Relevance of a polyhedral abacus to turbocharging SDGs?
Turbocharging SDGs by Activating Global Cycles in a 64-fold 3D Array (Part #12)
[Parts: First | Prev | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
Question to AI: The early role of the abacus was noted in this exchange. It continues to be appreciated in some contexts, notably because many calculations can be performed more speedily by abacus experts than with a modern calculator. Given the possibility explored in this exchange of associating cycles with polyhedra, is there a trace of any form of "polyhedral abacus" -- as might have featured in the reflections of Pythagoreans. With so-called "planetary boundaries" now primarily represented in 2D on "doughnuts", could you speculate on the value of using markers on polyhedral edges to indicate progress or failure with respect to strategic goals associated with cycles.
| ChatGPT 4o | Claude 3.5 |
The concept of a "polyhedral abacus" is quite intriguing, especially when exploring cycles and strategic goals in multidimensional space. While there is no historical evidence of such a device being used in classical times, the idea of marking progress or failure on polyhedral edges resonates with many contemporary efforts to visualize complex, interconnected systems in more than two dimensions. Speculating on its value brings forth several possibilities: Polyhedra and Cycles: Polyhedra, with their complex structures of vertices, edges, and faces, offer a rich framework for modeling cycles and processes that are inherently multidimensional. The use of edges on a polyhedral form could effectively represent transitions or transformations, such as phases of a project, progress towards strategic goals, or states in a system.
Planetary Boundaries and Cycles: The "doughnut" model (often associated with planetary boundaries or economic sustainability) is typically represented in 2D, focusing on overshooting ecological ceilings and shortfalls in social foundations. A polyhedral approach could extend this into 3D or higher dimensions, capturing the interaction between more variables and their potential cyclic dynamics.
Historical Reflections of Pythagorean Thought: Pythagoreans famously considered numbers and geometry to be fundamental to understanding reality, with the dodecahedron often associated with the cosmos. A polyhedral abacus, combining this geometric insight with the calculative powers of the abacus, could have appealed to them as a way to model not just static quantities but dynamic processes and cyclical systems. The geometry itself could reflect harmony, balance, and the ratios that governed natural phenomena in Pythagorean thinking.
Modern Speculation: Practical Use
Strategic Goals on Polyhedral Edges
In summary, a "polyhedral abacus" could serve as a rich metaphor and practical tool for visualizing complex, cyclical, and multidimensional systems. Using markers on polyhedral edges to indicate progress or failure with respect to strategic goals, especially in the context of planetary boundaries, would provide an innovative way to integrate dynamic systems thinking into decision-making frameworks. | Your question is intriguing and multifaceted, connecting historical computational tools with modern conceptual frameworks and visualization techniques. Let's explore these ideas step by step:
In conclusion, while there's no historical evidence of a polyhedral abacus, the concept of using polyhedral structures to represent and calculate complex, interconnected, cyclic processes is intriguing and potentially valuable in our modern context. It could offer a more nuanced, multidimensional approach to understanding and managing complex global challenges, bridging ancient mathematical insights with contemporary needs for holistic, systemic thinking. |
Question to AI: Using polyhedra edges for the placement of indicative markers is reminiscent of the extensive use of slider progress bars, most typically in relation to funding objectives. The Doomsday Clock of the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists is one such. A polyhedron would then enable the representation of an array of such indicators -- potentially of the degree of individual SDG achievement. Such an array would be an alternative to the bar charts generated by spreadsheets. On a polyhedron such markers would also be suggestive of "frozen cycles"
| ChatGPT 4o | Claude 3.5 |
Your comparison between polyhedral edges for placing markers and the common use of slider progress bars or indicators, such as the Doomsday Clock, is an insightful one. Representing such markers on a polyhedron could offer a richer, multidimensional view of progress toward complex global objectives, such as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Polyhedral Markers vs. Slider Bars: In contrast to linear slider progress bars, polyhedra allow multiple progress markers to be integrated into a single geometric form, each reflecting progress or regression across multiple goals or dimensions.
2. Doomsday Clock and Polyhedral Representation: The Doomsday Clock is a well-known symbolic device used to indicate how close humanity is to catastrophic global events, such as nuclear war or environmental collapse. Placing such a clock or array of progress indicators on a polyhedron would not only enhance its symbolism but also allow for the representation of multiple critical issues simultaneously.
Representation of SDG Achievement: Using polyhedra to map SDG progress offers several advantages over traditional bar charts and spreadsheets:
Polyhedra as an Alternative to Spreadsheets: Dynamic and Interactive Visualization: Spreadsheets typically present data in static, 2D formats. Polyhedra offer the potential for interactive, 3D visualization, where users can explore different edges, cycles, and connections between various goals or indicators. Such interactivity would provide a deeper understanding of how global issues are interconnected.
