Unrecognized complementarity of trinities of speech modalities?
Being Spoken to Meaningfully by Constructs (Part #10)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
In further emphasizing the role played by expletives, it is the degree to which they are used in discriminatory speech acts which merits attention -- in a society that continues to address inequalities, and the manner in which these are reinforced by expletives (Problematic language for problematic times -- systemic function of "expletives"? 2020)
Unholy trinity of expletives? In the speculative exercise which follows, three forms of expletive are distinguished as a set distinct from the 4-fold, 8-fold, and 16-fold arrays discussed above. The associated usage of the three together is variously described as profanity, obscenity, swearing/cursing, or foul language -- prohibited in various contexts and media, or otherwise considered taboo. Strangely requiring their conventional indication with asterisks, the 3-fold set can be understood (provocatively and for mnemonic purposes) as:
- blasphemous "invocation" (unnamable)
- obscene references to genitalia and their abuse ("f*ck", "c*nt", "pr*ck") and problematic intercourse ("motherf*cker", "bugger")
- references to excreta, faeces and waste ("sh*t", "bullsh*t", "sh*t for brains", "waste of space", "piss")
The second is commonly used in deprecating subordinates and opponents -- "calling" them or "speaking to" them -- or by implication (The Coalition of the Willy: musings on the global challenge of penile servitude, 2004). Such use could be explored as fundamental to discriminatory discourse.
The latter two may be understood as conflated in the widespread reference to "ass" or "arse", especially through use of "arsehole" (Arse vs Ass: etymology and slang, 2020; Backside to the Future: coherence and conflation of dominant strategic metaphors -- Worshipping the Golden Ass, 2003).
A provocative "philosophical" study has been devoted to the third (Harry Frankfurt, On Bullshit, 2005), evoking a surprising range of insightful reflections:
- Julian Baggini: Stirring Shit: On Bullshit, Harry Frankfurt (The Philosophers' Magazine, 31, 2005)
- Nicholas Agar: Confessions of a philosophical shit-stirrer (ABC Religion and Ethics, 1 December 2021).
- Nicholas Agar: On the moral obligation to stop shit-stirring (Psyche, 15 December 2020)
- Jeff Jarvis: In defense of bullshit (The Guardian, 4 April 2006)
- André Spicer: Shooting the shit: the role of bullshit in organisations (Management, 16, 2013, 5)
- G. Reisch and G. Hardcastle (Eds.): Bullshit and Philosophy (Open Court, 2006)
- Lisa Banu: Design and Shit: reality, materiality and ideality in the works of Jean Baudrillard and Slavoj Zizek (International Journal of Zizek Studies, 7, 2013, 4).
3-fold articulation of the Word of God? In framing an antithesis to the "Word of God", notably through blasphemous invocation, it is potentially instructive to recognize a fundamental complementarity with a primary articulation of that Word through the Trinity, notably as understood by Christianity and Judaism (although contested by Islam). Such an antithesis would necessarily be characteristic of a secular framework -- highly deprecated and condemned from a religious perspective -- hence the abhorrence of "foul language".
A 3-fold implication or correspondence of the set of expletives might then be recognized as reflecting or mirroring in some perverse manner the primary injunctions of the Word of God (for the Abrahamic religions):
- a memetic complex interweaving obedience, worship, blessing and invocation, as variously expressed:
- Obey My voice, and I will be your God, and you will be My people; and you will walk in all the way which I command you, that it may be well with you. (Jeremiah 7:23)
- ...blessed are those who hear the word of God and observe it (Luke 11:28)
- Blessed rather are those who hear the word of God and obey it (Luke 11:28)
- the specific command relating to population and reproduction, variously translated (Genesis 1:28):
- Be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth and subdue it
- Be fruitful and multiply. Fill the earth and govern it
- the specific command relating to dominion, variously translated as an extension of the previous command (Genesis 1:28):
- Rule over the fish in the sea and the birds in the sky and over every living creature that moves on the ground.
- ..have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the heavens and over every living thing that moves on the earth.
