Transference of moral responsibility for deferred pain
Patterns of the Past (Part #14)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx ]
Terrorism has been converted into a dramatic global challenge by 9/11 -- and especially by the Christian-inspired response to it. Similar disasters have occurred before in other countries. The 1995 Oklahoma bombing was one such disaster in the USA. The Bhopal disaster of 1984 -- resulting in many more deaths -- could usefully be considered as a form of terrorism.
But for Americans, 9/11 is to be understood by the rest of the world as a heinous violation sans pareil -- the ultimate rape of the spirit of freedom at the core of Christian civilization. The possibility that other cultures might feel themselves to have been raped by the USA at some time is a spurious argument of the most dubious motivation -- although feminists have long struggled to promote awareness of male use of this mode of denial in the case of the rape of women. Neither the destruction of Amerinidan peoples through which American settlement was achieved, nor the enslavement of millions through which the USA first built its wealth, nor the economic exploitation of client states by multinationals, is to be considered comparable to any degree to the actions of a group of men armed with box cutters in an attack of surgical precision to rival any Pentagon missile.
There is also the supreme irony of the erosion of collective memory regarding the coup on 11 September 1973 against Allende's democratically elected government in Chile -- a coup that history has established as having been strongly supported and funded by the US in order that the Americas should not be faced with a viable alternative model to capitalism [more. more | more]. In contrast with 9/11 (with which many compare it), subsequent operations (notably Operation Condor) to ensure the stability of the new Chilean "democracy" resulted in over 3,000 deaths, and thousands of "disappearances" after torture [more]. General Pinochet, later indicted for crimes against humanity, was portrayed as a strong ally by the USA and the UK. Margaret Thatcher, who personally supported him during his extradition proceedings asserted that he "brought democracy to Chile" [more].
The special challenge of the times is that the complexities of world governance no longer lend themselves to any hope of strategic management with the skills and resources considered acceptable. There is therefore considerable merit in reframing the challenge by focusing on singular threats with well-defined "enemies" that are sufficiently elusive and dangerous so as to justify repressive legislation and continuing military initiatives. "Terrorism" is one threat that may be suitably promoted and managed to this end (Promoting a Singular Global Threat -- Terrorism: Strategy of choice for world governance, 2002).
As many have remarked, the focus on terrorism very effectively draws attention away from the hundreds of millions of unnecessary deaths associated yearly with problems that have proven to be unresponsive to modest international programmes, notably in countries that have been labelled "basket cases". Such problems include starvation, water shortage, disease, illiteracy, shelter, etc. The resources briefly expended on the conquest of Afghanistan and Iraq vastly exceed the resources that have ever been recommended for remedial action by such programmes.
The actions against terrorism are claimed to be in revenge for a few thousand American deaths on the occasion of 9/11, and to prevent more deaths in that country later. But this neglects the fact that the allocation of scarce resources to this end has already guaranteed the deaths of far larger numbers of people -- elsewhere. They will die because the intractable problems -- that breed terrorism incidentally -- continue to be neglected. And fewer resources are now available to address them -- even if the will to do so has not now been severely eroded.
In this respect, Christianity is however curiously influenced by its foundation myth and especially by the "hand-washing" of Pontius Pilate that it has embodied through a perverse form of transference. It is a religion with a special relation to pain (as symbolized by the Cross as an instrument of torture and execution) and to lack of responsibility for the pain of others before God. Like the Aztec priests, Catholic priests were empowered to cause pain during the Inquisition to assist in the salvation of the sufferer -- even if this was achieved through the actions of menials, alleviating those responsible of any direct personal responsibility. Withholding succour to those in distress is not to be framed as causing pain -- since the pain experienced is the responsibility of the sufferer, especially if its manifestation is delayed for years.
Similarly, the failure of Christian leadership to address the intractable problems of the world is not to be recognized as implying any responsibility for the pain that will necessarily result. Indeed, cynically, as illustrated by both George Bush and Tony Blair with regard to Africa, the problems are skillfully and repeatedly "addressed" only through the promises briefly made in their speeches -- promises quickly to be forgotten in practice. Good intentions -- in the light of the highest Christian values in the present -- easily absolve Christian leadership of failure to engage in any effective action in practice. The latter is limited to military rather than humanitarian intervention -- as currently indicated by the evident challenge of fulfilling earlier nation-building commitments in Afghanistan and Iraq.
The main guarantee for present and future collective pain worldwide is the population explosion and its accumulative effect on quality of life and propensity for death. The world's population is set to rise from 6 billion to 9 billion in the next 70 years. Christian faiths have been at the core of efforts to avoid addressing this issue effectively -- to the point of ensuring that it is now only mentioned in passing in international debate, if at all. Responsibility now has been displaced -- with pain and social unrest to be experienced later -- a pain from which Christians have creatively absolved themselves of any responsibility.
This historic irresponsibility for experienced pain is to be seen most poignantly and personally in the challenge of those exposed to terminal illness and the suffering associated with it in its final phases. Again it has primarily been Christian faiths, in the light of their highest values, that see it as their loving obligation to ensure that the terminally ill experience pain and indignity for as long as possible, irrespective of their expressed desire for euthanasia. Christians admit of no doubt that such is the will of God -- seeking by the most perverse means to ensure that individuals in their power experience some measure of the pain associated with their own founding myth of the Cross.
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx ]
Subjects: Nervous System · Ethics · Responsibility