Polyhedral Progress Bars as Frozen Cycles: The idea of "frozen cycles" on polyhedra is especially powerful in the context of global challenges:
Visualizing Cyclical Dynamics with Polyhedra: Polyhedra are also well suited to representing the cyclical nature of processes such as the circular economy, planetary boundaries, and SDG interdependencies. Using a 3D polyhedron would help illustrate how different global cycles overlap, influence one another, and progress toward or away from equilibrium.
Practical Implications for Global Monitoring: The practical use of a polyhedral abacus for SDG monitoring or other global challenges would depend on how data is integrated into the model. Indicators would need to be updated in real-time, with markers dynamically adjusting along the polyhedral edges as new data becomes available.
In conclusion, using polyhedra to represent markers of progress or frozen cycles offers a visually and cognitively richer alternative to bar charts and other traditional methods. It aligns well with the complexity of global challenges, particularly in the context of SDGs and planetary boundaries, providing a multidimensional view of interdependent processes. This approach could lead to deeper insights into where intervention is needed or where progress has stalled, making it a powerful tool for strategic planning and monitoring. | Your observation draws an excellent parallel between familiar linear progress indicators and the potential for a more complex, multidimensional representation using polyhedra. This concept of "polyhedral progress indicators" is indeed a fascinating evolution of both traditional measurement tools and modern visualization techniques. Let's explore this idea further:
This concept of using polyhedra edges for progress indicators is a creative and potentially powerful way to represent complex, interrelated data. It combines the intuitive nature of simple progress bars with the complexity-handling capability of multidimensional models. As a tool for visualizing and understanding the intricate relationships between various global goals or indicators, it could offer new perspectives and insights, particularly valuable in our increasingly interconnected world where simple, linear representations often fall short of capturing the full complexity of global challenges. |
The possibility of a polyhedral configuration of slider bars to provide an integrated perspective on relative progress of the 16 SDGs calls for consideration of possible candidates. The Stella4D library offers the 16-edged faceted square antiprism, the square deltohedron, and the elongated square pyramid. The first is most "interesting" in offering a higher order of coherence for any SDG mapping. However variant forms with that same name (distinct from that presented by Stella4D) include tetrakis square antiprism, gyroelongated square bipyramid, heccaidecadeltahedron. The Stella4D variant is discussed and illustrated below
Question to AI: The 16-edged faceted square antiprism is of particular interest in that its dual has exactly the same configuration with 8 vertices. As a preliminary exercise would you be prepared to suggest which 4 edges are associated with each vertex -- given that each could be representative of one of the 16 SDGs (with the 17th suggested by the configuration as a whole). A preliminary mapping can then be done in Stella4D -- in anticipation of the addition of progress data
| ChatGPT 4o | Claude 3.5 |
Given the mapping of the 16 SDGs onto the 8 vertices of the faceted square antiprism, each vertex indeed connects 4 edges. The challenge would be to find a coherent way to associate each vertex with 4 SDGs. One way to conceptualize this could be by identifying thematic clusters of SDGs, and mapping them onto adjacent edges that converge on a particular vertex. One potential interpretation of the 8 vertices and their relation to the SDGs could be derived from a combination of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and the thematic breakdown of the SDGs themselves. For instance:
These clusters could be strategically placed in relation to one another on the faceted square antiprism by considering the thematic synergies and tensions between them, so that the edges between the vertices reflect these relationships. In this context, the faceted antiprism's structure, with 16 edges and 8 vertices, could represent 4 broad clusters (such as the ones above) where 4 SDGs meet at each vertex. Further reflection on how the MDGs evolved into the SDGs could help define which specific SDGs should be placed together on each vertex. For example, health and poverty reduction could be grouped at one vertex because of their inherent relationship. Once this mapping is conceptually clarified, you could introduce progress data to the edges (or "sliders") in Stella4D to visually represent the current state of each goal, and how the goals that converge at each vertex affect one another. This offers a powerful visual mnemonic for understanding systemic interconnections. | The 16-edged faceted square antiprism, also known as the tetrakis square antiprism, is indeed an interesting polyhedron for this purpose, especially given its self-dual nature. Let's map the 16 SDGs to the edges and associate 4 edges with each of the 8 vertices. This mapping will create a balanced representation where each vertex (representing a key area or theme) is connected to four SDGs. Here's a suggested mapping:
In this mapping:
This mapping allows for a balanced representation where each vertex represents a key thematic area, and the edges connecting these vertices represent the individual SDGs. The structure itself embodies the interconnected nature of the SDGs, with each goal (edge) contributing to multiple thematic areas (vertices). When implementing this in Stella4D, you can color-code the edges based on the SDGs they represent and potentially adjust the thickness or appearance of the edges to indicate progress. The vertices could be sized or colored to represent the overall progress in that thematic cluster. This setup provides a foundation for adding progress data, allowing for a visual representation of both individual SDG progress and the interconnected nature of sustainable development as a whole. |
Preliminary visual representation using faceted square antiprism as a conceptual modepurpose |
Although very willing to engage in a mappping of SDGs onto the "faceted square antiprism", the result generated by ChatGPT bore no relation to the Stella4D configuration. It recalled both the early effort of Heiner Benking in designing a Hyperlink Eco-Cube (Visual Access Strategies for Multi-Dimensional Objects and Issues, 1993) and the use of a design metaphor based on the Rubik Cube (Interplay of Sustainable Development Goals through Rubik Cube Variations, 2017; Harmonizing Dissonance via a Rubik's Cube Framework, 2024). The AI response by Claude was usefully focused, finally resulting in the mapping presented below.
