Information warfare as predominant feature of future civilization


Tank Warfare Challenges for Global Governance (Part #6)


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]


The possibility of information warfare, in contrast to other modes, has been an early theme evoked by Heiner Benking (A Humane Information Society or Information War? Reflections about societies, cultures, human potentials and tools such as: filters, brokers, agents, knowbots, and maps, Benjamin Franklin Institute of Global Education, 1998). Given the framing offered by tank warfare as a metaphor, of relevance is whether this constitutes an unfruitful framing of the information warfare of the future (Imran Shamsunahar, Are Tanks as Obsolete as Battleships? The National Interest, 15 October 2017). The latter commentary stresses their psychological value in addition to their technical value. It is however a detailed assessment of their strategic value which can be fruitfully read with respect to the relevance of the variety of tanks considered above (Michael B. Kim, The Uncertain Role of the Tank in Modern War: lessons from the Israeli experience in hybrid warfare. The Land Warfare Papers (Association of the United States Army), 109, 2016).

A fundamental strategic question is whether any desirable global govenance "breakthrough" can now be appropriately compared to the historic role of the array of 378 tanks in the successful attack on the Hindenburg Line at Cambrai in 1918, heralding the end of World War I. Is the current strategic focus on "red lines" with respect to virtual wars -- and in anticipation of World War III -- to be compared with deprecated lines of defence, such as the Maginot Line? (Review of the Range of Virtual Wars: strategic comparison with the global war against terrorism, 2005). Seemingly strategic thinking continues to follow that pattern (Tank Wars Are Coming: how the U.S. Army plans to fight Russia or China, The National Interest, 9 May 2019).

Information warfare is readily recognized as characteristic of increasingly surreal conditions (Surreal nature of current global governance as experienced, 2016). The challenge for land-bound tanks is whether "hybrid warfare" involves other dimensions. There is a further irony in that the main battle tank considered in the review of Israeli experience has been named the Merkava since the 1970s. This derives its symbolic significance from the Judaic mystical tradition regarding a multi-dimensional equivalent of some relevance to this argument (Framing Global Transformation through the Polyhedral Merkabah: neglected implicit cognitive cycles in viable complex systems, 2017).

Memetic warfare: Could the highly problematic dynamics of society now be explored in terms of memetic warfare -- a form of virtual tank warfare in the noosphere, especially given the alternative terms for conventional tank warfare, namely armoured warfare and mechanised warfare? Is the use of fake news to be compared to use of decoy flares as a countermesure?

Are the various tanks described above to be recognized as variously cognitively "armoured" against their environments (as a form of protection and to facilitate aggressive encroachment)? More problematic is whether in doing so the thinking cultivated could be challenged as primarily mechanistic.

As clarified by the range of references, memetic warfare is now recognized as central to noopolitics:

It has been noted that memes and social networks have become weaponised, while many governments seem ill-equipped to understand the new reality of information warfare. The question is how will who fight the variety of disinformation and propaganda in the future (Varieties of Fake News and Misrepresentation, 2019)? It is in this context that Michael R. McBride asks Why the US Government Spent Millions Trying to Weaponize Memes (Medium, 5 July 2017).

According to Jacob Siegel, in functioning like the IEDs of information warfare, memes are: natural tools of an insurgency; great for blowing things up, but likely to sabotage the desired effects when handled by the larger actor in an asymmetric conflict. This is clearly an insight to be borne in mind in a period of rising social unrest and populism -- and the emergence of other kinds of tank, as argued above.

Western secret services are alleged to be perfecting clandestine tools which are designed to weaken countries like viruses weaken bodies, according to the head of Russian foreign intelligence, arguing that this kind of warfare is currently used in Venezuela.(Venezuela the latest victim of West's 'virus-like' black ops – Russian intel chief, RT, 18 June 2019)

The nature of memetic warfare was previously considered in terms of Conceptual defence systems and memetic warfare within a larger context of some relevance to this argument (Missiles, Missives, Missions and Memetic Warfare: navigation of strategic interfaces in multidimensional knowledge space, 2001).

Complicity of think tanks in questionable processes: The ranking provided by Global Go To Think Tank Report (2019) of 8,248 think tanks avoids the fundamental issue of the often highly problematic relations between them. They are effectively engaged in a form of tank warfare between each other (as representatives of different "sides") and against segments of the populations in which they are variously embedded -- dubiously funded by vested interests.

With respect to the latter especially, a commentary on the dynamics has been periodically provided by George Monbiot (Secretive thinktanks are crushing our democracy, The Guardian, 12 September 2011; How corporate dark money is taking power on both sides of the Atlantic, The Guardian, 2 February 2017; The educational charities that do PR for the rightwing ultra-rich, The Guardian, 18 February 2013). A complementary perspective is offered by Hopi Sen (How I learned to stop being bitter and love the thinktanks, The Guardian, 7 November 2012; Jamie Whyte, Hard to believe, I know, but: George Monbiot is wrong, Institute of Economic Affairs, 18 May 2017).

From noopolitics to "noo-warfare"? As presented by Wikipedia, noopolitics is an information strategy of manipulating international processes through forming in the general public a positive or negative attitude by means of mass media. The aim is to reframe external or internal policy (of a state or block of states) such as to create a positive or negative image of ideas and promulgated moral values .

As discussed separately (Noopolitics and memetic warfare within the noosphere, 2014), although Realpolitik is commonly equated with hard power, and seemingly Noopolitik with soft power, both are broader in their embodiment of a form of organization. Specifically, Realpolitik is not limited to hard power and coercion, but embodies a hierarchical form of organization. Likewise, Noopolitik is not limited to reliance on knowledge and soft power, but embodies a networked form of organization.

Think tanks and infowar: There is no lack of references to think tanks and infowars:

The emphasis is primarily on the role of think tanks in engaging with the think tanks of the "other side" and to a far lesser degree with how think tanks (supposedly "on the same side") engage competitively with each other. The current importance of memetic warfare is made apparent by the study by P. W. Singer and Emerson T. Brooking (LikeWar: The Weaponization of Social Media, 2018).


[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]