Requisite complementarity of governance modelscomprehensible through metaphor
From Zoom Organization to Zome Configuration and Dynamics (Part #4)
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]
It can be argued that the complexity of the global condition, and the variety of perspectives it engenders, call for comprehension of the situation through a complementary set of metaphors.
The reference above to the relevance of insights from flowers and nature in general is consistent with the arguments of Jozef Keulartz (Using Metaphors in Restoring Nature, Nature and Culture, 2. 2007, 1) and of Thomas Wiben Jensen and Linda Greve (Ecological Cognition and Metaphor, Metaphor and Symbol, 34, 2019, 1).
- Chris Cowan: Metaphors for Understanding Governance: the map is not the territory (Holocracy, 21 March 2018)
- Meg Leta Jones and Jason Millar: Hacking Metaphors in the Anticipatory Governance of Emerging Technology: The Case of Regulating Robots (The Oxford Handbook of Law, Regulation and Technology, 2017)
- Christopher Mackin: Political Metaphors and Workplace Governance (October, 2013)
- George Lakoff: Metaphor, Morality, and Politics (Social Research, 62, 1995, 2)
- Aaron Maniam: From Maps to Metaphors: governing (in) a world that doesn't exist (Public Innovators Network, 7 January 2016)
- Julia Slupska: War, Health and Ecosystem: generative metaphors in cybersecurity governance (Philosophy and Technology, April 2020)
- Z. Pablo: Metaphors in e-governance and their implications for participation: the case of the development gateway (ECIS, 2005)
- S. Sackmann: The Role of Metaphors in Organization Transformation (1989)
The argument can be presented otherwise:
- Complementary Metaphors of Discourse: towards transformative conferencing and dialogue (1984)
- Governance: from governing metaphors to governance through metaphor
- Metaphor as an Unexplored Catalytic Language for Global Governance (1993)
- Complementary Bullfighting Metaphors of Global Governance: challenge of asymmetric engagement (2009)
- Metaphorizing Dialogue to Enact a Flow Culture: transcending divisiveness by systematic embodiment of metaphor in discourse (2019)
- Alternating between Complementary Images of Coronavirus: requisite variety to enable viable strategic engagement (2020)
The question requiring clarification is how any such understanding relates to the possible models of global governance -- and especially the conditions under which each model may be especially relevant. As indicated above, approaches variously include use of:
- Checklist, as with the UN's earlier set of 8 Millennium Development Goals and its current major focus on the set of 17 Sustainable Development Goals. Both are remarkable in that no explanation has ever been offered regarding the number of goals selected, and no indications are offered regarding the functional and systemic relationships between the goals identified, or the actions they imply -- 169 having been articulated in the latter case. This method of ordering the preoccupations of governance invites critical comment in terms of its limitations and its potentially implied significance:
- Memorability of 17 Sustainable Development Goals with 169 tasks (2020)
- Functional dynamics of a 16-fold configuration of strategic goals (2019)
- Refining the Value of Sustainable Development Goals: in quest of the systemic coherence of global attractors (2017)
- Interplay of Sustainable Development Goals through Rubik Cube Variations: engaging otherwise with what people find meaningful (2017).
- Plan, typically in the form of a "global plan of action". This is potentially best understood in its planar 2D form as articulated through a table or a standard spreadsheet, posing the question as to how this relates to global challenges with their 3D implications, as can be variously argued:
- Spherical Accounting: using geometry to embody developmental integrity (2004)
- Adhering to God's Plan in a Global Society: serious problems framed by the Pope from a transfinite perspective, (2014).
- Functional Classification in an Integrative Matrix of Human Preoccupations (1982)
- Matrix Organization and Organizational Networks: Next Step in Inter-organizational Relationships (1971)
- Circle in 2D, complexified in the case of the doughnut model into concentric circles, and distinctively in the extensive references to governance of cycles. The circle of course features widely on logos in 2D implying a global (3D) preoccupation
- Eliciting Insight from Mandala-style Logos in 3D: interactive engagement with mandalas and yantras in virtual reality (2020)
- Sustainable Cycles of Policies: Crop Rotation as a Metaphor (1988)
- Mohammed Abubakr's circular periodic table is one alternative to the standard periodic table
- Torus in 3D, as implied by a doughnut and a sunflower -- living within / space habitat
- Helix, as with the triple, quadruple and quintuple models of innovation mentioned above. Use of a helix has been advocated as a means of ordering the periodic table of chemical elements. For example the Helix Chemica: the periodic spiral, 1937) is a graphical representation illustrating the relationship between the chemical and physical properties. In music, pitch space is often modeled with helices or double helices, most often extending out of a circle such as the circle of fifths, so as to represent octave equivalency. Although both may imply a spiral form, this is not necessarily immediately apparent:
- Spiral phyllotaxis. Seemingly unrelated to issues of governance, again, the periodic table of chemical elements may be proposed in spiral form,
- Braids: It appears to be questionable whether use of either helical or spiral forms takes account of the manner in which multiple helices or multiple spirals may weave together -- especially given the widespread comprehensibility of the weaving metaphor, and the traditional value of wampum in relation to governance, The mathematics of braid theory is potentially relevant in this respect:
- Interweaving Thematic Threads and Learning Pathways (2010).
