Faith-based military action: “Gott MIT Uns”


Patterns of the Past (Part #11)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx ]


Christianity has a long tradition of justifying its defence and advancement through the use of military force. This has included the Knights Templar and the Crusades, the forces of the Papal States (including a papal navy dating back to the 9th century) and of the Holy Roman Empire -- and the reinforcement of the activities of Christian missionaries (notably by the Conquistadores). A characteristic confusion was however cultivated between "saving souls" and "filling the coffers of Christendom". European colonialism was born of this ambiguity (now echoed in the preoccupations regarding "development" of the United Nations Development Programme and its associated Global Compact).

There is a long tradition of ensuring that military activity is appropriate blessed and supported by representatives of an appropriate priesthood. As early as 7 BC, there are records of the Assyrian Army having a cadre of military chaplains. The role of the chaplain became more clearly defined at the time of the Crusades when he was charged with the spiritual and moral welfare of the troops which has been formalized in recent centuries.

The notion of a Christian "church militant" (Ecclesia Militans) has long been cultivated as "the Christian church on earth, which is supposed to be engaged in a constant warfare against its enemies..." [more | more]. It is evident in the rationale of the Crusades -- a term now widely used metaphorically in relation to missionary activity. It is evident in the title of the Salvation Army and its military structure, or the Army of God (that is open in its support of those assassinating abortionists [more | more]). The point continues to be made with regard to the Army of Christ, that Christians are enjoined to serve as soldiers of Jesus Anointed [more | more].

The New Testament is filled with militaristic references and characterizations of Christians as soldiers. For example:

  • "You, therefore, my child, be empowered by favor in Anointed Jesus. And what things you hear from me through many witnesses, these things commit to men of persuasion, who will be competent also to teach others. You, then, suffer hardship with us as a good soldier of Jesus Anointed. No one serving as a soldier tangles with the affairs of life, so that he might please the one having enlisted him." (II Timothy 2:1-4)
  • "Do not think that I came to bring peace on the earth. I did not come to bring peace but a sword." (Matthew 10:34)
  • "But now, he having a purse, let him take it. Likewise also a wallet. And he not having, let him sell his garment and buy a sword." (Luke 22:36)

Millions of children have been exposed to hymns joyously employing military metaphors [more] | more] | more | more] such as:

Onward Christian soldiers, Marching as to War
With the Cross of Jesus, Going on Before

Such words raise questions about the legitimacy of concern expressed by Christians regarding analogous comments in the Koran relating to any references to holy war. The use of warlike metaphors by Christians was debated at a Consultation on Mission Language and Metaphors at the Fuller Theological Seminary in June 2000. It concluded:

"We regret that certain words and images long employed to call the church to mission have increasingly caused offense to the very people with whom we are seeking to share the good news. Some of these words and images are biblical; some are motivational tools from the secular arena that we use to inspire involvement and action. Many are military in nature: 'target,' 'conquer,' 'army,' 'crusade,' 'mobilize,' 'beachhead,' 'advance,' 'enemy,' 'battle.'....'warfare' metaphors and terminology" have become "increasingly counterproductive to mission work." They recommend alternate words and images such as "blessing, healing, inviting, sowing and reaping, fishing, restoring family relationships, becoming reconcilers, peacemakers and ambassadors." [More | more]

St Augustine provided five qualifications for a "just war," which are still useful in guiding a Christian's evaluation of the rightness of his nation's cause. The concept was reviewed, to justify exceptions, by the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life (Just War Tradition and the New War on Terrorism, 2001). Briefly, St Augustine's points include:

  • the war must have a just cause such as the punishment of injustice and the restoration of peace.
  • the use of armed force must be the last resort when no other maneuver will stop the injustice.
  • war must be waged under the authority and sovereignty of the state (not for private purposes).
  • the effects must be proportionate; the evils inflicted by war should be less severe than the evils being righted.
  • the war must have a reasonable probability of succeeding.

