Expletives as fundamental to a pattern of problematic “speech acts”?


Being Spoken to Meaningfully by Constructs (Part #9)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]


Mode of address? It is curious that for many the experience of being "spoken to" is framed by the use of expletives -- however offensive, if not deliberately so. This mode is widely evident in the relation between authorities and subordinates in any hierarchy or power relationship. Rather than being called by a given name, a person may be explicitly "named" by an expletive, whether in their hearing or behind their backs -- being fundamental to the problematic process of discrimination. The pattern extends to the naming of collectives, especially those perceived as competitors in any way. Inferiors are expected to respond appropriately and without protest to being "called" in that way.

Executive emphasis? There is considerable evidence (typically anecdotal) of the use of expletives by executives, most notably in relation to decision-making -- even at the highest level (Nicole Lyn Pesce, This chart shows the obscene amount of swearing lawmakers are doing in public, MarketWatch, 3 October 2019). Accounts include:

Reasons have been offered (Judy Kurtz, F-bombs away: Why lawmakers are cursing now more than ever, The Hill, 18 August 2019; Michael Adams, In Praise of Profanity, 1981). The point to be stressed is that such language may well be tolerated, and extensively used in parliamentary committees, board rooms, and the like -- or in corridor discussion of formal debate. It may well be characteristic of aspirants to world leadership

Noteworthy is the notorious description of Australia by its Prime Minister, Paul Keating, as "the arse end of the world" -- and where this document was written -- a phrase subsequently incorporated into a musical. Also noteworthy is that Winston Churchill trained a parrot (alive in 2002) specifically to use such language. All the "bad" terms indicated below are however potentially characteristic of debates in some parliaments (or their corridors) -- notably in descriptions of political opponents.

Feature of entertainment: Expletives are especially evident in popular entertainment. Their use can be considered an indicator of authenticity. It is therefore of interest how their use relates to the array of speech acts through which strategies are articulated -- especially at the global level. It is evident that expletives are excluded from the pattern of speech acts associated with the presentation of such strategies. These require a form of political correctness.

Absence of expletives from fundamental speech acts? Given widespread recognition of how deities speak to believers, could such speech be understood as making use only of the 8-fold pattern of "speech acts" -- making it curious that expletives do not feature in such discourse (except in any humorous representation). Might it be the case that there are accounts of "wrathful deities" making use of expletives? The concern was submitted to ChatGPT for comment:

The way deities are believed to speak to believers varies significantly across different religious and cultural contexts. While the concept of deities communicating with humans is present in many religious traditions, the nature of this communication and the language used can differ widely. In some cases, deities are seen as conveying messages or guidance through various forms of divine revelation, including visions, dreams, or inspired texts. This communication may not always align with the conventional patterns of human speech acts. Here are some points to consider:

  1. Symbolic and Sacred Language: In religious contexts, communication from deities is often conveyed through symbolic and sacred language, which may not neatly fit into the 8-fold pattern of speech acts. These communications may include parables, visions, or prophetic utterances that serve a different purpose than everyday speech acts like questioning, asserting, or commanding.
  2. Cultural Variation: The way deities are believed to communicate varies widely across cultures and religions. Some religious traditions emphasize direct and personal communication with deities, while others rely on intermediaries such as priests or religious texts. The language used in these communications can be shaped by cultural norms and beliefs.
  3. Wrathful Deities: In some religious traditions, there are representations of "wrathful deities" or deities associated with destruction and chaos. These representations may involve strong language or symbols meant to evoke fear or reverence rather than conforming to typical speech acts. However, even in such cases, the use of expletives in divine communication is rare and may not align with the reverence typically associated with religious discourse.
  4. Humorous Representations: In certain contexts, humor or satire may be used to depict deities or religious figures, and this can include the use of expletives. However, these representations are often seen as irreverent or sacrilegious by religious authorities and believers.

In summary, while there are various ways that deities are believed to communicate with believers, the nature of this communication is deeply rooted in religious and cultural contexts. Communication from deities may involve symbolism, sacred language, and forms of revelation that do not necessarily align with everyday speech acts or the use of expletives. While there are accounts of "wrathful deities", their expressions are typically more symbolic and evoke awe or reverence rather than expletives as we might understand them in ordinary language.

