategies in any set -- as is so evident in driving a 15-gear truck. Driving in one gear only would be considered ridiculous. The question would then be what are the analogues to enable shifting between strategic patterns according to circumstances -- or to shifting between strategies within any one such pattern (as suggested below right). There is no simple song like that on the right to interweave the SDGs and render them widely memorable.
| Mnemonic aids to a set of contrasting strategic patterns? | ||
| As suggested by a well-known song? | As suggested by a gear shift pattern in trucks | Single pattern: UN SDGs as "strategic gears" ? |
| On the 12th day of Christmas my true love sent to me: 12 drummers drumming 11 pipers piping 10 lords a-leaping Nine ladies dancing Eight maids a-milking Seven swans a-swimming Six geese a-laying Five golden rings Four calling birds Three french hens Two turtle doves, and A partridge in a pear tree | ![]() |
|
Strategic coherence enabled by drawing dynamically on modelling resources? Global civilization has yet to engender consensus on the anture of "unity" -- deemed only too readily comprehensible and well-defined by each religion and discipline, despite the profound disagreements between them. The quest for any adequate comprehension of unity is exemplified by the challenges faced by fundamental physics and cosmology with respect to any such assumption.
Policy-makers have yet to accept that a singular global plan is far from adequate in clarifing the nature of such unity -- preferring instead to impose simplistic patterns inherited from the past, as with the Marshall Plan, condemning any who question their viability. Could this be appropriately termed "dimagination" -- usefully associated in its consequences with dumbing down and psychic numbing? (David Graeber, Dead Zones of the Imagination, HAU Journal of Ethnographic Theory, 2, 2012).
Strategic unity and self-reflexivity? If the elusive nature of such unity merits recognition as essentially dynamic, the question is how any models can be understood as transformation pathways circumscribing such understanding. Ironically this capacity has effectively been anticipated in the worldwide enthusiasm for transformer toys and the depiction of transforming robots in movies. This familiarity is far greater than that with respect to t entative arguments for any "global plan" or international organizations of "variable geometry".
As noted separately with respect to transformational pathways between patterns of N-foldness, it is a "gearbox" which offers an accessible metaphor (Polyhedral possibilities of interrelating patterns comprehensibly: a "cognitive gearbox"? 2019). A map of such pathways is suggested by the image on the left below derived from Changing Patterns using Transformation Pathways (2015)., Portions of its dynamics are suggested by the animation on the right. Somewhat ironically such a gearbox can be explored in terms of the memorable nesting of polyhedra (Transformation: changing cognitive gear and pattern shape shifting, 2015; Nesting polyhedra to enable comparison of patterns of discourse, 2015; Relative movement of nested Platonic polyhedra: pumping and rotation, 2015)
| Map of relationships between spherically symmetrical polyhedra | Relative "pumping" dynamic of nested Platonic polyhedra within Rhombic triacontahedron (green) as a nesting framework |
![]() | ![]() |
| Reproduced from derived from Changing Patterns using Transformation Pathways (2015)., | virtual reality: vrml or x3d; video: mp4 |
How many facets of such insight could be usefully seen as a feature of polyhedral geometry -- as faces, vertices, or edges? So framed, do simpler polyhedra serve as simpler scripts suggesting a degree of understanding but only implying a subtler sense of unity? Do more complex polyhedra render explicit more facets, whilst increasing the challenge of comprehending the significance of the patterns they offer? The possibility of "organizing" global governance otherwise is presented separately as an animation of some 120 images (Engaging Playfully with Coronavirus through "Organizing" Global Governance? Eliciting imaginative new thinking inspired by transformations in 3D of the form of the virus, 2020).
Does the interconnected array of polyhedra, exemplifying the variety of patterns of order, frame the question of both how they map each other self-reflexively and how this constitutes an insight into higher orders of unity? One exercise to that end animates the association of Archimedean polyhedra with the cuboctahedron, as shown in a video derived from a separate discussion (Time for Provocative Mnemonic Aids to Systemic Connectivity? Possibilities of reconciling the "headless hearts" to the "heartless heads", 2019).
Subjects: Change · World Order


