Systemic challenge: opportunities (hopes) vs threats (fears)


Systemic Crises as Keys to Systemic Remedies (Part #7)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Links: To-K | Refs ]


This approach is not about "finance" and "profit" as conventionally understood but:

  • how best to understand the elusive nature of "confidence" and "benefits" in relation to social organization and development -- in a turbulent environment in which there are indicators of various possible imminent crises
  • recognizing that overdefinition of confidence and benefits and their reification and materialization (as through monetary and other tokens) distorts and oversimplifies their real significance -- for sustainable confidence, benefit and development
  • where distortion and oversimplification of confidence and benefits are inappropriate to the fundamental processes with which they are associated -- and consequently engender new systemic crises

The question, in the face of uncertainty and the need to manage risk, is use of:

  • hope in framing the fruitful outcome of any initiative
  • cultivating credibility and building confidence
  • information in articulating possibilities, challenges and potential threats
  • openness and confidentiality (Orrin E Klapp, Opening and Closing: strategies of information adaptation in society, 1978)
  • recognizing and constraining excesses which engender other challenges

These considerations apply with respect to a range of potential system crises and the hopes that people engage with them. Of special relevance at this time is the framing of any alternative to discredited approaches -- given the tendency towards binary logic and triumphalism, and despite the argument of Madeleine Bunting (Faith, Belief, Trust: this economic orthodoxy was built on superstition, The Guardian, 6 October 2008):

We are now witnessing the collapse of this absurd economic orthodoxy that has dominated politics for nearly 30 years. Its triumphalist arrogance, its insistence on orthodoxy, has been comparable to Soviet communism in its scale. For two decades, we've been told "Tina" -- "There is no alternative".

Economists talk of trust, belief, faith; we now understand that all along neoliberal capitalism was a form of mythology. That's why the triumphalism was necessary -- you could not afford to have anyone challenge the system or we might all realise we were gawping at the emperor's nakedness. Rowan Williams was right to quote Marx, that "unbridled capitalism becomes a kind of mythology, ascribing reality, power and agency to things that have no life in themselves". Richard Dawkins should be critiquing this superstitious belief system.

Whilst "TINA" may have been discredited, there is huge potential for a backlash of "TINATTA": There Is No Alternative To The Alternative. It is the need for a binary, triumphalist pattern of arrogance that requires attention.


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Links: To-K | Refs ]

Subjects: Resourcefulness · Systems