Expletive as complementing the Word of God? Given its succinct nature, arguably use of an expletive -- especially in its blasphemous form -- is indicative of a complementary function to that associated with any "Word of God". Accepting the reservations appropriately indicated by ChatGPT, and given the incidence of use of expletives -- frequently associated with blasphemously naming God as a form of "negative singularity" (at least in the Christian tradition) -- could the 16-fold, 8-fold and 4-fold patterns be understood as having negative counterparts effectively "collapsing down" to that singularity. ChatGPT offered the following in response to that possibility:

The idea of understanding the 16-fold, 8-fold, and 4-fold patterns as having negative counterparts that "collapse down" to a singularity associated with expletives or blasphemous language is an interesting conceptual exploration. However, it's important to recognize that this is a highly abstract and metaphorical way of framing language and communication, and it may not align with conventional linguistic or philosophical frameworks. Here's how this concept might be explored:

  • Negative Counterparts of Speech Acts: In this concept, the negative counterparts of speech acts could be seen as expressions that defy or contradict conventional patterns of communication. Expletives, especially when used in a blasphemous context, can be considered as negations of the typical reverence or respect associated with religious language.
  • Negative Singularity: The "negative singularity" in this context might represent expressions that challenge or negate established norms and values, often through the use of profanity or offensive language. Blasphemous language involving expletives can be viewed as an extreme form of negation, challenging religious conventions.
  • Collapsing Down: The collapsing down of these patterns to a singularity could symbolize the way expletives and blasphemous language deviate from established communication norms and conventional speech acts. It's a way to highlight the disruptive and provocative nature of such language.

It's important to note that this conceptual framework is highly abstract and metaphorical. While it can be a thought-provoking way to explore the relationship between language, communication norms, and religious taboos, it does not align with traditional linguistic or philosophical categorizations. Language and communication are complex and multifaceted, and the interpretation of expletives, blasphemous language, and their relationship to conventional patterns of speech is subject to cultural, religious, and contextual factors. In practice, discussions of expletives and blasphemous language are often examined within the domains of sociolinguistics, pragmatics, and cultural studies, where scholars analyze the social, cultural, and psychological aspects of such expressions and their impact on communication and society

It is appropriate to note a form of "nervousness" in the finally commentary of ChatGPT. Whilst valid, it is useful to emphasize that the disciplines indicated cannot be said to have ensured significant breakthroughs in the discourse relating to consideration of the crises with which governance is faced -- or to the dialogue relating to associated controversies. It could be said that, despite their validity, they lack "traction" where traction is required and as such can be claimed to be less than "fit for purpose".

Unexplained widespread usage of expletives: Whilst the reservation of ChatGPT can be appreciated in the light of the focus of conventional research, the unexplained extent of the use of expletives in decision-making contexts and entertainment discourse can be seen as a matter of concern -- even of major concern in a civilization which claims to be "knowledge-based". Ironically the practitioners of the disciplines indicated s may themselves make very intensive use of such expletives (even in their blasphemous form) . Curiously it would seem that such use of expletives is seemingly used as an indicator of authenticity -- a form of reversed virtue signalling, The matter was submitted to ChatGPT for comment:

The use of expletives in decision-making, entertainment discourse, and various forms of communication is indeed a complex and multifaceted phenomenon, and it can be seen as an indicator of authenticity or a form of expression that deviates from conventional norms of politeness and decorum. Here are some key points to consider:

