World problems and global strategies


Eliciting Patterns of Global Consensus via Tensional Integrity (Part #12)


[Parts: First | Prev | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | Refs ]


The interlinked data sets of the online Encyclopedia of World Problems and Human Potential profile thousands of perceived world problems and advocated global strategies. A continuing concern has been how this complexity is to be rendered comprehensible through innovative visualization. This has included spring maps -- with their potential relation to tensegrity -- as originally developed by Gerald de Jong using an earlier incarnation of the current Pretenst initiative noted above (Spring-maps: self-organizing network visualization, 2002; Displaying complexes of problems, strategies, values and organizations, 2001; Information Context for Biodiversity Conservation, INFO2000 Project 5052).

The obvious difficulty at this time is the level of radical global disagreement on problems -- matched by desperately righteous appeals for agreement ("consensus") on appropriate strategic responses. Whilst this systemic condition is recognized to a degree, little effort is made to move beyond deploring both the problems and the inadequacy of remedial responses -- a condition enabling every possible indulgence in blame games. Ironically these even extend to authoritative framing of those who disagree as inherently "evil" -- without any ability to encompass such perceptions, as provocatively argued (Encyclopedia of Evil Claims, Claimants, Counter-claims, and Sigils, 2016). This tendency can be considered as institutionalized to a degree in the language of parliamentary debate between government and opposition.

An unusual feature of the online Encyclopedia is the identification of a large number of feedback loops and cycles. There has long been recognition of how one problem can impact on another, or how one strategy can complement or undermine another. The Encyclopedia registers many relationships between perceived problems in complex networks. Such relationships may form chains or pathways linking many problems or strategies. Hidden in the data as presented is also the existence of chains that loop back on themselves to form loops, the focus of a specific effort to:

Develop, refine and seek to dynamically display the self-sustaining, interlocking loops of conservation issues and solutions. In the event that on-the-fly generation and visualisation of loops is feasible during web server access, such dynamic displays would be developed as a means of shifting the level of analysis beyond seemingly isolated environmental Problems and Strategies. The visualization tools would then be adapted to assist editorial and error detection processes. The key issue here is speed of detection and generation of loops. This will be explored as a combination of machine capacity, algorithm logic and display design. (Nadia McLaren, Feedback Loop Analysis in the Encyclopedia Project, 2000).

It is however appropriate to note that there is currently no collection of systemically depicted problems which global governance is called upon to address -- where the emphasis is placed on the systemic depiction of their complexity. Ironically the nearest equivalents are elicited from that Encyclopedia as what amount to specific systems diagrams generated dynamically, as described and illustrated by Tomas Fülöpp (Loop Mining in the Encyclopedia of World Problems, Paper for the 17th International Futures Conference on Futures Studies Tackling Wicked Problems, 2015).

The systemic relationships between problems and strategies explored in the Encyclopedia initiative can be understood as anticipating the development of facilities to configure them on-the-fly in the form of tensegrity patterns -- as a means of eliciting coherence, comprehensibility and memorability. The challenge would appear to be one of "form-finding" as indicated above, namely interrelating the identified elements in coherently memorable forms, as suggested by polyhedral tensegrities. An obvious question is the polyhedra which might be (provocatively) elicited to that tend (Identifying Polyhedra Enabling Memorable Strategic Mapping, 2020). Especially intriguing is the manner in which complex networks might be woven into interlocking cycles -- as implied by traditional skills in basket weaving (Encycling Problematic Wickedness for Potential Humanity, 2014).

The principles of tensegrity enable incommensurable -- "non-negotiable" -- perceptions to be modelled as "struts". These are necessarily carefully to be separated from each other -- even when implying a degree of systemic cyclicity. Requisite connectivity (in cybernetic terms) is ensured by embedding such elements within an inherently flexible network of links as a pattern of systemic communication between stakeholders. The question is whether sustainability is enabled when an appropriate balance can be recognized between such contrasting elements in characterizing the dynamics of the global system. Tensegrity modelling, especially when self-organizing facilities are developed, offers a pattern language through which the quest for such balance can be explored (Transcending Psychosocial Polarization with Tensegrity, 2021). Artificial intelligence may prove to be a key to such exploration and configuration, circumventing the conventional focus on physical applications of tensegrity.

Any presentation of the relevance of tensegrity in terms of incompressibles ("struts") and flexibles ("links") can easily obscure the inherent dynamics of such forms -- specifically appreciated for their resilience in response to external stress and "shocks to the system". Such recognition contrasts with the quest for rigid models by which it is assumed that consensus and unity "should" be defined -- and can be imposed through the 3D/2D incongruity of global planning.

One speculative exercise to that end configured 30 "disabling" trends (global problems) in relation to 30 "remedial" trends (global strategies) as depicted below, reproduced from a separate discussion (Convergence of 30 Disabling Global Trends: mapping the social climate change engendering a perfect storm, 2012)

Representation of mutual reinforcement of systems of global trends
engendering together a hurricane-like vortex into which society is drawn
30 disabling global trends 30 remedial global trends
Mapping of 30 disabling global trends to form a vortex Mapping of 30 global trends to escape from a vortex

As previously demonstrated, a tensegrity icosidodecahedron could be used experimentally as a mapping device to interrelate such trends -- offering immediate access to relevant documents by clicking on nodes in the interactive display.


[Parts: First | Prev | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | Refs ]

Subjects: Strategy · Planetary Initiatives