- Governance as "juggling" -- Juggling as "governance": dynamics of braiding incommensurable insights for sustainable governance (2018)
- Quantum Wampum Essential to Navigating Ragnarok: thrival in crisis through embodying turbulent flow (2014)
- Global Coherence by Interrelating Disparate Strategic Patterns Dynamically: topological interweaving of 4-fold, 8-fold, 12-fold, 16-fold and 20-fold in 3D, (2019)
- Alternating between Complementary Conditions: dialogue, vision, conference, policy, network, community and lifestyle (1983)
- Sphere
- Spherical Configuration of Categories to reflect systemic patterns of environmental checks and balances (1994)
- Spherical Configuration of Interlocking Roundtables: Internet enhancement of global self-organization through patterns of dialogue (1998)
- Spherical Accounting: using geometry to embody developmental integrity (2004)
These metaphors variously rely on increasingly complex geometry, as can be otherwise clarified (Metaphorical Geometry in Quest of Globality -- in response to global governance challenges, 2009; Engaging with Globality through Cognitive Lines, Circlets, Crowns or Holes, 2009). Curiously such geometry has been variously embodied in ceremonial objects, much-valued for their symbolic implications (Engaging with Globality through Cognitive Crowns, 2009; Imagining local-global connectivity through innovative mace and vajra design, 2019).
| Comparison of governance models based on different geometries | ||||||
| Geometry | Depiction | Governance | Integration | Comprehensibility | Memorability | Symbolism |
| Points / Lines | Checklist | Declaration | Low | High | Low | Sceptre |
| Plane / Matrix | Plan | Spreadsheet | High | Relatively low | Low | Domain |
| Circle / Cycles | Doughnut | Roundtable/Ring | Relatively high? | Relatively high | Lower | Circlet/Tiara/Ring/Sash |
| Torus | Space habitat? | ? | Higher | Higher? | ? | Crown |
| Helix | "Spiral" stair? | ? | Higher | Lower? | Lower | "Spiral" stair |
| Spiral | "Black hole"? | Financial drain | Higher | Lower? | Lower | ? |
| Braid | Wampum | Wampum | Higher | Relatively high | Relatively high | Wampum |
| Sphere | Globe | Sphere of influence | Higher | Relatively high | Relatively high | Orb |
Of further relevance are the references to degrees of integration of an even higher order, as required in the organization of a hypothetical "global brain" as it might be enabled by artificial intelligence (Peter Russell, The Global Brain: speculations on the evolutionary leap to planetary consciousness, 1983; H. G. Wells, World Brain, 1938; Francis Heylighen, The Global Superorganism: an evolutionary-cybernetic model of the emerging network society, Social Evolution and History, 6, 2007).
The possibilities are especially relevant to governance given the reference to the studies of phyllotaxis by Alan Turing (cited above) and his own speculation with regard to some form of "hypercomputer" (Michael Brooks, Turing's Oracle: the computer that goes beyond logic, New Scientist, 16 July 2014).
Such possibilities can be variously explored in relation to the challenges of governance:
- Envisaging a Comprehensible Global Brain -- as a Playful Organ (2019)
- Corpus Callosum of the Global Brain? Locating the integrative function within the world wide web (2014)
- Imagining Order as Hypercomputing: operating an information engine through meta-analogy (2014)
- Superquestions for Supercomputers: avoiding terra flops from misguided dependence on teraflops? (2010)
- Beyond the Matrix: becoming other wise (2007)
- Simulating a Global Brain: using networks of international organizations, world problems, strategies, and values (2001)
Somewhat ironical, in the currently surreal framing of global governance, is the manner in which transcending models based on spherical geometry is framed through the popular slogans used by many leaders to make their country "great again". This could be seen as strangely associated with the use of rockets to get "off the planet" and into orbit -- whether to live in toroidal space habitats or/and to travel "elsewhere".
[Parts: First | Prev | Next | Last | All] [Gallery] [Links: To-K | From-K | From-Kx | Refs ]