But, surprisingly to those convinced of the "godlessness" of their enemy, military chaplains were active in the Wehrmacht of Hitler's Germany (but not in the ss). During the military activity of World War II, Germany set up military religious jurisdictions in Austria, Poland, France, Norway and in the Balkan countries. These initiatives followed a long history of military religious welfare. In Prussia, for example, Christianity and the military professionals had joined in a particularly close and characteristic relationship based on its special relationship to monarchy. (see Pastor Dr. Dieter Beese. The Role of Protestant Military Chaplains in the Second World War Pacem Forsvarets Overkommando, nr. 2-2001).

Although war is inimical to the teachings of Jesus (as it is to other religions), the role of a military chaplain is not to justify war in general. A chaplain's task is to minister to the emotional and spiritual needs of service members in both war and in peace [more | more]. In this context, chaplains have an extraordinary combination of tasks that may variously include:

  • ministering to personnel who may be suffering from crises of conscience, whether in anticipation or following acts of violence for which they were personally responsible
  • ministering to personnel of other denominations by embodying the challenges of interfaith dialogue
  • encouraging personnel to continue to perform their military duties in the light of the orders that they are given
  • determining those (rare) instances in which it is inappropriate to follow military orders
  • determining whether information given under an implicit oath of confidentiality calls for a breach of that confidentiality
  • reflecting the Christian values which the force claims to be fighting to defend
  • justifying to personnel the acts of savagery (inadvertently) perpetrated in defence of those values
  • during peacekeeping missions, assisting people toward peace and reconciliation [more]

The degree of involvement of religion in the German military enterprise of the two World Wars is illustrated by the standard issue military belt buckle bearing the phrase Gott MIT Uns ("God is With Us"). For the first war it included the crown of Imperial Germany, for the second, this was replaced by a Reichs Eagle and Swastika as part of Hitler's symbolic agenda (see Hitler's Cross). The Serbian Orthodox Church was intimately involved in the nationalist aspirations of Slobodan Milosevic (since indicted for crimes against humanity). The Shinto religion was intimately involved in support of the Japanese war effort of World War II and continues to play a controversial role in Japanese nationalist policies. Islam promises direct entrance to the "7th degree of heaven" for those who die in battle defending, or promoting, the faith. Given Hitler's own interest in pagan religion -- suggesting a distinct understanding of "Gott" by the ss -- there is a high degree of irony to the existence of a Military Pagan Network within the US military forces, that has provoked considerable controversy amongst Christian groups [more].

Ironically the assistance of witchdoctors, as the earliest practitioners in this arena, continues to be sought by combatants in conflicts in developing countries -- thus acknowledging the power of early understanding of faith-based military action.

Given the interdenominational role of which military chaplains are so rightfully proud, one wonders at the extent to which they effectively minister to the spiritual needs of Muslim terrorist suspects held on the American military base at Guantanamo Bay -- and who are tortured in the name of Christian values by the chaplains' military colleagues (the primary focus of the chaplain's spiritual ministry). Despite professional issues of breach of confidence, are detainees encouraged to confess to such chaplains as part of the standard "good-cop / bad-cop" interrogation routine? [more | more | more]

Few Americans would doubt from the words of George Bush that God is specially supportive of the successful outcome of the attack on Iraq in defence of US interests and Christian values. In American terms, the attack might be said to have been "endorsed" by God. The special theological problem is that Muslims hold to a corresponding belief that Allah is specially supportive of Arab interests and Muslim values. Neither Christians nor Muslims have ever been able to address these differences of perspective non-violently. In the world of binary thinking favoured by both sides, the other must necessarily be wrong. As such each sees the other as misrepresenting God and therefore, as unbelievers, as being the epitome of Evil.

The Institute of American Values has produced a manifesto to demonstrate that a times waging war is not only morally permitted, but morally necessary, as a response to calamitous acts of violence, hatred and injustice. To justify this position the manifesto invokes those "American values [which] do not belong only to America, but are in fact the shared inheritance of "humankind". As reviewed by richard Sennett (They mean well: the American flight from politics into faith. Times Literary Supplement, 7 June 2002):

They invoke an American version of religious faith as the most important of these values. While they recognize "no religious tradition in spotless", still they reject what the manifesto calls "ideological secularism"...What they affirm is that religious faith is an "important dimension of personhood"....


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx ]

Subjects: Action · Military · Faith