Question to AI: However the structure of the faceted square antiprism is such that no two SDG-labelled edges can be associated with more than one vertex. This is a major constraint on any proposal
| Claude 3.5 |
You are correct that in this structure, no two edges can share more than one vertex. Let's revise the approach to respect this structural constraint. Given this constraint, here's a corrected mapping that ensures each edge (SDG) connects two unique vertices:
In this revised mapping:
This configuration respects the geometric constraints of the faceted square antiprism while still providing a meaningful representation of the SDGs. The structure naturally highlights the interconnected nature of the goals, with each vertex representing a point of intersection between four different SDGs. When implementing this in Stella4D:
This revised mapping maintains the integrity of the polyhedron's structure while providing a visually intuitive representation of the SDGs and their interconnections. It allows for a clear visualization of progress and relationships between different sustainable development goals. Thank you again for catching this important structural detail. This correction ensures a more accurate and meaningful representation using the faceted square antiprism. |
Question to AI: Much appreciated, although it then renders elusive how each of the 8 vertexes is to be named
| Claude 3.5 |
The naming of vertices becomes more complex and less intuitive when we strictly adhere to the structural constraints of the faceted square antiprism. Let's approach this problem from a different angle, focusing on the relationships between the SDGs that each vertex connects. Given that each vertex connects four distinct SDGs, we can name each vertex based on a theme that emerges from its connected goals. Here's a possible approach:
This naming approach:
While these names are not as straightforward as in the previous attempt, they do capture the complexity and interrelationships of the SDGs. Each vertex now represents a unique intersection of four goals, emphasizing how different aspects of sustainable development are interconnected. In Stella4D visualization:
This approach acknowledges the complexity of the SDGs and their relationships, rather than trying to oversimplify them into distinct categories. It may require more explanation, but it also provides a richer, more nuanced representation of the SDG framework. |
Question to AI: How do your 8 proposed names relate to the original 8 Millennium Development Goals from which the SDGs emerged
| Claude 3.5 |
Your question brings an important historical perspective to our discussion. The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) were indeed the precursor to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and it's valuable to consider how our proposed vertex names relate to these original goals. Let's examine this relationship: The 8 Millennium Development Goals (2000-2015) were:
Now, let's look at how our proposed vertex names for the SDG-mapped faceted square antiprism relate to these MDGs:
Observations:
This comparison highlights how the SDGs, and consequently our vertex naming, represent an evolution and expansion of the MDGs. The naming reflects a more complex, interconnected approach to global development challenges, while still maintaining continuity with the core objectives of the original MDGs. |
Question to AI: The complexity of the faceted square antiprism poses a problem in mapping your suggestions to edges. Stella4D uses the [shared] numbering (vertexes followed by edges). Can you associate your suggestions with those numbers to facilitate the mapping process
| Claude 3.5 | ||
| I understand the need to align the suggestions with Stella4D's specific numbering system for the faceted square antiprism. Let's map our SDG assignments to these numbers, which will indeed facilitate the mapping process in Stella4D. Here's the association between the SDGs, the vertex numbers, and the edge numbers: | ||
Vertices:
| Edges (SDGs):
| Mapping to Stella4D numbering:
|
This mapping aligns our SDG assignments with Stella4D's numbering system for the faceted square antiprism. Each vertex is now associated with four specific SDGs, represented by the edge numbers in Stella4D's system. This should allow for a direct implementation in the software, facilitating the visualization process. When working in Stella4D, you can now:
This mapping preserves the interconnected nature of the SDGs while adhering to the specific structure of the faceted square antiprism as numbered in Stella4D. | ||
| Indicative mapping of 16 SDGs onto 16-edged faceted square antiprism (as suggested by Claude 3.5, edges colour-coded according to the SDG guidelines) | ||
| Side view with faces | Top view with faces hidden | Side view with edges coloured by great circle |
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| Animation and images produced with Stella4D | ||
With respect to any association of visual imagery of the operation of a "turbocharger", rendering transparent selected faces of the faceted square antiprism readily recalls the rotating blades of turbocharged engines.
As an imaginative trigger, it is intriguing to consider how the 8-vertexed faceted square antiprism might be embedded within the cubic frame of the 8-vertexed truncated tesseract. A dynamic possibility is presented below.
| Speculative turbocharging of SDGs: embedding of rotating faceted square antiprism within truncated tesseract | |
| "Side" view | "Top" view |
![]() | ![]() |
[Parts: First | Prev | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
Subjects: Sustainable Development · Form