Triadic articulation of speech act theory: With respect to the earlier focus on speech act theory, of considerable potential relevance to any triadic distinction from a (Christian) theological perspective is the work of Kevin Vanhoozer (A Pathway into the Holy Scriptures, 1994; From Speech Acts to Scripture Acts, 2001) as noted by Brian S McGuffin (Triune Communicative Acts in the Theology of Kevin J Vanhoozer, 2011). This has been fruitfully reviewed in relation to speech act theory by Joshua C. Stone (Triadic to Trinitarian: Kevin J. Vanhoozer’s Application of J.L. Austin’s Speech Act Theory, Eleutheria 1, 2010, 1). As noted by Stone:
Vanhoozer uses Speech Act theory to counter the skepticism of postmodern linguistic epistemology, leading the understanding of language to a place where a text, particularly the Bible, can be read and viewed with binding authorial intent... Through his study of the philosophy of language, Vanhoozer has found great potential in the work of Austin and Searle to overcome the dichotomy of personal-propositional revelation... Vanhoozer presents the Bible preeminently as the collection of God’s speech acts. God as a communicative agent and Scripture as the reliable and authoritative source of the recordings of his speech acts is the source from which a properly biblical hermeneutic comes
Elusive integration of 3-in-1: Seemingly missing from the articulation into distinctive speech acts however is consideration of the manner in which they are integrated into a singular Word of God whose comprehension is only feasible to a limited degree -- even through any threefold articulation. Hence the acclaimed mystery of the Trinity -- too readily misinterpreted through conventional categories and the controversies to which they give rise.
A valuable clarification in this respect is the extensive analysis of how Dante Alighieri describes the three rings (tre giri) of the Holy Trinity in Paradiso 33 of the Divine Comedy (Arielle Saiber and Aba Mbirika, The Three Giri of Paradiso XXXIII, Dante Studies, 131, 2013, pp. 237-272).
This remarkable interdisciplinary exploration combines insights from speculative theology, geometry and knot theory. It is of particular relevance to the argument here, especially in the light of its commentary on the threefold set of Borromean rings -- to whom others have referred (Vlad Alexeev, Borromean Rings, Impossible World; Symbols of the Holy Trinity, Holy Trinity Amblecote; Borromean Rings, ThisIsChurch.com). As a validation of the Islamic perspective challenging any triadic articulation, the 3-ring set of Borromean rings cannot be disassembled.
There is clearly significance to the use of that configuration as the logo of the International Mathematical Union, potentially from the perspective of theology (Mathematical Theology: Future Science of Confidence in Belief, 2011; The-O ring: Theory, Theorem, Theology, Theosophy? 2014).
| Borromean rings (and their misrepresentation) Reproduced from Engaging with Elusive Connectivity and Coherence (2018) | |||
| (3,3)-torus link (circles NOT bending to form the 3-link, see knot atlas) | Borromean rings (circles bending to be able to be woven together) | International Mathematical Union logo | Borromean rings formed by Möbius strips (animation) |
![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| Reproduced from The Three Giri of Paradiso XXXIII (2013) | Reproduced from Wikipedia | Video (mp4); Virtual reality (x3d; wrl) | |
As discussed separately, these questions help to frame what is meant by the elusive "unity" for which national, religious and world leaders so frequently appeal (Borromean challenge to comprehension of any trinity? 2018). Do they understand what might be meant by that? Is it too readily assumed that everyone understands its nature -- despite the allusive articulations of theologians and the elusive accounts of mystics? A case can be made for a mode of discourse respecting that subtlety (Beyond binary dialogue -- the subtle possibility of "Borromean intercourse"? 2023).
As separately discussed, it remains unclear what meaning enduring unity has in relation to the ecosystem and biodiversity (Paradoxes of Durable Peace, Heaven and a Sustainable Lifestyle, 2023). Does reference to holiness and holons avoid the question of how these are to be comprehended in practice? Of some relevance to such questions is the notion of "wholth" (Wholth as Sustaining Dynamic of Health and Wealth: cognitive dynamics sustaining the meta-pattern that connects, 2013; Encycling, enwholing and wholth, 2014). The term is a focus of a thesis by John C Samples (Wholth: a philosophy of religious education, Emmanuel School of Religion, 1972).
Rings, cycles and holes: The insights from the geometry of interlocking rings tends to distract from any related insights from the manner in which the rings may call for recognition of cycles -- cyclic processes of cognition. Additionally there is the neglected focus on the significance of the hole which any ring so obviously frames.
Ring geometry can be understood as indicative of a curious process of encycling, as discussed separately with respect to the quest for an imaginal episystemic container embodying self-reflexivity (Encycling Problematic Wickedness for Potential Humanity, 2014).
Understood as a metaphor borrowed from sport -- with a goal framed as a hole -- what has to be inserted where to satisfactorily transform the environment? What is the significance of the hole framed in the quest for a cyclic economy? As noted separately (Cognitive mystery of holes, lacunae and incompleteness, 2014; Cognitive mystery of holes, 2015). Of particular relevance is the remarkable exploration by Roberto Casati and Achille C. Varzi (Holes and Other Superficialities, 1994) -- with respect to the borderlines of metaphysics, everyday geometry, and the theory of perception (reviewed by Steven A. Gross, What's in a Hole? The Harvard Review of Philosophy, 1994).