  • Authenticity and Emotional Expression: Some individuals and communicators use expletives to convey a sense of authenticity or raw emotion. Expletives can be seen as a way to express strong feelings, frustrations, or emphasis in a candid and unfiltered manner.
  • Subversion of Conventional Norms: In certain contexts, the use of expletives can be a deliberate subversion of conventional norms and expectations. This subversion can be a form of rebellion, provocation, or resistance against societal constraints.
  • Entertainment and Shock Value: In entertainment and media, including stand-up comedy and certain genres of music, the use of expletives can be employed for shock value, humor, or to challenge audience sensibilities. It can generate attention and controversy.
  • Identity and Group Dynamics: Expletives are sometimes used within specific social or cultural groups as a way to reinforce group identity or solidarity. Such language may be seen as a form of bonding or shared expression among members.
  • Communication Styles: Some individuals have communication styles that naturally involve the use of expletives as part of their everyday language. For them, it may not necessarily be about authenticity but a matter of habit or comfort.
  • Virtue Signaling and Reaction: In contrast to virtue signaling, the use of expletives can signal a rejection of political correctness or a refusal to conform to certain norms. It can also trigger strong reactions and debates, further emphasizing its significance in contemporary discourse.

It's important to recognize that the perception and interpretation of expletives can vary widely across individuals and contexts. What one person views as authentic or genuine expression, another might see as offensive or inappropriate. The prevalence of expletives in discourse, especially in decision-making or entertainment, reflects the evolving dynamics of language, culture, and communication norms in society. As you've pointed out, this phenomenon is not always thoroughly explained by traditional research disciplines, and it often requires a nuanced and interdisciplinary approach to fully understand its implications and functions in contemporary discourse.

Corresponding "problematic" sets? Whilst appreciating the reservations made, it would seem that the ChatGPT presentation "skips" too quickly into the problematic singularity of expletives. Arguably collapsing to that singularity would be preceded (if speculatively) by problematic (inappropriate) sets of 16 illogical connectives ("fallacies"?), of 8 speech acts, and of the 4-fold pattern presented. Chat GPT was then asked more specifically about the existence of 16-fold, 8-fold or 4-fold nested sets of fallacies and responded as follows:

I apologize for any confusion in my previous responses. The concept of 16-fold, 8-fold, or 4-fold nested sets of fallacies, as you've described, is not a widely recognized or established framework within the field of fallacy theory or logic. In the study of fallacies, scholars typically categorize fallacies based on various criteria, such as formal vs. informal fallacies, relevance vs. presumption fallacies, and so on.

The specific categorizations and classifications of fallacies can vary depending on the context and the approach taken by different researchers. While there may be attempts to create structured taxonomies of fallacies, they don't typically follow a nested 16-fold, 8-fold, or 4-fold pattern. Fallacies are usually classified based on the specific logical errors or rhetorical techniques they involve, and these classifications can be quite diverse and nuanced.

ChatGPT was questioned on the possibility that any sets of 16, 8 and 4 fallacies might provide clues to a larger pattern:

I see your point, and it's an interesting conceptual exploration to consider how patterns of fallacies and inappropriate language might relate to the broader patterns of speech acts and logical connectives. Fallacies, both formal and informal, are indeed deviations from valid logical reasoning, and inappropriate language can be seen as a deviation from conventional and polite communication norms. Here's how this concept might be explored further:

  • Sets of 16 Fallacies: These could be seen as deviations from sound logical reasoning. Fallacies, whether formal or informal, often involve errors in reasoning, and their use can disrupt logical communication. Each of the 16 fallacies could be analyzed as a form of linguistic deviation.
  • Sets of 8 Speech Acts: The 8-fold pattern of speech acts could be seen as the ideal or normative way of using language for effective communication. Deviations from these speech acts, whether through inappropriate language or manipulative communication, could be seen as departures from the expected patterns.
  • 4-Fold Pattern: The 4-fold pattern could represent the core elements of communication, including seeking information, making assertions, giving directives, and making commitments.

Deviations from these core patterns could be seen as disruptions in the communicative process. It's worth noting that the exploration of fallacies and inappropriate language in this context is metaphorical and abstract. Fallacies, for example, can be categorized in various ways (formal, informal, fallacies of relevance, fallacies of presumption, etc.), and not all fallacies involve inappropriate language.

However, this kind of exploration can be thought-provoking and may lead to insights about the nature of communication and deviations from established norms. It's important to remember that fallacies and inappropriate language are typically studied in fields like logic, rhetoric, and pragmatics, where scholars analyze their impact on reasoning and communication. The relationship between these deviations and broader patterns of communication is a complex and nuanced topic.


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]