Systemic Coherence of the UN's 17 SDGs as a Global Dream

Rather than merely an arbitrary outcome of political influence-peddling


Systemic Coherence of the UN's 17 SDGs as a Global Dream
Set of 17 4-dimensional polyhedra suggestive of higher dimensional coherence to the 17 SDGs
Radical recursivity of topological/geometrical implication
Six
References

[Parts: Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | Refs ]


The 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), as widely promoted by the United Nations, can be understood as the culmination of humanity's best effort to respond in a coherent manner to the longer-term challenges of global governance in this period. Together they are  hailed as an achievement for that reason, especially in the light of the lengthy negotiation between 193 countries that the articulation required.

The set of SDGs, whether collectively or individually, continues to evoke criticism. Of obvious concern is whether they will prove to be fit for purpose in the light of other trends which render their scheduled achievement by 2030 improbable (SDG Indicators, UN SDGs; Measuring Distance to the SDG Targets, OECD, March 2020). Will they prove to be as inadequate as the 8 Millennium Development Goals which they were designed to replace -- or Agenda 21 which constituted the precursor?

The focus here is not on such critiques but on whether the set of goals can indeed be considered systemically coherent, as might be necessary for sustainable global governance. Nor is it on the particular the concern as to whether the relationships between the goals have been appropriately recognized, designed and articulated to guide the processes of strategic governance with which the goals are associated.

The articulation of the 169 targets of those goals does not seemingly offer any sense of the pattern of goals in systemic terms -- if pattern there is -- and has attracted specific criticism, although evidence may emerge to the contrary (The 169 Commandments: the proposed sustainable development goals would be worse than useless, The Economist, 28 March 2015; David Tremblay, et al, Sustainable Development Goal Interactions: an analysis based on the five pillars of the 2030 agenda, Sustainable Development, 28, 2020. 6).

Of greater concern here is how a set of 17 goals can be considered coherent and memorable given that that number does not benefit from the assumed memorability, coherence and credibility of the 12-fold sets of goals that are so widely adopted (***). It is indeed a fact that there is no more understanding or interest in why any such set is itself coherent and memorable in that simpler case.

The distinctive exploration here follows from an unexplored assumption. The set of 17 SDGs can indeed be assumed to be systemically coherent -- despite affirmations to the contrary by those intimately involved in the process by which they were articulated. Such participation, and documentation of the process, does necessarily reinforce the sense that the outcome was effectively a compromise emerging from a conventional pattern of political horse-trading and influence-peddling. Subsequent efforts at institutional implementation also reinforce that conclusion.

The argument explored here is that global civilization is indeed "unconscious", as argued by John Ralston Saul (The Unconscious Civilization, 1995) and otherwise with respect to the collective unconscious by Carl Jung. In that condition it could then be assumed that the SDGs are best recognized as a collective dream of possibilities and potential -- much as with the famous assertion of Martin Luther King (I Have a Dream, 1963). However, as an inspiring dream, there is the fundamental question of how it is remembered -- despite the sense that it was indeed coherent. As with any dream, the sense of fundamental potential remains ,but the detail of how it might become reality remains elusive for civilization as a whole -- and may well tend to fade (Societal Learning and the Erosion of Collective Memory, 1980).

Somewhat ironically, one way to understand the SDGs as currently experienced is in the light of the so-call "Belgian compromise" in decision-making, as explored from a cybernetic perspective (Principia Cybernetica). Complex issues are settled by conceding something to every party concerned, through an agreement that is usually so complicated that nobody completely understands all its implications. In spite of the apparent inefficiency of these settlements, the compromises do work in practice, because they stop the existing conflicts, and thus allow life to go on without fights or obstructions.

This argument does not focus on the possibility explored in what follows, namely that there are largely unrecognized forces in play which enable forms of coherence essentially beyond conventional understanding. Social cycle theory currently focuses on cycles of 70 to 100 years (Kondratiev wave, Technology life cycle, Hegemonic stability theory). Less evident is their relevance to the rise and fall of empires of the past (Johan Galtung and Sohail Inayatullah, Macrohistory and Macrohistorians: perspectives on individual, social, and civilizational change, 1997; Sohail Inayatullah, Epistemes and the Long Term Future, Metafuture, 2002).

The process can also be explored in terms of enantiodromia,  namely the emergence of the unconscious opposite in the course of time from a cultural historical perspective (William Irwin Thompson, From Nation to Emanation: Planetary Culture and World Governance, 1982).

More relevant to this argument is the challenge to the comprehension of the forces in play, as argued by management cybernetician Stafford Beer (on Le Chatelier's Principle as applied to social systems):

Reformers, critics of institutions, consultants in innovation, people in short who "want to get something done", often fail to see this point. They cannot understand why their strictures, advice or demands do not result in effective change. They expect either to achieve a measure of success in their own terms or to be flung off the premises. But an ultra-stable system (like a social institution)... has no need to react in either of these ways. It specializes in equilibrial readjustment, which is to the observer a secret form of change requiring no actual alteration in the macro-systemic characteristics that he is trying to do something about." (The cybernetic cytoblast - management itself, Chairman's Address to the International Cybernetic Congress, September 1969)

Rather than any such obstructive counterforce, a reverse effect of significance to emergence and evolution could be hypothesized. This would be readily named as "angelic" -- engendering coherence -- in contrast to the "demonic" forces to which reference is now so frequently made at every level of society. The religious framework aside, these evoke hypotheses regarding psyschosocial dynamics of higher dimensionality than are conventionally recognized -- possibly commensurate with the explanations of reality by fundamental physics in terms of 10 to 26 extra dimensions. Any Gaia paradigm could well call for understanding in such terms. Is humanity effectivelhy constrained into coherence by unconscious systemic forces -- through a corollary to Beer's Le Chatelier's Principle?

As a "collective dream" however, there is the further charm to the possibility that its elusive elements -- as recalled in a waking mode -- invite "interpretation" much as is the practice of psychoanalysis. How might a psychoanalytic approach to global civilization interpret the SDG dream? Aspects of this understanding are explored separately (Dreamables, Deniables, Deliverables and Duende, 2015).

With respect to the 17 SDGs, the argument here is somewhat consistent with the exploration of the "dream" of the renowned theoretical physicist Wolfgang Pauli. Throughout his life Pauli was preoccupied with the question of why the fine-structure constant, a 

[Parts: Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | Refs ]