The authors seek to answer two basic questions: Do holes really exist? And if so, what are they? As they indicate in an extensive entry on holes in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:
Hole representations -- no matter whether veridical -- appear to be commonplace in human cognition. Not only do people have the impression of seeing holes; they also form a corresponding concept, which is normally lexicalised as a noun in ordinary languages... Moreover, data from developmental psychology and the psychology of perception confirm that infants and adults are able to perceive, count, and track holes just as easily as they perceive, count, and track paradigm material objects such as cookies and tins... These facts do not prove that holes and material objects are on equal psychological footing, let alone on equal metaphysical footing. But they indicate that the concept of a hole is of significant salience in the common-sense picture of the world, specifically of the spatiotemporal world.
Especially curious in cognitive terms are the fascinating attractors constituted by the "holes" in the nether regions of genitalia -- given their universal role as fundamental drivers in human behaviour (and that of animals). That function can be understood as being as mysterious as any ring-framed spiritual trinity -- if not as a strange reflector of it. As is potentially the case with the spiritual trinity, it is the cyclic dynamics (and potential implication) which are fundamental to the attraction of the nether holes -- rather than any static focus.
Systemic correspondence between "upper" and "lower" trinitarian dynamics? The preceding points suggest the value of exploring how the trinity of expletives might be a perverse reflection of the articulation of that framing the Word of God. The question could then be how the set of expletives serve as indicators of incomprehension of the systemic implications of the 3-fold set of injunctions noted above -- of humans as the image of God.
Possibilities could be explored in relation to their frustration:
- "going forth and multiplying" -- transformed into unconstrained reproduction (as implied by "f*cking")
- "ruling over every living creature" -- transformed into the unquestionable quest for dominion and hegemony (implied by discriminatory expletives)
- appreciation unification of a higher, subtler order (of God) -- transformed into blasphemous invocation
With current recognition of human consumption as far beyond planetary capacity, one intriguing indication of such correspondence (with respect to the first two) is the argument of such as Arthur Kover (The Sublime and Consumer Behavior: consumption as defense against the infinite. Consumption Markets and Culture, 2, 1998, 1; Are the Oil Sands Sublime? 2014). Is the frustrated appreciation of any integrative (transcendental) "wholeness" the primary trigger for blasphemous invocation of a sense of how that might be named in a secular society?
It follows that the exploration of George Rossolatos is of particular value:
This paper addresses the scarcely scrutinized topic in the consumer culture literature regarding how a social actor consumes himself through speech acts. More specifically, by introducing a new type of speech act, viz. the taboo speech act, and by effectively differentiating it from expletives, slang, and swearing words and expressions, I outline how subjectivity appropriates and individuates its systemic underpinning as other or linguistic system (Saussure) and wall of language (Lacan) in linguistic acts of transgression. Taboo speech acts do not merely express emotions, such as anger and frustration. They also seek to contain a linguistic system as an ideational totality of acts of parole in a primus affectivus that is incumbent on the inverse sublimation of epithets and cultural symbols standing synecdochically in a pars pro toto relationship for the limits of what is culturally/linguistically sanctioned. The subject consumes/annihilates and institutes itself at the same time in taboo speech acts whose mission may not be fully accounted for through conversational pragmatics, insofar as they perform at a more foundational level a social ontological function. (Holy Shit: Taboo Speech Acts as Self Consumption Chinese Semiotic Studies, 13, 2017, 2)
Ambiguous connotations of "swearing" -- indicative of a "missing link"? As might be expected, the role of expletives -- as "challenging" speech acts -- has evoked particular attention in relation to speech act theory, most notably in the literature on swearing. Its problematic ambiguity can be seen as indicator of a form of link between the triadic configurations noted above.
Oath taking: The sense of identity and status associated with swearing an oath (and "swearing in") is variously described -- an act frequently considered fundamental to the solemn process of taking office or bearing witness in judicial procedures:
- First, we will see that to swear is to attest to the truth of a proposition. Further, it is to do it in a way which brings the status of the one swearing to the fore in a significant way. In general. of coursee. speech acts presuppose thai the agent has a status.... But in swearing, the status of the swearer is not just presupposed; it plays a role in the speech act. It offers a surety against against the swearer's carelessly or thoughtlessly swearing, The peculiarity of the act of swearing is the role that the status of the swearer plays. Finally. we will see that this peculiarity has a significance that sets speech acts like swearing and vowing off in a class importantly different from other speech acts. Solemn oaths risk status of the agent (Richard D. Parry, On Swearing, The Personalist, 57, 1976, 3)
- As an oath it is well suited to the application of speech act theory, which allows for interpretations with Gregory and/or any orthodox bishop as speaker. When further considered in light of other oaths as compositional models -- professional (e.g. Hippocratic), magisterial, imperial loyalty, biblical -- the poem’s scope expands beyond the "autobiographer" to encompass the episcopate and fourth-century culture more broadly. (Suzanne Abrams Rebillard The Speech Act of Swearing: Gregory of Nazianzus’s Oath... Journal of Early Christian Studies, 21, 2013, 2)
Affirmation of solidarity: The sense of solidarity and brotherhood/sisterhood is variously emphasized:
- Particular attention is given to the way in which the expletive fuck is used in two face threatening speech acts, direct complaints and refusals, and its contrasting function in the speech act of whingeing. The analysis focuses on the complex socio-pragmatic functions of fuck and its role as an indicator of membership in a specific community of practice. (Nicola Daly, et al, Expletives as solidarity signals in FTAs on the factory floor, Journal of Pragmatics, 36, 2004, 5)
- Swearing is a risky interactional activity but has also been shown to have great potential for fostering social cohesion and positive relations in professional communication. It is particularly interesting to observe in intercultural and multilingual team interactions, where on the one hand attitudes and practices around swearing are likely to differ and on the other, the need to foster positive relations is more pressing given that social cohesion in diverse teams tends to be lower (Carolin Debray, Swearing, identity and power in professional interaction, Journal of Pragmatics, 215, October 2023)
- Although swearing is considered as an offensive act, it frequently occurs in movies which represent an instance of everyday conversation. It is the use of language to express a spectrum of emotions such as anger, frustration and annoyance. It also infuses intimacy, solidarity and jocularity. (Mariam D. Saffah, Swearing in The Wolf of Wall Street: A Pragmatic Study, Education and Linguistics Research, 6, 2020, 2)
Swearing at: This process is the most obvious as an expression of frustration with circumstances, and with others held to be exacerbating them, and in framing scapegoats (as in any blame game). In some contexts it may feature as a curse (following the traditional practices of witchcraft -- "swearing out" in contrast with "swearing in"):
- Daniel McGinn: Should Leaders Ever Swear? (Harvard Business Review, 14 June 2010)
- Kate Neilson: Threats, swearing, bullying -- or acceptable banter? (HRM: Australian HR Institute, 5 March 2019)
- Holly McGurgan: What do you do when a supervisor curses at you? (Chron)
- Chloe Taylor: Swearing at work: when is disciplinary action justified? (HRD, 20 January 2015)
- Kris Boratyn: Drivers warned of huge fines for swearing behind the wheel (Daily Express, 23 August 2022)
- Are Verbal Abuse and Emotional Abuse Domestic Violence? (LifeLaw)
Given the entanglement between the solemn process of oath taking, variously reminiscent of a binding relation to a "transcendent" context, and the demeaning of subordinates and others, swearing could be seen as indicative of a form of missing link between the triadic configurations above .
Their implied framing of a (w)hole is suggestive of recognition of a "root" recognized metaphorically in the systemic process of root cause analysis (Nature of a "missing link" between capitalism and arsenalism: role of a "hole"? 2020).
Unspoken, unsayable and unsaid: There is considerable irony to the manner in which both triads evoke a need for extreme discretion. This may be most evident with respect to vocalizing the name of God as the originator of the Word or in apophatic theological discourse (Michael Sells, Mystical Language of Unsaying, 1994). The conventions of polite society and formal communication may obviously prohibit use of expletives.
The Nobel Prize in Literature for 2023 was awarded to the Norwegian author Jon Fosse, "for his innovative plays and prose which give voice to the unsayable".
It is therefore intriguing to consider how strategic issues may themselves be discussed and configured such as to avoid discourse deemed to be problematic (Global Strategic Implications of the "Unsaid", 2003; Question Avoidance, Evasion, Aversion and Phobia, 2006). Root cause analysis of the systemic challenge of climate change and resource issue may be subject to such constraint (Lipoproblems: Developing a Strategy Omitting a Key Problem, 2009). Current focus on the "training" of AI may reinforce such avoidance -- a danger of another kind.
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]



